Jinglebellsfrocks - I'm with you on this one. I was brought up to be a nominal CofE member. (I think Mum and Dad wanted some 'time to themselves' while we littlies were at Sunday school), I was confirmed, went along on Sundays etc..., then teenage activities got in the way. I was married in Church, because 'everyone' was in those days, went a few times, then more or less stopped. I flirted with the idea, even thinking of becoming Catholic a few years ago, then got my head sorted and more or less accepted that it's no more than a lovely story. HOWEVER ... I can't quite let it go ... not really sure why - fear maybe? The sensible side of me says there's nothing, the hopeful side says 'well, maybe'. I worked in a Catholic school till recently and, when my mum in law was gravely ill, likewise my own mum, my first thought when contacting work was to ask for prayers ....still not sure why.
Also, (I shall stop in a minute), having worked in a Catholic school, I must point out that it was noticeable that the Catholic members of staff who were actual card-carrying Catholics, absolutely sure in their beliefs, were the ones who accepted questioning from doubters like me. It was 'nominal' Catholics who were merely going along with the ethos of the school who didn't like questions.