Gransnet forums

Science/nature/environment

We shouldn't eat honey!

(115 Posts)
Chestnut Tue 31-Mar-26 15:43:04

Well I never knew this, but eating honey actually harms the eco system.

Google confirms it:
"Consuming honey, particularly commercially produced honey, can contribute to the decline of wild bee populations, largely because the honey industry drives a high demand for managed honey bees (Apis mellifera), which directly compete with wild, native bees for resources. While many people keep bees to "save the bees," conservation scientists argue that this often harms biodiversity because honey bees are agricultural livestock, not endangered wildlife."

There are over 270 species of bee in the UK and 24 types of bumble bee and they are endangered. So anyone who loves wild bees should try to save them rather than eating commercially produced honey.

Just to add, there is a programme on BBC iPlayer called 'My Garden of a Thousand Bees' which is absolutely amazing and deserves an award. Start watching and you won't be able to stop.

Basgetti Tue 31-Mar-26 22:48:22

Allsorts

I won't buy cheap honey, it's now being imported from China and sold for less than a pound a jar by a certain supermarket known for its cheap prices. I buy mine from a local supplier, as I have allergies and just have a little each day, a jar that costs me 10.00 lasts me for ages. Won't buy cheap meat either, you can imagine how animals are treated to produce it, I would rather eat less meat and bulk it out with lentils or mixed beans or go veggie. I look at trolleys full of processed food and boxes of cakes and crisps, such a waste of money that could be spent on good food.

TK Maxx often has lovely, organic honeys from Greece and Italy.

Catterygirl Tue 31-Mar-26 22:48:34

Allira, I don’t eat fruits unfortunately as they set off IBS but I eat a lemon every day as they don’t affect me negatively. I do eat every kind of vegetable and love them all.

Allira Tue 31-Mar-26 22:49:44

I'm sure we don't need sugar and sweet things.

Unfortunately, I like them, but don't take sugar in tea or coffee.

SueDonim Tue 31-Mar-26 23:21:36

The honey I’m using currently comes from beehives that sit on the Scottish mountainside all summer. When I open the jar, the scent of a Scottish hillside covered in gorse and heather comes flooding out - it’s glorious. I don’t use much honey, a jar a year at best, unless I bake with it. The beekeepers had 55kilos of honey last year - they were giving it to all and sundry!

nanna8 Tue 31-Mar-26 23:35:40

Horrible stuff with a yucky flavour but not too bad if you mix it with soy sauce.

vegansrock Wed 01-Apr-26 02:42:59

Maple syrup is a good substitute for honey in lots of recipes.

Chestnut Wed 01-Apr-26 10:09:54

Can I just bring up again the problems our wild native bees are having as mentioned in the OP.

I also found the following:
Native wild bees in the UK are in severe decline, with 35 bee species under threat of extinction and 13 species already lost. Around one-third of pollinator species have declined since 1980, with about a quarter of British wild bees showing long-term decline due to habitat loss, intensive farming, and pesticides.

So can you do anything to help our native bees? If you watch the programme My Garden of a Thousand Bees you'll see a magical place full of wild flowers and pieces of wood with holes (they love holes of course). It looks very much like I imagined a fairy garden as a child.

I just hope anyone with a garden can recreate that, even if just in a tiny corner of their garden.

Chestnut Wed 01-Apr-26 10:16:41

Here's more information about native bees, and you can even get a Bee Saver Kit.
Friends of the Earth The Bee Cause

mum2three Wed 01-Apr-26 10:22:03

Piffle! Destroying the countryside is what is harming the eco system. Schools need to teach about how nature works. I don't think this government understands how vital plants and trees are. Honey was used before we discovered sugar, it's a perfectly natural food.

twiglet77 Wed 01-Apr-26 10:40:02

I buy local honey (from a family in the next village). The only supermarket honey I’ve bought in the last decade or so is single-apiary honey from M&S.

Grantanow Wed 01-Apr-26 10:45:36

Isn't honey almost pure sugar?

Basgetti Wed 01-Apr-26 10:58:40

Yes but it has positive properties that refined sugar does not have.

dotpocka Wed 01-Apr-26 11:00:33

no it isnt
www.verywellhealth.com/honey-vs-sugar-11825483

Maremia Wed 01-Apr-26 11:16:22

People have known about the healing properties of honey for a long time.
Great for sore throats.

Maremia Wed 01-Apr-26 11:17:23

But yes, it has to be the proper types of organic honey mentioned in a few posts upthread.

Chestnut Wed 01-Apr-26 11:23:00

mum2three

Piffle! Destroying the countryside is what is harming the eco system. Schools need to teach about how nature works. I don't think this government understands how vital plants and trees are. Honey was used before we discovered sugar, it's a perfectly natural food.

You can still help the endangered native bees even if you eat honey.

Honey is harvested the same way silk is harvested from silkworms, using the insects as workers. So it's a natural food but farmed just like all our food, and that always has implications for the natural world.

suelld Wed 01-Apr-26 14:45:23

And if imported from New Zealand where the country is fast and the bees not particularly endangered?

suelld Wed 01-Apr-26 14:45:51

VAST not fast!

Borfmum Wed 01-Apr-26 14:52:33

We have one hive in our garden and consume the honey made by our own bee's. We support other pollinators by keeping our garden as natural as we possibly can. We don't mow the grass and encourage wild flowers rather than planting hybrids. We have bee hotels and keep small piles of rotting wood for all manner of small creatures.

Amandajs66 Wed 01-Apr-26 14:57:27

For this reason I haven't eaten honey for many years. Instead I make dandelion "honey"
My Granddaughter always asks for Nanas special honey. smile

Cossy Wed 01-Apr-26 15:01:34

vegansrock

Maple syrup is a good substitute for honey in lots of recipes.

Love both!

Cossy Wed 01-Apr-26 15:02:05

Borfmum

We have one hive in our garden and consume the honey made by our own bee's. We support other pollinators by keeping our garden as natural as we possibly can. We don't mow the grass and encourage wild flowers rather than planting hybrids. We have bee hotels and keep small piles of rotting wood for all manner of small creatures.

Sounds wonderful

Gwyllt Wed 01-Apr-26 15:20:15

Used to keep a small number of hives We now only have one hive and that was one that a wild swarm decided to move into. Occasionally we might take honey from a single frame. Even so the hive can become really light at the end of winter and in which case we will feed them. After all they are good pollinators

Chestnut Wed 01-Apr-26 15:25:36

suelld

And if imported from New Zealand where the country is fast and the bees not particularly endangered?

Bees native to New Zealand still need help. I found this:
While keeping honey bees is relatively easy, they’re not native to New Zealand - meaning that they’re in direct competition with our native bee species. None of the 28 species of bees native to the island produce honey, rendering them less profitable than the farmed honey bee, but they remain vital to New Zealand’s ecosystem. As many as 224 plant species depend on native bee species to pollinate them, but they can be disrupted by the more social and aggressive honey bee.

Robin202 Wed 01-Apr-26 15:26:36

I only buy locally produced honey to have with my wild foraged teas. Nettle is an excellent source of nutrients, add a few Cleavers and Dandelion - even better.