Gransnet forums

Site stuff

Absolute codswallop

(64 Posts)
jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 17:19:08

where's the science please

Links to some research papers would be greatly appreciated.

hmm

And quite angry actually. Bloody insulting.

absent Wed 04-Feb-15 00:04:35

It was only a short time ago that research was published showing that mental exercises, such as sudoku and crosswords, had no benefit to the brain but physical exercise had some.

I don't know anything about this woman's organisation. Does anyone else?

ninathenana Tue 03-Feb-15 23:33:27

The final sentence is the most ridiculous.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 23:28:56

You are obese, you stupid woman. You ate too much.

You have dementia, you idiot. You didn't buy fish oil/eat enough fruit and veg/take exercise.

Where will it stop?

Quite apart from that, you can't stop brains becoming diseased that easily.

As I said - codswallop. Total.

vegasmags Tue 03-Feb-15 23:28:51

These are my own tips for avoiding dementia - and if they don't do any good, they won't do any harm.

1 Regularly hide your handbag in the house and don't look for it until a couple of hours have passed. This will give your brain a wonderful workout as you struggle to remember where the hell you have put it.

2 Overspend and treat yourself as often as possible. Use your numerical skills to work out how you are going to pay off your credit card bill.

3 Use research to keep your slang up to date. Nothing is so aging as using phrases such as 'browned off'.

4 Try walking backwards to Christmas. This will exercise both your physical and mental capacities

5 If you want to avoid an awful future, please buy my book at once.

rosequartz Tue 03-Feb-15 23:25:47

Well, I eat fish but I don't go ballroom dancing!

Anya Tue 03-Feb-15 23:20:55

Can't see that myself and I've just re-read it in case I missed something.

Anya Tue 03-Feb-15 23:18:03

Does it really?

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 23:15:35

It borders on blaming the sufferer. Which is wrong.

Anya Tue 03-Feb-15 23:13:33

wink

durhamjen Tue 03-Feb-15 23:08:22

Agree, Anya. It's not as if we've been told to do anything outlandish.
I've always known that if I get dementia, it's because I do not eat fish!

Anya Tue 03-Feb-15 23:05:30

Or is it because most people know this already?

Anya Tue 03-Feb-15 22:58:16

FFS what's all the fuss about? It's only a few tips.

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 21:52:56

Maybe you can get June Andrews on her to explain her research methodology.

loopylou Tue 03-Feb-15 21:48:25

The first person I ever nursed who had dementia had been the first female barrister in England (I'm told), spoke 6 languages fluently and had been a mountaineer until well in to her 60's........
I don't stand a chance against her.....!

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Tue 03-Feb-15 21:38:03

Hello everyone, I'm sorry to see the post has caused such a stir - this absolutely wasn't our intention and, as the introduction indicates, it was written by an expert in the field so we put our trust in a published academic's research.

As the introduction states, these are tips as to what could make a difference later in life - none are harmful, but might well make a difference later down the line. In terms of the ballroom dancing point, from what I gather it's thought that the act of remembering the steps and responding to a partner's movements can help to postpone some dementia symptoms. I believe this is all based on research done at the University of Stirling by June and her colleagues.

annodomini Tue 03-Feb-15 21:01:27

Harold Wilson was, as one of his opponents memorably opined, 'too clever by half'. But he had Dementia.

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 20:46:23

I've reported myself - in the absence of knowing what else to do - to elicit some sort of response from GN to justify publishing such claptrap.

Ana Tue 03-Feb-15 20:36:10

I don't think they bother about what they put on here any more - GN is even more of an afterthought now than it ever was! hmm

rosesarered Tue 03-Feb-15 20:21:30

It's a random thing, striking the intelligent as well as anyone who, shall we say, is not?

rosesarered Tue 03-Feb-15 20:20:16

One of my Grandmothers, who lived to be about 95, never developed any kind of dementia and ; she took no excercise [ever] was overweight, didn't read and never had an intelligent thought in her life.

soontobe Tue 03-Feb-15 20:05:39

The second and third sentences in number 10 are hmm too.
If you eat well, drink well, and ballroom dance you are definitely having a good time! hmm. And if you get dementia you can carry on partying.

pompa Tue 03-Feb-15 20:03:49

The moral here is - Take anything you see on the internet as rubbish, until you can prove otherwise, whoever posts it.

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 19:57:00

Can I report a GN article to GN?

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 19:44:55

"10 things you can do today to stop dementia tomorrow"

You have made a statement there Gransnet. Can we have your word that you can guarantee that it is true. Please.

harrigran Tue 03-Feb-15 18:05:29

Gifted musicians and academics get dementia, it does not discriminate.