Gransnet forums

Site stuff

HQ is it really acceptable ....

(221 Posts)
suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 12:22:34

to post any story at all about Meghan and Harry no matter how lacking in evidence from whatever gutter source? Can they just be libelled by posts on GN because it’s open season on them and they therefore have no rights? Opinion is one thing but on here it’s now often inseparable from lies.

Eglantine21 Thu 23-Jan-20 16:51:22

Harry, not Garry. Oh dear......

Eglantine21 Thu 23-Jan-20 16:52:28

sparkii say d Prince Andrew was a paedophile. I’ve written that very badly...

Eglantine21 Thu 23-Jan-20 16:53:15

Id be very interested though Laura in why Gransnet thought it was ok

suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 17:00:35

Well craftys post has been deleted. That must be a great disappointment for those of you who think anything goes in the M and H pile on.

MawB Thu 23-Jan-20 17:09:53

Thread about a thread.

CBA to plough through the mud somebody is trying their best to rake up, it does nobody any credit.

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 17:12:20

If someone makes a contribution to a thread stating something that they believe to be true, can that really be called "lying"?

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 17:13:41

...and is it really worth making a heck of a fuss about?

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 17:16:01

I can't understand why the post by craftyone was deleted. It was incorrect, as following posts pointed out, but I wouldn't think it was exactly libellous. confused

Eglantine21 Thu 23-Jan-20 17:17:58

I think saying you believedsomething to be true is no defence in law.

Libel is a criminal offence.

LaraGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 23-Jan-20 17:18:39

We've had a look into it. That particular post was deleted as soon as we became aware of it. The confusion may have come about when a post alongside it was reported (presumably in error instead of the offensive one) so the GN response would have been about that one.

suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 17:23:04

lucy yes it is imo. Anyone could make up anything about anyone and simply say they believed it to be true. If we post something as a fact (not an opinion) which is very negative about someone and puts them in a bad light, we should at least do them the common courtesy of basing it on some source. What is happening with the current hate fest imo is that some posters are so desperate to believe anything bad about MM that they half hear/read something, employ no critical faculties whatsoever as to the possible veracity of the ‘fact’ and post away.
The stupid post about the ‘marriage’ to JG fits this bill as well. The idea that MM’s wonderful sister for starters wouldn’t have fed on that story if it were true is risible.

suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 17:28:25

Oh dear lucy what do you think libel means? It’s about lies that are potentially damaging.

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 17:30:27

Are you sure "the current hate fest" didn't turn a bit on craftyone there?

Anniebach Thu 23-Jan-20 17:36:14

I am relieved that post was deleted, i had thoughts of Gransnet hitting the headlines.

GagaJo Thu 23-Jan-20 17:40:41

That's strange, Annie Bach, because I had a post deleted for saying Tonald Drump was a rapist.

suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 17:44:10

craftys post was a rather egregious example lucy and fully merited criticism

icanhandthemback Thu 23-Jan-20 17:46:30

Eglantine21, Defamation (Libel or Slander) is not a criminal offence, it is a civil matter which why most normal people cannot afford to litigate about it.

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 17:48:24

Ok. Googled 'egregious'.

Well, as Meghan does seem to want to do voiceovers for film and tv, we had better make sure we get the programmes right, or we shall all be up in court for getting it wrong.

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 17:50:30

(Watch out craftyone !. No mistakes allowed round here.)

suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 17:57:49

Nice discussion to be had about ‘completely careless mistake I CBA to check because we all know she’s an evil witch’ and lying. Still libellous either way

lucywinter Thu 23-Jan-20 18:01:01

Eh?

phoenix Thu 23-Jan-20 18:07:59

Oh shucks, suzie has NOT given permission.

That's us told then.

suziewoozie Thu 23-Jan-20 18:12:32

Grow up phoenix pity you’ve nothing to contribute

lemongrove Thu 23-Jan-20 18:17:41

HQ....is it really acceptable that suziewoozie can say anything she fancies about other posters? ?

lemongrove Thu 23-Jan-20 18:23:14

We can all report libellous posts without setting up a whole thread to air a grievance btw.