Would you wear these?

No, no and - no.

Number 3

First two are rather frumpy, so no.3 for me.

Number 3 for me with flat shoes or ankle boots. I wear a very similar outfit myself sometimes (not the bag - I wish ?).

Number 3 is the only one that I might wear (with flatter shoes- loafers/ballet shoes/slim trainers). The trousers in number 2 are horrendous!

The jacket, scarf and jeans combo is very me, I mostly wear the jeans with ankle boots...

I’d wear 2 and 3 (with flats, don’t do heels).

Lucca

The dress in no1 is passable but the beret and scarf are dire.
Tunic in no.2 at a pinch but not with those awful trousers and shoes . No3 just a mess

No 2 is just ridiculous- no wonder she looks so aggressive!
The top could be just ok perhaps, two sizes smaller but not with those daft trousers.

No 1 dress looks a bit like one I wore in the 1990s but without all the odd accompaniments.

No 3 is just ok but needs a good tweak ?

No 3 and the trousers from no 2 for me. The tunic makes no 2 look a bit bulky and square shaped IMO.

No. 3 but with flats.

No.3 would look a lot better with dark navy jeans.
Even so, the turned-up collar and pushed-up sleeves on the jacket make her look like she's trying too hard.
Just my opinion of course!

No 3 is what I wear now , not keen on 2and 1 is positively dire!

I would wear the 1st one and 3rd one as i love jeans. Hate the middle outfit