Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

SAS:Rogue Heroes

(28 Posts)
tanith Sat 29-Oct-22 11:59:23

This new series starts tomorrow at 9pm on BBC1, I’m really looking forward to it. It’s about the formation of the SAS during WW2 and their exploits thereafter. Apparently it was shown to past and present members of the regiment and they approved it as very authentic.

Charleygirl5 Sat 29-Oct-22 12:02:56

Thanks, tanith, my ex was in the SAS so I may watch it. It should not keep me out of my bed for too long!

tanith Mon 31-Oct-22 07:36:30

What did you think Charleygirl? I’m not sure about it. Hopefully all will become clear in the next episode I’m going to try and not binge watch it.

cornergran Mon 31-Oct-22 07:43:19

Mr C enjoyed it. I had half an eye on my book.

Greyduster Mon 31-Oct-22 07:45:09

I watched it for about twenty minutes and then found myself nodding off. I’ll have to catch up on it. I read a book about David Stirling. If it’s anything like as interesting as that it will be a good series.

Sar53 Mon 31-Oct-22 08:12:09

We watched it but found the sound quality was poor. Very loud music but very quiet speaking, we had to turn the volume up quite a lot.
We found it interesting and will watch the rest of it.

grannydarkhair Mon 31-Oct-22 08:43:20

I’ve watched three episodes and really enjoyed them. The sound quality was fine to me, although I do always use sub-titles as well when they are available. I loved the music, it was a real mix of genres and periods.

MayBee70 Mon 31-Oct-22 15:53:34

I haven’t watched it yet but will because Jack O’Connel is patron of our local cinema and I watch everything he’s in. But last night, whilst channel hopping I started watching SAS Rogue Warriors which is a repeat of a 3 part series about the real people who started the SAS. I’m not keen on anything about war but I was transfixed by the programmes and I’m going to watch them properly with DH. The sheer bravery of those men is astounding. I don’t know when the series was originally made but it had several interviews with some of the men themselves. It really brings the horror of war home to you because the things they experienced and had to overcome were beyond belief.

Bodach Mon 31-Oct-22 16:10:09

Not overly impressed with the first episode. - complete with glamorous French Agent, who will doubtless reappear from time to time.
And I wonder why one of the main protagonists turns out to be an American. Couldn't be anything to do with selling the series to the US, could it?

Aveline Mon 31-Oct-22 16:13:30

I gave up after about 20 minutes.

luluaugust Mon 31-Oct-22 16:18:04

The music is to loud and overpowers everything.

grannydarkhair Wed 02-Nov-22 04:48:20

I watched the other three episodes and enjoyed them just as much as the first three. Worst Churchill portrayal I’ve ever seen on film but the rest of the cast, who were mostly unknown to me, were fine. Only “faces I really knew were Alfie Allen, Dominic West and Cesar Domboy. Jack O’Connell was superb as Paddy Mayne.
And I have no idea who Bodach is referring to, there was an American in the first episode for all of a few minutes, never saw him again.
David Stirling’s real life story after his capture is extraordinary, he ended up in Colditz due to his constant escape efforts.

MrsKen33 Wed 02-Nov-22 05:12:28

DH is watching it. I am just listening to the music and intrigued as to the choice.

FannyCornforth Wed 02-Nov-22 06:02:05

MayBee I knew Jack when he was at school at Saint Benedict in Derby. I used to work there (first in the mid 2000’s and again in my last role)

FannyCornforth Wed 02-Nov-22 06:02:43

I think that he’d be a really good Bond.

MayBee70 Wed 02-Nov-22 19:45:36

I think he was at the same theatre school in Nottingham that Samantha Morton went to.

Deedaa Wed 02-Nov-22 20:57:52

This is one of the times I wish my father in law was still alive. He was captured in the desert and spent the rest of the war as a prisoner of war but he had got friendly with David Stirling and stayed in touch with him for the rest of his life. I'd love to have got his opinion of the show.

FannyCornforth Thu 03-Nov-22 11:18:55

MayBee70

I think he was at the same theatre school in Nottingham that Samantha Morton went to.

He did his GCSEs at Saint Benedict

FannyCornforth Thu 03-Nov-22 11:21:04

And then he went to the Central Television Workshop in Nottingham, like you say MayBee smile

FannyCornforth Thu 03-Nov-22 11:22:27

He wasn’t exactly academic, to put it mildly, but he was full of charm.
He has done extremely well

Boz Thu 03-Nov-22 11:46:49

I really liked this prog. although not expecting to!
Excellent music choices (punk rock for rule breakers- good idea). It is filmed very stylishly which will sell it abroad. Well done BBC

MayBee70 Thu 03-Nov-22 11:50:39

I can imagine that. A proper cheeky chappie. Angelina Jolie (who’s underestimated as. director imo) cast him in Unbroken. He was brilliant in that. I think that theatre school had a lot of support from Prince Harry who did a lot of secret charity work at the time. I binge watched the series last night (got an awful cold and can’t move off the sofa). I don’t think I would have made much sense of it if I hadn’t watched the documentary first.and I understand why it has to point out that most of the events in the series did actually take place because they do seem so far fetched. I did want to like the series because of it’s links to Peaky Blinders so I’m glad it didn’t disappoint.

Boz Thu 03-Nov-22 13:01:15

On what channel is the documentary?

MayBee70 Thu 03-Nov-22 13:35:53

It was on BBC4. Now on iplayer.

glammagran Tue 08-Nov-22 02:18:00

Bing watched SAS Rogue Heroes over 6 days. I really liked it though hadn’t been expecting to.