Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

This city is ours. Bbc1

(59 Posts)
LucyAnna5 Tue 25-Mar-25 13:14:32

Until you’ve

LucyAnna5 Tue 25-Mar-25 13:14:04

Curlywhirly

I really enjoyed it (only watched the 1st episode). I agree that Nelson-Joyce is superb and perfectly cast. His girlfriend however, to me, is miscast. His character is a rough diamond and he has the looks of a really menacing thug, whereas his girlfriend could easily pass as a frumpy librarian (no offence to librarians, but you get my drift). I just can't see them as a couple.

I thought that at first, but wait tolyoy’ve watched further episodes…….

Visgir1 Tue 25-Mar-25 11:14:36

I got totally confused as to who was who? and struggled at times to understand the accent but will stick with it.
The highlight is definitely James Nelson - Joyce what a star in the making, although I looked him up he's been in a lot of high profile programmes.

Curlywhirly Tue 25-Mar-25 10:31:41

I really enjoyed it (only watched the 1st episode). I agree that Nelson-Joyce is superb and perfectly cast. His girlfriend however, to me, is miscast. His character is a rough diamond and he has the looks of a really menacing thug, whereas his girlfriend could easily pass as a frumpy librarian (no offence to librarians, but you get my drift). I just can't see them as a couple.

LucyAnna5 Tue 25-Mar-25 07:33:34

You’re right, dogsmother, it is a bit heavy duty. I’m on Ep 4 and enjoying it. As that review says, Nelson-Joyce is superb. The relationship between him and his girlfriend is interesting - and more to be revealed, clearly.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Mon 24-Mar-25 20:54:14

Here it is …

Anita Singh

“You’ve got to hand it to Sean Bean: he’s absolutely committed to his own accent. In This City Is Ours (BBC One), he plays the boss of a Liverpool crime family. The show has already been dubbed the Scouse Sopranos, and everyone else in the cast is either a real-life Scouser or has put effort into sounding like one. And then there’s Bean, happily sticking with his South Yorkshire brogue, which is explained in the first scene with a reference to Sheffield steel.

Anyway, of course this isn’t as good as The Sopranos, so let’s dispense with that comparison. But it’s cracking. I binged all eight episodes, and I’m not a fan of dramas about drugs and guns.

It’s a tense crime thriller of betrayals and shifting loyalties, but it’s also about family dynamics and the day-to-day of running a successful business when that business happens to be dealing in shipments of cocaine. This line of work buys nice houses, expensive garden furniture and shiny Range Rovers.

The glamorous WAGs acknowledge where the money comes from and turn a blind eye to the less salubrious aspects. Life can be fun: see the family christening where everyone gets dolled up and, a little surreally, perform a dance routine to House of Bamboo by Andy Williams. This isn’t a humourless drama.

Things have ticked along nicely with Ronnie Phelan (Bean) steering the ship, aided by sidekick Michael Kavanagh (James Nelson-Joyce). Trouble comes in the form of Ronnie’s son, Jamie (Jack McMullen), a loose cannon whose jealousy of Michael sparks a power struggle.

People begin to take sides; do they fall in with Jamie because he’s a Phelan, or stick with Michael, who knows what he’s doing? One of the things that makes this series so strong is the way that supporting players come into their own, from middle-ranking crew members (Mike Noble and Kevin Harvey are especially good) to the troubled wife (Derry Girls’ Saoirse-Monica Jackson).

Bean is the headline name but he’s not the star of the show. That honour goes to Nelson-Joyce, a magnetic actor whose striking features give him the look of a puma on the prowl. Some of the themes are a bit clichéd, but Nelson-Joyce’s performance cuts through and all of the characters behave like real human beings, helped by writer Stephen Butchard’s authentic dialogue.

You can swot up on your Scouse slang as you go: “lemo” is cocaine, a “straightener” is sorting out a dispute through an old-fashioned fight. It all builds to an operatic climax – unlike The Sopranos, there’s no doubt about who lives to fight another day.“

dogsmother Mon 24-Mar-25 20:52:59

We watched it, meant to put Protection on, but put the wrong channel and went with it. Went with it and wow really enjoyed it. Will probably wait until next t week for next episode as it is heavy duty and want to watch both sides which are at the same time and both a bit heavy duty.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Mon 24-Mar-25 20:51:23

I quite fancy it travelsafar. Might give it 2 penn’orth worth tomorrow.
I read a review in the Telegraph about it today which was highly favourable.
I’ll see if I can find it & cut and paste for anyone interested.

travelsafar Mon 24-Mar-25 19:53:50

New Sunday night series. I'm binge watching. It's complicated but very good. Some old faces, Sean Bean and Julie Graham and some new faces too. If you like gangster type programmes you probably enjoy this.