Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Bake Off - Goodbye to Prue

(46 Posts)
ferry23 Wed 21-Jan-26 19:00:59

So Prue has decided to stand down - suggestions for replacement?

If we're sticking with the male/female format I would go with either Delia or Nigella - though I doubt either of them would do it.

I expect Si King would be a popular choice. I'd love to see John Torode but he's not really known for his baking skills and probably too "chefy".

GrannyGravy13 Wed 21-Jan-26 19:04:13

James Martin is an accomplished pastry chef.

ixion Wed 21-Jan-26 19:20:50

Cherish Finden?

ferry23 Wed 21-Jan-26 19:27:09

ixion

Cherish Finden?

I think too professional for Bake Off. And after all her time on Professionals she'd be very intimidating. (Although I love her - my secret "Strictly" choice).

ixion Wed 21-Jan-26 19:47:19

Umm, I did wonder if she would be too exacting.

She was certainly very demanding on 'Bake Off: the Professionals', but very good, IIRC, with children on Junior Bake Off in its early days.

Jaxjacky Wed 21-Jan-26 20:00:16

Lorraine Pascale.

Pantglas2 Wed 21-Jan-26 20:03:04

Agreed Jax - mentioned her to my daughter earlier!

merlotgran Thu 22-Jan-26 08:37:19

It’s been confirmed that Nigella Lawson will take over from Prue.
👏👏👏

aggie Thu 22-Jan-26 08:44:06

Oh yuck , i will all be sidelong glances and fluttering eyelashes sigh !

ginny Thu 22-Jan-26 08:44:08

Oh no! Can’t stand all her fluttering eyelash business.

TerriBull Thu 22-Jan-26 08:48:02

I like Nigella, not that I disliked Prue. I forget to watch it must try to remember when she starts to present. I wish they'd do away with the Showcase section, impossibly difficult to construct exercises along the lines of the Leaning Tower of Pisa using 3 different types of cake. I prefer the simpler tasks such as a dozen uniform in size iced buns.

Lollin Thu 22-Jan-26 08:51:37

It could become the battle of the eyelashes and handshake with both trying to outdo the other one in smouldering. Had almost stopped watching now I can’t see a reason to watch.

BlueBelle Thu 22-Jan-26 08:52:17

Don’t watch it so shouldn’t comment but isn’t Prue about 90 looking 70

Bukkie Thu 22-Jan-26 09:03:00

I liked the lady who did some of the Celebrity episodes earlier in the year. I think she was called Caroline.

Foxtail Thu 22-Jan-26 09:55:03

Hopefull Nigella has stopped dipping her fingers into food then licking them followed by a big sigh when dressed in satin nightclothes. wink

merlotgran Thu 22-Jan-26 11:41:44

Caroline Waldegrave was Prue’s business partner back in the day.
They produced an excellent cook book together which was my ‘go to’ for many years

Visgir1 Thu 22-Jan-26 12:05:53

I think it's a good choice to have Nigella she going to bring some energy to a dull at times show.
Shame they can't loose Hollywood as well? Completely revamp the show.

Sarnia Thu 22-Jan-26 12:08:41

Nigella named as a frontrunner by my newspaper this morning.

ferry23 Thu 22-Jan-26 12:29:38

merlotgran

It’s been confirmed that Nigella Lawson will take over from Prue.
👏👏👏

Doesn't seem to be any confirmation anywhere?

Caroline Waldegrave looks to be s front runner - I thought she was good but not sure she fits the role in terms of viewer expectations in the long term.

ayse Thu 22-Jan-26 12:36:43

ferry23

merlotgran

It’s been confirmed that Nigella Lawson will take over from Prue.
👏👏👏

Doesn't seem to be any confirmation anywhere?

Caroline Waldegrave looks to be s front runner - I thought she was good but not sure she fits the role in terms of viewer expectations in the long term.

Apparently it’s been in The Sun according to UTube. I’m definitely not fond of Nigella so I doubt I’ll watch. To me she’s rather like marmite

Astitchintime Thu 22-Jan-26 13:54:26

Well, I’ll reserve judgment until the first episode of the next series but not being a Nigella fan I don’t think I’ll be bothering with the GBBO. Non of the co-hosts can hold a light to Mary Berry!

spabbygirl Thu 22-Jan-26 14:13:25

thank goodness she's gone, I didn't like her I found her terse, hideously bright colour clothes and not as good as Paul at feedback. she never had the warmth Mary had.
I'd love Si King but probably not 2 men, Nigella would be great but there's no confirmation yet. I think she was told to do that fluttery eyelash bit & over did it, hopefully she could be more natural. I think it needs someone natural not a professional chaffy type. I do agree Mary was superb.

Sarnia Thu 22-Jan-26 14:16:33

Personally I would like to see Nadiya Hussein who won Bake Off herself.

Annitona Thu 22-Jan-26 14:17:54

She is 86.

Ktsmum Thu 22-Jan-26 14:49:14

I read a while ago that Cherish is joining