Starts tonight on BBC4 at 19.30
LIMERICKS (April 2025 contd August 2026)
++Grandson of New Limerick (Son of New Limerick cont)
Starts tonight on BBC4 at 19.30
I watched with growing admiration for all the performers. Every single one of them was exceptionally talented or they would not have been in the programme.
I was intrigued by the flying fingers of the accordionist and the harmonica player who instrument sounded strangely like a violin at times.
The pianists were all so talented that it came down to whether I liked the piece they were playing rather than their expertise as to how much I enjoyed their playing. The same could be said for all the other players.
All the young musicians displayed complete control of their instruments whether brass, woodwind, strings or keyboard and the harmonica of course. I have no idea how the judges are going to choose.
It was wonderful and inspirational .
Thanks ixiom. I wasn't aware it's on. I really enjoy this competition.
I so want more of this - I felt frustrated by the small excerpts from each player - why not just broadcast the whole thing? - so many people who would love this.
I am going to the live final - which is on 15th October, so I will have to zip the lip for a few weeks before it is broadcast in November! I went to the last live final where two of the finalists were pianists and both played the same concerto - not ideal for the listener.
Proms have gone the same way - selected bit and compilations broadcast.
There are people around who can cope with a long classical music broadcast that might disrupt the schedule a bit! - it happens for sport.
The final of this incredible competition is on BBC2 on Sunday 1st November at 7pm on BBC2.
Three finalist, all young women, playing violin, saxophone and unusually, the recorder.
I have watched from the first heats and am in awe of their wonderful talent.
Thank you Luckygirl13 for no spoilers.
I love every one of the finalists and wish they could all win. The young recorder player is exceptionally talented and is showcasing an instrument that has generally had a bad press. I think it will be an eye opener for many people who only knew recorders from school! I will be watching on Sunday. Good luck to them all. They are a credit to youth and to music.
I have to say that I wish there had been room in the final for the percussion player. I’ve been a big fan of percussion since Jordan Ashman won Young Musician in 2022. He was amazing.
Greyduster
I have to say that I wish there had been room in the final for the percussion player. I’ve been a big fan of percussion since Jordan Ashman won Young Musician in 2022. He was amazing.
I liked Anna too. I thought she was very brave playing her own composition. At least her Dad has got his favourite saucepan back.
I wonder if a recorder player has ever reached the finals before? As you say it is usually seen as a starter instrument and is often left behind at Primary school. Alma gets some incredible sounds from it.
Last night we heard an ex Young Musician of the Year play the Rachmaninov 2nd at Nottingham Concert Hall - it was brilliant.
Samsara1
Last night we heard an ex Young Musician of the Year play the Rachmaninov 2nd at Nottingham Concert Hall - it was brilliant.
I would enjoy seeing a programme showing what has happened to past winners of this competition. The talent seems to get better with every passing year and they all seem such lovely, sensible young people.
I’ll never forget seeing a very young Freddie Kempf winning YMY playing Rachmaninov’s Second. Some years later we saw him live playing the same piece to a packed concert hall. It was spellbinding. He followed it up with the Balakirev Islamey. Couldn’t have chosen a more exciting encore.
The thing that impresses me about virtuoso percussion players is the way they have to “own the stage” and have so much equipment to feature that they are never still. It takes an amazing amount of energy to sustain a performance.
Well my goodness, wasn’t that something! I was blown away by all of them. Sophia was a worthy winner but you cannot take a single thing away from Alma and Kezia (who I was pleased to see had Jordan Ashman, a previous winner, on stage as one of her accompanists). I hope they all go far.
Brilliant performances by all musicians but Sophia was outstanding.
All 3 of these girls have a very bright future in the world of music. Sophia displayed a wider range of techniques than Kezia or Alma, or so the judges said.
A wonderful showcase of outstanding young musicians.
What amazed me is that the music that Kezia and Alma played was so avant gard that I wonder how you retain that sort of music in your head let alone play it. Consummate musicianship.
Phew ... I can unzip the lip now! I was at the final which actually happened weeks ago!
I watched it again last night and the TV coverage gives a different perspective with background info and close up detail.
It was a wonderful evening ..... I think these wonderful young people show such maturity and dedication but thankfully seem to be normal teenagers with friends and othe fun in their lives.
How the judges made their decision I have no idea!
I always find it so reassuring that there are young people whose ambitions aren’t directed to the world of pop music. Wonderful.
In my teens I was a virtuoso recorder player, treble/alto and sopranino. I always had to play at school concerts to “show there was more to the recorder than the usual descant”.
The violinist was a worthy winner, I felt - but then she played the best music!
It is wonderful that there are these young people, but it deeply troubles me that music is so weak in our state schools now that it is only those whose parents have the money or commitment to pay for tuition or drive their children to lessons and events who get to be a part of this.
So many children miss out and it feels fundamentally wrong to me.
I agree wholeheartedly. There is no funding for it in state schools and hasn’t been for a long time. That’s not likely to get any better now.
Luckygirl3 and Greyduster I agree with your comments about music tuition in schools.
We were frantic when GD's school closed without warning and were afraid that she would not be able to study music at A level..
I am in a position where I can afford the fees at a very good independent school who were happy to accept her.
I have been talking with Julian Lloyd-Webber about this and he has been taking up the cause on facebook, by letter and verbally. If you are interested in supporting this cause this is one of his posts: www.facebook.com/reel/3023753367958303
At a grass roots level we are lucky to still have a thriving brass band tradition. Bands like Grimethorpe, Black Dyke, Coventry and numerous others in the North and Midland have music training for youngsters 18 and under and dedicated youth bands which are over subscribed. This is the nearest many youngsters will get to becoming trained musicians and this is not Sunday afternoon bandstand music we are talking about, as anyone who has ever seen Grimethorpe and Blackdyke in concert and competition will know. Fledgling musicians, wherever we find them, continue to be nurtured.
The fledgling musicians who are nurtured are those whose parents can afford the lessons and the instruments and have the commitment to take their children to these activities. Children without these benefits miss out entirely as the music curriculum in schools is a pitiful thing and the visiting tutors need paying by the parents. If you are on benefits or have no understanding of the benefits of musical participation then your children miss out.
The benefits in terms of academic achievement, cooperation, behaviour, psychological well-being etc. are well researched.
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »Get our top conversations, latest advice, fantastic competitions, and more, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter here.