Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

🎶 BBC Young Musician of the Year 2026

(34 Posts)
ixion Sun 04-Oct-26 19:20:17

Starts tonight on BBC4 at 19.30

hollysteers Mon 02-Nov-26 10:44:48

Luckygirl3

The fledgling musicians who are nurtured are those whose parents can afford the lessons and the instruments and have the commitment to take their children to these activities. Children without these benefits miss out entirely as the music curriculum in schools is a pitiful thing and the visiting tutors need paying by the parents. If you are on benefits or have no understanding of the benefits of musical participation then your children miss out.

The benefits in terms of academic achievement, cooperation, behaviour, psychological well-being etc. are well researched.

Hear Hear👏

Greyduster Mon 02-Nov-26 12:03:10

This is why I was talking specifically about bands. Most bands, from the most prestigious to the bands found in many town encourage people of all ages - especially juniors - to join and to learn. Membership fees are low and most brass bands have instruments that are loaned to those who don’t have or can’t afford their own. Some bands will welcome complete beginners and tuition is provided. It’s a way in and worth exploring if a youngster is interested in playing a musical instrument, no matter what their station in life.

Humbertbear Mon 02-Nov-26 16:21:49

Sarnia

All 3 of these girls have a very bright future in the world of music. Sophia displayed a wider range of techniques than Kezia or Alma, or so the judges said.
A wonderful showcase of outstanding young musicians.

I think Sophia won because she played a piece that the judges knew and were therefore able to judge her performance more easily.

Greyduster Mon 02-Nov-26 17:52:58

I’d like to think there was a bit more to it than that.

Luckygirl3 Mon 02-Nov-26 21:18:43

I think she won because she was the whole package.... technical skills, musicality, interpretation, subtlety, good communication with orchestra and audience.
But the others too were superb.
The judges were of sufficient calibre this time to embrace new and unusual music especially as one of their numbe writes such music herself!
The saxophone and the recorder players had more limited choice of concertos. I enjoyed their choices. What extraordinary young people they really are.

Grandma70s Sun 08-Nov-26 17:47:12

Someone I know said they thought the programme did no service to classical music, because of the “tuneless” nature of so much of the “modern” music they play, citing particularly the recorder and saxophone pieces in the final. I don’t agree with him, but suspect many do.

All the finalists were brilliant. I wouldn’t have liked to choose, but luckily they won’t be competing with each other in their musical careers.

Greyduster Sun 08-Nov-26 18:15:14

I’ve listened to classical music practically all my life and I think it’s refreshing to hear something new and modern. We may not like it all, or be able to whistle it in the kitchen while waiting for the kettle to boil, but you have to be in awe of the young musicians who manage to keep it all in their heads and at their fingertips. They are brave, and they showcase their instruments in an amazing way and deserve every accolade for so doing.
The only composer I can’t bear is Philip Glass. I bought one of his CDs, listened to three tracks and threw it in the bin!

Luckygirl3 Mon 09-Nov-26 08:32:56

The modern music played by these finalists was truly fascinating. I was there and the audience was riveted to it.
Not long ago Britten was considered by some to be unlistenable and is now mainstream. Indeed Beethoven too was criticised to begin with.

We can listen to music for lots of different reasons: to be soothed, uplifted, intrigued.... each has their place and is for listening to at different times and in different moods.
The skill of these young people and their ability to communicate with the audience were nothing short of miraculous.