Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Feeding the birds

(60 Posts)
morethan2 Wed 28-Feb-18 17:37:52

I am so not a bird lover, really scared. Today I noticed some tiny little birds, think they may be blue tits scrabbling around my patio. So I worried they were hungry the only thing I’ve got that’s suitable is some fruit and nut mix. Ive put two lots out and it’s gone in half an hour. Is this safe for them? I don’t want to do more harm than good. I’m not going to the shop for birds seed it lethal here. Advice appreciated.

Nelliemoser Thu 01-Mar-18 12:24:15

Whitewave They are gorgeous little birds. All fluffed up to keep warm.

morethan2 Thu 01-Mar-18 12:25:49

Oh lovely photo whitewave I’ve never heard of Fielfaresnever mind seen one.

Tegan2 Thu 01-Mar-18 12:48:25

Was feeling disappointed as, having put out a piece of bread covered in suet, margarine, peanut butter and dog food, very few birds were taking an interest [except, of course, Mr Pigeon who was still eating the seed and lard that I made yesterday]. Then I looked out and there was a Jay feeding from it. I know they're quite common but I've only seen them a handful of times [if that].

Greyduster Thu 01-Mar-18 13:23:18

Handsome birds. We had some in our lane on Sunday; they are quite often seen alongside redwings but I haven't seen the latter this year. They come to this country to escape the cold weather in Scandinavia. They misjudged it badly this year!

Tegan2 Thu 01-Mar-18 14:05:21

I haven't seen any redwings for years...

Agus Thu 01-Mar-18 17:01:36

I made some fat ball mix today with peanuts, bird seed, sunflower seed,apple, grapes and cheese all ground up and mixed with some warmed up lard.

I ran out of feeders and found an old ladle and whisk which I stuffed the mix into and hung them from the trees. They are having a feast. I hang all feeders on tree branches, no problem with rats and our cat, although a good mouser, doesn’t bother the birds.

Tegan2 Thu 01-Mar-18 17:49:25

I didn't think to grind the seed up. I'll do that tomorrow. Had a shock when I thought the dog had eaten the lard I'd taken out of the freezer [paper and all] until I realised I'd moved it to a safer place. She used to be a terrible thief but now she's old she doesn't do it as much and I'm getting a bit complacent.

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 17:53:37

Psst has the snow stopped yet?

pbs.twimg.com/media/DXHtauOXcAEED3V?format=jpg

Elegran Thu 01-Mar-18 18:10:55

morethan I think that is a wagtail. Does it twitch its tail up and down as it walks/runs?

etheltbags1 Thu 01-Mar-18 20:13:09

Ive got 1 fieldfare. Yesterday he ate 3 apples and a tomato. He wont allow any blackbirds or robins. He ignores sparrows but hides when the crows come down. He chases anyone near his food. He is so cute but i wish he would let the others feed

morethan2 Fri 02-Mar-18 15:45:35

I think so Elegran but now I’ve got big gull like birds sweeping down so haven’t seen the little uns for a while. It’s snowing again here again so you’ve got to feel sorry for the poor little things. Arhh their back must be desperate. Oh yes I can see the tail wagging.thanks for the input.

Auntieflo Fri 02-Mar-18 16:36:44

Whitewave. thanks for the lovely picture of Fieldfares. There seem to be two threads running on Feed/ing the Birds, and I have just found your picture. We have flocks of them in the garden today, and I wasn't sure what they were, as I don't remember seeing them before, but you have confirmed it. They are scoffing the berries on our tree like billy-o.

Greyduster Fri 02-Mar-18 17:50:28

They were making the most of the remaining ornamental crabapples on the trees around our estate today. We have a lot of fruit trees and berried shrubs in the landscaping so there are rich pickings at the moment. As you say, large flocks of them this year. Not many redwings though. They are often seen together.

NanTheWiser Fri 02-Mar-18 18:13:17

My late husband used to feed the birds, but it led to rats, so sadly I don't feed them now. However, yesterday I had three Redwings right up near the patio doors, turning over any exposed leaf litter for insects, which made me feel rather guilty! As I don't eat bread (being a low-carber) I did find some ciabatta croutons (for my soup) which I crushed to crumbs, and also grated some rather ancient cheese, which I put on the patio. So far, only a crow and a wood pigeon have noticed them.
I am going to get a window feeder (as linked above), as I do love to see the birds, and hope the birds find it, and the rats don't!

NfkDumpling Fri 02-Mar-18 19:46:45

We have several hanging feeders with various seeds for the sparrows and other small birds. They’re quite picky and much gets dropped to be gobbled up by the wood pigeons and blackbirds etc. No rats luckily. We bought a couple of half coconuts filled with fat and seeds and refill them with melted lard with seeds in. The tits and robins love them.

The main thing which brings birds into the garden I think is having a little waterfall to our small pond. Running water is most important. It brought in a couple of redwing and a field fare today and we’re quite well into town.

Jalima1108 Fri 02-Mar-18 19:49:40

What about dried fruit ie currants, raisins, which look rather too dried to use in cakes? Would they be suitable for birds?

I did put a home-made gf loaf out the other day which was rather leaden - some seagulls came and demolished it in a few minutes. I'd rather feed the smaller birds but we have seed and fatballs out for them.

Tegan2 Fri 02-Mar-18 19:56:26

Be careful if any of you have dogs as raisins are poisonous to them. I prepared a veritable smorgasbord of delights for the birds today and they've hardly touched it. Ground seeds mixed into lard; peanut butter, grated cheese, eggshells [even put on a tiny bit of minced beef]. Annoyingly, DIL put some apple aside for me to bring home and I've forgotten it; I know the blackbirds would have wolfed that down.

Treebee Fri 02-Mar-18 20:00:26

DH threw some sliced apple out onto the snow today and we had two fieldfares eating them for a good part of the day. As said upthread they guarded their territory quite viciously.

Jalima1108 Fri 02-Mar-18 20:01:21

Well, I didn't know that, thanks for that tip Tegan

We don't have dogs now but we feel a bit sad as the birds seem to be ignoring our our offerings. I think there are a lot of neighbours feeding them.

We have some apples in the fridge, may put those out tomorrow if I can plough through the snow in the back garden.

Jalima1108 Fri 02-Mar-18 20:02:15

I know that blackbirds love grapes, they always pinch ours which grow on the vine.

Tegan2 Fri 02-Mar-18 20:04:51

Grapes are poisonous to dogs as well [although my last dogs stole a bunch, scoffed the lot and were perfectly ok!].

Jalima1108 Fri 02-Mar-18 20:08:42

apparently tomatoes are poisonous to dogs, I never knew that when my dog used to get the left-over spaghetti bolognaise (his favourite).

Tegan2 Fri 02-Mar-18 20:12:05

I didn't know that shock...

Jalima1108 Fri 02-Mar-18 20:28:31

I've just checked and apparently it is the stems and leaves of tomatoes and green tomatoes are unsafe for dogs.
He always seemed fine and what I didn't know I didn't worry about but they were were ripe tomatoes anway.

NfkDumpling Sun 04-Mar-18 22:02:21

I do wonder how dogs survived a generation ago. My parents trained their dogs with raisins as rewards and a chocolate treat or a grape or two wasn’t unknown. They loved them.