Gransnet forums

Books/book club

May book - The Wives of Los Alamos

(105 Posts)
LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 01-May-14 10:38:36

This month's book pick is The Wives of Los Alamos...

Told in the collective voices of the wives of the men who created the atom bomb, this is the bold and emotionally charged story of the women of Los Alamos.

Their average age was twenty-five. They came from Berkeley, Cambridge, Paris, London and Chicago - and arrived in New Mexico ready for adventure. But hope quickly turned to hardship in the desolate military town where everything was a secret; including what their husbands were doing at the lab.

If you received one of our free copies don't forget to leave your comments and questions below! We'll be sending questions off to TaraShea towards the end of May.

Deedaa Sun 04-May-14 20:23:54

I'm not minding the style at all. I haven't got very far yet but I think it's going to be riveting. What a situation to be in! It's like a witness protection programme on a huge scale.

chloe1984 Sun 04-May-14 21:18:58

I really enjoyed it even though the style of writing was a first for me. Ashamed to say that the subject matter was fairly new to me and I found it absorbing , loved the way the writer managed to convey so much in a few sentences of very descriptive writing.

merlotgran Mon 05-May-14 14:26:35

I've just started it and now I've got used to the writing style I'm finding it hard to put down.

pattieb Mon 05-May-14 14:54:53

Thanks for my copy of this unusual book
I have started it and my question is, what was the impetus to write this book and why did the author choose this writing style?

is there a link to your Phd ?

weather Mon 05-May-14 19:16:14

Half way through

Grandmanorm Mon 05-May-14 20:25:42

I have just finished it and found it a thoughtful book and in a style I have never read before.
I would never have chosen it but I learned a lot and enjoyed it.
As pattieb has asked, what promoted the author to write about this particular subject? Did she have family involved?

Rosannie Mon 05-May-14 22:58:05

I'm glad that the book arrived for the bank holiday weekend and I have had time to read it all on the same day. It was a compelling read, the style of writing and the organisation of the text was very usual but effective.
I will recommend it to my book group as I think the subject matter and the style of writing will generate a lot of discussion.

Wen Tue 06-May-14 13:54:03

Many thanks to Gransnet and Bloomsbury for my copy. What a delightful read. I found the style of writing in the plural original, clever, and extremely effective as a way of portraying the different thoughts and actions of the women as a group whilst not singling out one person's opinions, which would have made it controversial. It was also witty and very funny in places. It was obviously well researched but I would have liked TaraShea to do a bibliography to highlight this, instead of just including sources in the acknowledgements.

matson Tue 06-May-14 18:45:51

A very good book, once you became accustomed to the quirky writing style. It was thought provoking and absorbing and informative of a situation of people I had previously not given a thought to ! Thank you.

Galen Tue 06-May-14 19:39:55

Unusual, query, but quite fascinating.

Galen Tue 06-May-14 19:46:06

Querky, not query! I'm not asking! I'm saying!

weather Tue 06-May-14 21:36:56

Thankyou for my free copy
I have just finished this book its very different..the style of writing took a bit of getting used too but never the less I couldn't put it down and finished it very quickly.
I would like to ask the author if this will be made into a tv serial I think it could be adapted quite well and would prove to be very interesting..or if it already has been a tv program that I may have missed?

emmasnan Wed 07-May-14 13:44:36

Found the style of writing unusual but also that it was easy to read quickly.

I would like to ask the reasons behind wanting to write this book. It's an interesting subject and I'd not thought about the wives and children involved before.

Lowslung Thu 08-May-14 16:07:20

As others have mentioned, the narrative written in the plural is unusual but effective - it enforces the " we're in this together" feeling very well. I enjoyed the book a lot. I knew nothing about Los Alamos, and have since read up a little on it.
Tarashea, have you visited Los Alamos? Were you able to stay there? Have you met any members of the original families involved?

Kizzie Thu 08-May-14 17:39:05

Thank you so much for my copy of The Wives Of Los Alamos, really looking forward to reading it.

rocketstop Thu 08-May-14 19:14:43

Thankyou for my copy of the book. I too have never read writing in this style before. I found it very strange and a little uncomfortable at first. I am halfway through, and enjoying it but would like to ask the author if she was at all worried about alienating readers by choosing this writing style? It certainly was a brave choice !

Helen2014 Fri 09-May-14 10:26:08

I was somewhat bemused when I first started reading this as I had never come across the narrative style before. It is written in the collective voices of the women whose husbands designed and built the atomic bomb.

It was engaging and very much gave me as a reader the flavour of the range of experiences of the women and the challenges they met in keeping their families together, how they coped with their fears and dealt with their isolation. However, I found the style to be distracting. I would have preferred an in-depth narrative approach as I wanted to know more about individual stories rather than the 'skimming the surface' collectivity presented by the text.

I'm glad I read it because there were imaginative insights into the women's lives but I'd probably avoid any future books written in this style.

purplehairstreak Fri 09-May-14 16:47:57

I was delighted to receive this book as I recently visited Los Alamos when visiting family and granddaughter in the US. The road trip holiday we had took us to New Mexico and Santa Fe, and we went to Los Alamos to visit the museum there. So, I started reading this book with excitement and anticipation. Yes, the descriptions of the amazing sparse mountainous desert were all there, and I felt as though I was really into the story very quickly because I could picture so much of the place as I read.

The anonymous PO Box which was the address is all true and TaraShea has done a brilliant job with the research. Having watched a film at the museum, the description of Oppenheimer in his pork pie hat is spot on.

I was a bit disconcerted at first by the collective "we" method of telling the story, but on reflection found it an interesting device to use to convey the all in it togetherness of the wives in that situation. I'd like to ask TaraShea if

a) She chose the collective voice deliberately as a kind of Greek chorus to tell the story. It also reminded me of the chorus of women who tell the story in T.S.Eliot's play "Murder in the Cathedral".

b) Did she visit Los Alamos and the museum and the surrounding area? I think she must have done as she describes the New Mexico desert so well and conveys a realistic feel of what it's like there.

I really liked the bitchy catty snippet about the women who "accidentally" forgot not to flush the loo when water was short, just to annoy the hostess. That was very real. (no I wouldn't do anything like that!)

Thank you, I enjoyed it very much.

cazthebookworm Sat 10-May-14 12:21:05

Thank you for my copy, unfortunately I have not had time to read it yet, but hope to start this weekend. I will give some feed back eventually.

milli Sat 10-May-14 21:15:27

Really looking forward to reading this book. Thank you.

Milly Sat 10-May-14 23:49:39

I've been away for a couple of weeks and was delighted to find The Wives all ready for me when I returned, but have to catch up with the rest of you.
I started it this evening and found the style very unusual but compelling, however it is making me feel slightly depressed,(confused) I dont know why, shall continue to the end and see how I feel then.

Milly Sat 10-May-14 23:50:58

OH I thought if I put (confused) I would get a little funny face in its place.
Obviously I didn't do the right thing!
I am not confused, just depressed!!

Greenfinch Sat 10-May-14 23:54:22

Square brackets needed Milly

Milly Sun 11-May-14 12:25:42

Thanks Greenfinch, as usual I hadn't read the instructions properly blush

grandma60 Sun 11-May-14 15:02:14

It is a very strange book. I didn't think I was going to like it but then found I couldnt put it down. I was still.thinking about it days after I had finished it.