Gransnet forums

News & politics

Big Ben Can Bong For Brexit

(216 Posts)
Calendargirl Sun 22-Dec-19 07:29:55

I see in my Sunday paper that the new Speaker, Sir Lindsay Hoyle, has said he would allow Big Ben to ring out to mark Brexit on January 31st, ‘If MP’s wish to do that’.
How refreshing that this Speaker seems keen to do his job impartially, so unlike the bombastic Bercow, who did everything in his power to force his own views about Brexit at every turn.

Firecracker123 Sun 22-Dec-19 13:13:37

Yes hallelujah ? of course Big Ben should chime, it should be a national holiday.

Jabberwok Sun 22-Dec-19 14:08:26

It will be in this house!!!??????

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 14:28:59

''jura will you be travelling from SWITZERLAND to protest about something the UK government is doing?''

YES- because it affects us hugely- thanks.

BlueBelle Sun 22-Dec-19 14:47:40

Im so happy to live in a democracy ?? oh dear oh dear oh dear I don’t feel we live in a democracy any more I don’t recognise this country any more the result has been achieved through lies lies and more lies and the country is every bit as divided as three years ago
How can we have freedom of choice when half the population not to mention half the four countries within the UK have been pulled along kicking and screaming with the ‘majority’
A poster on here the other day said they voted for Brexit not knowing that the money we paid in came back in the form of grants etc and she went on to say most of her friends were the same ?
I personally will NEVER be happy about turning our back on the rest of our cousins in Europe and for what ? it’s absolutely nothing to rejoice about and rubbing people’s noses in it by chiming out will only cause more bad feeling
jennifereccles what was bad being part of the EU? I ve never understood the xenophobic point of view

inkcog Sun 22-Dec-19 14:52:57

How weird, how very weird. Why on earth are people getting excited about this?

Firecracker123 Sun 22-Dec-19 15:53:45

Because it's a signal that we are finally leaving the EU, although if you voted to remain you will probably be crying ? lol.

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 16:44:52

With the country so divided, this will not help with that 'healing' process- a gloating red rag, for sure- and will cause trouble, for sure.

Labaik Sun 22-Dec-19 16:48:39

I was just thinking that, jura. 50% of the people and 3/5 countries will not be celebrating and will just have their noses rubbed in it. Added to which it will be broadcast throughout the world and everyone will think this is what we all want #notinmyname

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 16:51:24

Well, I think a big demo to make it plain that this is the case, is in order ...

POGS Sun 22-Dec-19 16:54:59

www.hansardsociety.org.uk/blog/who-is-in-charge-of-the-palace-of-westminster-big-ben-and-parliamentary

It is a queer on this. The above link raises the question who has the 'say'.

I would prefer not to see nor hear any activities that could be deemed as some sort of jubilation or bombast, merely my opinion obviously and I accept others have theirs.

I think it is a time to remain dignified and respectful of the fact there is a hell of a lot of hard work and negotiations that require a little sensitivity and pragmatism for the right outcome to benefit both the UK and the European Union.

POGS Sun 22-Dec-19 17:02:51

As for those calling for ' demos' and talk of some sort of rebellion that is by far worse than ringing the bells of Big Ben as a proposal, not even on the same scale.

That is all that is left I suppose for those who cannot accept what has happened politically.

WadesNan Sun 22-Dec-19 17:30:23

jura what makes you think you have the right to interfere with the decisions made by the government of an country different to the one you live in - that is why the majority voted to leave the EU because we are tired of people living in another country thinking they have that right.

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 17:30:37

From a friend today ''"Bercow was too partisan and that we needed a more neutral Speaker.... by right-wing liars.''

oh yes. And for goodness sake, will you desist with this 'left' mallarkie (sp???) - remainers do not reperesent 'the left'.

Ringing the bells of Big Ben- as to celebrate the end of a war which saved the country is nothing else than gloating by a minority- in a very divided country which is not going to heal for a very long time, if ever.

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 17:36:17

WadesNan, I am British and have the right to vote and so is my OH- we have given our life to work for this country- the fact we are not currently there (well actually we are right now) is irrelevant. We belong to the great majority who did NOT vote for Conservatives.

GagaJo Sun 22-Dec-19 17:38:01

WadesNan Sun 22-Dec-19 17:30:23
jura what makes you think you have the right to interfere with the decisions made by the government of an country different to the one you live in - that is why the majority voted to leave the EU because we are tired of people living in another country thinking they have that right.

EITHER we live in a democracy, or we don't. Personally, I believe the latter.

BUT if you believe we ARE a democracy, which all the Leavers seem to feel we are, then a protest fits in very well with that theory. If we're democratic, then freedom of speech and freedom of protest are allowed.

I suspect those that are happy about Brexit want it BOTH ways. They want the Brexit vote respected but want to deny those who want to protest that right too.

BE VERY CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR. Restricting right to protest is very far-right. It's how it started under the Nazis.

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 17:39:09

Especially as Big Ben is in London where most voted to remain,it's so offensive!

aprilrose Sun 22-Dec-19 17:42:15

Especially as Big Ben is in London where most voted to remain,it's so offensive!

Then maybe we need to have all the church bells in all the leave constituencies to ring out instead then? London can remain in silence. smile

aprilrose Sun 22-Dec-19 17:45:12

oh dear oh dear oh dear I don’t feel we live in a democracy any more I don’t recognise this country any more the result has been achieved through lies lies and more lies and the country is every bit as divided as three years ago

I feel exactly the same way, having been pulled along b y the minority for the last three years. I have lost nearly all faith in democracy.

Democracy is what the majority decide. If you want to protest against it thats fine but to try and stop it is not fine.

Labaik Sun 22-Dec-19 17:47:17

What exactly is there to celebrate ie years and years of negotiations...sad…?

suzied Sun 22-Dec-19 17:49:28

Yes leave us Londoners alone. We don’t want it . And those in Scotland and NI. Have your bells out in the Toryshires and get leavers out in Wetherspoons with their microwaved readymeals and warm beer. Enjoy.

Labaik Sun 22-Dec-19 17:49:35

And, can I just say, I'm sick and tired of all the nasty comments aimed at jura who has, along with her husband, pretty much devoted her life to this country. However, that is disregarded because, in many eyes she's just a 'furrnier'...angry...

Labaik Sun 22-Dec-19 17:50:00

...bloody racist imo….

WadesNan Sun 22-Dec-19 17:51:26

Ringing the bells of Big Ben is hardly something to protest about.

Jura you may have been born here but you choose to live in another country - so why do you feel you have the right to dictate to those to choose to live here. I used to own a property in Spain I didn't think that gave me the right to dictate to the Spanish. Do you vote in Switzerland AND UK?

growstuff Sun 22-Dec-19 17:51:34

"although if you voted to remain you will probably be crying ? lol."

I accepted that the country is leaving the EU the day after the referendum. That doesn't mean I think it's a good idea. In fact, I still think it's a really bad decision. Nevertheless, what's happened has happened.

What really makes me mad is the gloating by people who think they've "won" something, call for some kind of unity and then laugh because others have "lost". Quite frankly, it just shows how pathetic and shallow such people are.

jura2 Sun 22-Dec-19 17:54:17

I was not born here, thanks. Did you take Spanish nationality.
I came to UK in 1970, became British in 1973 - lived in the UK for 40 years. Is that enough for you. OH was also born abroad, but British, and came in 1948 - is that not enough for you?

Irrelevant if you like ti or not- that is the LAW- British Law, so that is enough for me.