Gransnet forums

News & politics

So many dreams for our youngsters dashed.

(406 Posts)
Kali2 Thu 05-Aug-21 08:45:49

Already a huge problem for all those wanting to work in European resorts, be it in the leisure, sport or tourism of any form - and ski/snowboard instructors, sailing, surfing, etc. as 'equivalence' only applies to EU and Switzerland. Now those who aspire to be pilots, face the same problem as post-Brexit exclusion frustrates UK pilots as carriers seek EASA-licensed crews.

The Ski Operators are now advertising for staff in all their resorts, requiring an EU passport for all staff, from cleaners, to reps and instructors.

How sad that opportunities for our grand-children are being dashed like this - at the time where they lives are being so restricted in other ways due to Covid, and they also face the worries of climate change.

Antonia Thu 05-Aug-21 09:10:12

It will be a problem for some young people, but there are many job opportunities in the UK. Maybe the EU countries aren't keen to employ British youngsters, after Brexit.
Climate change is a different story and will probably affect them all.

Ellianne Thu 05-Aug-21 09:14:28

With English as their first language I can't see the job world shrinking for our youngsters.
Antonia is right, my son works alongside EDF engineering projects in the UK.

Alegrias1 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:17:20

It'll all be fine Kali2, after all we speak English, what could possibly go wrong? We're British don't you know?

In that overused phrase, I despair sad

Ellianne Thu 05-Aug-21 09:21:38

Alegrias1

It'll all be fine Kali2, after all we speak English, what could possibly go wrong? We're British don't you know?

In that overused phrase, I despair sad

I despair too Alegrias. Have you ever worked as a pilot where English is actually the main language, or in tourism where Englush leads the way? Look at the start of Kali's thread and my response. It is nothing about nationality, but about language. Picking a fight isn't always necessary. You should know I don't do politics, much as that phrase upsets.

Alegrias1 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:28:29

The first two responses to a thread seeking to discuss the impact that Brexit will have on the job opportunities for our younger generations were basically, "don't worry, there's no problem".

Kali didn't mention the English language. My DH works part time in tourism, speaks 3 languages. Don't really see how that's relevant, though.

NotSpaghetti Thu 05-Aug-21 09:31:14

But you are already wrong Ellianne as the whole thread is about the jobs shrinking for our children/grandchildren in Europe.

Many young people with an adventurous spirit go off to work in Europe for a year or two or maybe do the summer season abroad.
Obviously the same opportunities (may) exist as they did before if they are wanting to work in the UK... but there's something liberating in forging a new you, growing in confidence, becoming an adult away from family, in a foreign place.

MaizieD Thu 05-Aug-21 09:34:02

Antonia

It will be a problem for some young people, but there are many job opportunities in the UK. Maybe the EU countries aren't keen to employ British youngsters, after Brexit.
Climate change is a different story and will probably affect them all.

Maybe, just maybe, some of our young people recognise that a whole world exists outside the UK and they would like to be part of it.

Until the disastrous Brexit vote 27 European countries were easy for them to access, to work in, and to settle in if they felt so inclined. Taking that freedom from them is nothing but negative.

And before any Leavers step in, yes, I'm perfectly aware that all those things will still be 'possible' in the EU 27, but it won't be anywhere near as easy and their choices are restricted by some jobs, previously wide open to UK applicants, requiring EU passport holders only.

Ellianne Thu 05-Aug-21 09:35:31

Sorry, as my comments aren't palatable I will move to a more positive place.
By the way, my goddaughter has just finished Russian at Durham uni and has several offers of jobs in Europe in the pipeline.
Hurdles there might well be, but they are not insurmountable.

MaizieD Thu 05-Aug-21 09:39:41

Hurdles there might well be, but they are not insurmountable.

We know that the 'hurdles' aren't insurmountable. We're just angry that they are there at all after so many years of their complete absence.

MerylStreep Thu 05-Aug-21 09:42:52

A friend of my grandson has started his Pilot training.
I will pass on your words of wisdom kali2
I doubt his reply will be printable on GN.

Ellianne Thu 05-Aug-21 09:44:14

MerylStreep

A friend of my grandson has started his Pilot training.
I will pass on your words of wisdom kali2
I doubt his reply will be printable on GN.

grin

Alegrias1 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:44:58

Ellianne

Sorry, as my comments aren't palatable I will move to a more positive place.
By the way, my goddaughter has just finished Russian at Durham uni and has several offers of jobs in Europe in the pipeline.
Hurdles there might well be, but they are not insurmountable.

Ellianne please don't stop posting. But in the rough and tumble of the News and Politics threads anybody who says something that is unsubstantiated, or doesn't really address the problem, is going to get a response that they might not like flowers.

Kali2 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:49:44

Ellianne

Alegrias1

It'll all be fine Kali2, after all we speak English, what could possibly go wrong? We're British don't you know?

In that overused phrase, I despair sad

I despair too Alegrias. Have you ever worked as a pilot where English is actually the main language, or in tourism where Englush leads the way? Look at the start of Kali's thread and my response. It is nothing about nationality, but about language. Picking a fight isn't always necessary. You should know I don't do politics, much as that phrase upsets.

I am so sorry, but you are so wrong here. And that is the whole point, it is not about speaking English, but about 'equivalence' of qualifications, and about the need to have visas/permits. Loss of 'equivalence' for so many professions is entirely linked to Brexit and the UK becoming a 3rd country. Same for work permits and visas.

This will be made so much more difficult due to a shrinking air transport market, and airlines moving their base to EU to avoid difficulties with air travel post Brexit.

MaizieD Thu 05-Aug-21 09:50:45

MerylStreep

A friend of my grandson has started his Pilot training.
I will pass on your words of wisdom kali2
I doubt his reply will be printable on GN.

So your grandson's friend, once qualified, will have no problem in getting a job in the EU? Without having to clear any more hurdles than they would have had to clear, say, 10 years ago?

MawBe Thu 05-Aug-21 09:54:02

MaizieD

^Hurdles there might well be, but they are not insurmountable.^

We know that the 'hurdles' aren't insurmountable. We're just angry that they are there at all after so many years of their complete absence.

I would never agree with “complete absence”.
Language learning at secondary school level has been woeful for too many years, long before and entirely unconnected with Brexit, putting many young people at a disadvantage vis-a-vis their European counterparts who nearly always have a second or third language, whether or not that is their chosen area of study.
We have many foreign companies in and around MK and company policy is to require two languages (their own plus one) for progression to the high levels. I taught many students of French, German, Dutch, Indian and Japanese parents who also spoke excellent English. Our narrow system of choices at Secondary level, invariably discriminates against those who may wish go on to study science or engineering as two languages at GCSE level or even one language at A level does not fit into the curriculum.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:54:15

Ellianne

Sorry, as my comments aren't palatable I will move to a more positive place.
By the way, my goddaughter has just finished Russian at Durham uni and has several offers of jobs in Europe in the pipeline.
Hurdles there might well be, but they are not insurmountable.

I agree there are hurdles, I agree that they are not insurmountable.

We now have to view applying for a job in European Countries the same as USA, Canada, Australia, Asia etc.

Kali2 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:55:45

Ellianne, my comment followed after a niece who is training to be a pilot sent me the article fro Flight Global. They are already worried about their future due to the shrinking of the Airline industry. She is trilingual, with French and Spanish.

'' By David Kaminski-Morrow4 August 2021
Lauda Europe A320-c-Transport Malta

Frustrated UK cockpit representatives are urging the government to redress the licence-recognition imbalance with the European Union, as Ryanair’s Maltese carrier Lauda Europe’s recruitment for a London Stansted base lays down a requirement for European-licensed pilots.''

Alegrias1 Thu 05-Aug-21 09:56:46

If they brought in restrictions for applying for jobs in other parts of the UK, - Yorkshire for instance - would you be OK with that?

Because that is how people in the EU view other parts of the EU; just somewhere else that they can apply for jobs, or go and live, or whatever. But not British people. We're the outlier here.

Ellianne Thu 05-Aug-21 09:56:47

and Politics threads^
I love a bit of rough and tumble, but preferably not in the air! Talking of pilots!!
Too much turbulence.

Ellianne Thu 05-Aug-21 09:57:38

Buckle up for a bumpy ride then.

Peasblossom Thu 05-Aug-21 09:59:37

But if climate change is one of the worries they are facing, wouldn’t shrinking if the aircraft industry actually be a good thing?

Disappointing for the individual, but good for the planet?

Kali2 Thu 05-Aug-21 10:03:24

Yes, totally. Agreed.

But it is not the point of this thread. And my post is not 'just about' pilots. And yes, to some extent your comment applies to all tourism and certainly the ski industry. Perhaps for another thread?

MaizieD Thu 05-Aug-21 10:06:33

GrannyGravy13

Ellianne

Sorry, as my comments aren't palatable I will move to a more positive place.
By the way, my goddaughter has just finished Russian at Durham uni and has several offers of jobs in Europe in the pipeline.
Hurdles there might well be, but they are not insurmountable.

I agree there are hurdles, I agree that they are not insurmountable.

We now have to view applying for a job in European Countries the same as USA, Canada, Australia, Asia etc.

Which we haven't had to for several decades. This is not a Good Thing. Leave voters should be ashamed of raising barriers, not defending them.

Particularly as there are still NO noticeable benefits as a result of Brexit.

Whatdayisit Thu 05-Aug-21 10:18:39

Peasblossom

But if climate change is one of the worries they are facing, wouldn’t shrinking if the aircraft industry actually be a good thing?

Disappointing for the individual, but good for the planet?

Agree. I think the effects of climate change on people's lives is a bigger problem than working in the EU.
These times they are a changing. Poor kids have a lot of our mess to clean up.