Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Amn't I

(37 Posts)
FarNorth Fri 19-Jul-19 22:37:30

Can anyone explain why 'amn't I' is wrong and we have to say 'aren't I'?

gulligranny Sat 20-Jul-19 17:33:46

Just been reading Kirsty Wark's new novel "The House By The Loch" set in Galloway and "amn't" is used quite a lot. I don't use it myself but I rather like it.

Grammaretto Sat 20-Jul-19 20:25:54

DH says: "A long life and a Scottish education has raised no difficulty with amn't I. As with aren't I a small e is introduced to make pronunciation easier.
I regard amn't I as the correct original (though increasingly archaic) version of the Queen's English".

mcem Sat 20-Jul-19 20:31:40

Hear, hear Mr G!

grannyticktock Sat 20-Jul-19 22:18:43

I agree that in Scotland and NI, "amn't I?" is normal. If you say "Am I or amn't I?", you can see the logic of it - we don't say "I are" or "I aren't", so "aren't I" is the form that's an aberration.

Fennel Sun 21-Jul-19 09:50:36

To me, amn't is correct anyway - "I am not" turned into a question.
It's incorrect to say "I are not".
OHO "aren't you...." etc is correct.

Alexa Sun 21-Jul-19 17:01:47

" I've heard plenty of people saying 'amn't I' but if anyone said it in school they were corrected to 'aren't I'."

I am shocked. I wonder where your teacher was trained.

mcem Sun 21-Jul-19 21:04:59

alexa that doesn't happen in Scotland. 'Aren't I' just is not used!

Alexa Mon 22-Jul-19 11:54:48

mcem, yes but the bit in inverted commas is what somebody else wrote.

I was born in Scotland and lived most of my life there so I agree with you. It's too bad any school teacher would object to any regional dialect, except perhaps its use in a business letter.

BradfordLass72 Mon 22-Jul-19 11:56:33

I have just posted on another thread, 'ant's nest...'

Now I'm wondering if it should be 'ants' nest'
Or ants nest

And recently heard in a long list of reason why a man should not marry her, the girl said,
'....And then there's I'

confused ???

sodapop Mon 22-Jul-19 12:43:51

Now you have opened up a new hornet's hornets' hornets nest BradfordLassgrin

grannyticktock Mon 22-Jul-19 22:13:08

Assuming there's more than one ant inhabiting the nest, it's "ants' nest". You write down who or what owns the nest (= ants) and then put the apostrophe after it.