Gransnet forums

Site stuff

Inactive thread warning?

(9 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

Vallotton Sat 26-Jun-21 08:38:48

Other internet discussion sites have a warning message for participants along the lines of:

You are about to post on a thread that has been inactive for "x" months or "y" years. Do you wish to continue?

This site could do with something similar.

lemsip Sat 26-Jun-21 08:49:32

That would be very useful. I'm sure that has happened in the past when I've gone to post on an old thread without noticing.......

JulieNoted Sat 26-Jun-21 08:50:12

It already has something similar.

JulieNoted Sat 26-Jun-21 08:56:48

Although further investigation indicates this only happens if a thread is a year or more old.

BlueBelle Sat 26-Jun-21 08:59:22

We do have that I ve encountered it before now
Ok sorry Julie after it’s a year old, well I guess that’s fairly ok by a year it’s done and dusted

Vallotton Sat 26-Jun-21 09:11:54

Thanks JulieNoted. This issued occurred to me after seeing a thread in Bereavement which has been reactivated after two years. The person reactivating the thread would have seen this warning, then. A warning message after a month would be better imo.

toscalily Sat 26-Jun-21 09:55:14

I have noticed several rather old, resurrected threads over the past week. I presume this is more likely to occur when someone is new to the site, perhaps not realising that things move on at quite a speed and posting on a thread which is several months old is usually irrelevant. Perhaps a three month warning message would be a happy medium, long enough for someone to come back and update if they wish but not overlong.

AnnieGransnet (GNHQ) Sat 26-Jun-21 15:19:38

Hello all - thanks for the suggestions. We'll have a discussion about this and let you know the outcome.

Nannarose Sat 26-Jun-21 17:33:56

I think a 'warning' is the most appropriate - sometimes posters (especially OPs) may want to come back to say 'this is the outcome / thank you for helping me' or similar.
I would add that the warning could include ' you may get a better response if you start a new thread'
I think some posters google their issue / problem, get led to a thread here, and sign in and post without really checking the site.