Gransnet forums

AIBU

I still get irritated by this - AIBU to hate being referred to as a 'girl'...

(280 Posts)
Carolghill Sun 30-Apr-17 17:35:35

Okay. At church today a rather nice chap came up to a friend of mine to say hi. Nice. But he said 'Hi Girls'. My friend is 50 and I'm coming up to 65. I just said nicely - X,,, I am not a girl - I am a woman. He looks nonplussed. He says he means it as a compliment that we look good still!

Hmm.

I pointed out that at almost 65 I am NOT a girl. I am a woman.

He is nice. He just looked surprised. But to me being referred to as 'girl' infantises me, makes me less of an adult, puts me at a lower status ... Yukkity yuk yuk. Have we not achieved anything?!

Sorry. Rant over.

Ana Mon 01-May-17 21:04:35

The word 'chap' is simply not a term I've ever been familiar with. I'm not objecting to it, it just seems rather an olden-day word.

BonnieBlooming Mon 01-May-17 21:16:22

Honestly some people on this forum must get up especially early to get as much annoyed as possible into the day. The things people object too! Sounds like grumpy old women to me.

chickenlegs Mon 01-May-17 22:16:17

A man I was with referred to TV newsreaders and said, "They're nearly all girls now". I objected and told him they are women not girls. He doesn't like the word "women", they must be called girls or ladies. He is patronising, there's no other word for it.

Caro1954 Mon 01-May-17 22:23:57

Really sorry but what does AIBU stand for? confused

Maggiemaybe Mon 01-May-17 22:38:00

I must have missed the memo that said we should be offended by the word ladies. I still see it as just a polite version of the word women. What's patronising about it? confused

nannypink1 Mon 01-May-17 22:41:11

Caro 1954...Am I Being Unreasonable

nannypink1 Mon 01-May-17 22:42:23

I often refer to my friends as girls...I'm going out with the girls. Can't see anything wrong with it...quite like it tbh

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 22:48:43

Honestly some people on this forum must get up especially early to get as much annoyed as possible into the day. The things people object too! Sounds like grumpy old women to me.

... and coming on to a thread especially to tell those freely expressing an opinion is ...?

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 22:50:58

Yes, but GGMK2, the OP asked a question
Am I Being Unreasonable?

and people are answering.

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 22:51:35

woman: generic word for a female human being
lady: a woman of refined behaviour and speech

Mrs Bucket comes to mind. It seems to me that 'ladies' is a left over from the classism of the past - and loos.

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 22:53:52

I know that Jalima so why should BonnieBlooming, who I quoted, feel we need to be criticised for offering an opinion? I am really not sure what you are complaining about.

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 22:55:34

loo?
is it wrong to say loo now?
shock

I will be sent to Room 101

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 22:58:05

Who's Bonnieblooming?

Bonnie blooming heather?

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 23:00:22

No Jalima - you seem to be reading for affect rather than what is writtenhmm

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 23:01:17

BonnieBlooming Mon 01-May-17 21:16:22. That is where the quote came from.

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 23:01:46

don't know what you're on about

reading for affect doesn't make sense

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 23:02:25

She's another poster
Apologies BonnieBlooming I missed your post

Caro1954 Mon 01-May-17 23:03:26

Thankyou nannypink1!

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 23:06:52

Not a lot seems to for you tonight Jalima.

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 23:08:34

Well, as I haven't been on here tonight until now then how would you know?

Perhaps if your post made some sense I could understand it.
But it doesn't.
Unless, of course, it is just grammatically incorrect or spelt incorrectly.

MawBroon Mon 01-May-17 23:08:46

Honestly some people on this forum must get up especially early to get as much annoyed as possible into the day. The things people object too! Sounds like grumpy old women to me

... and coming on to a thread especially to tell those freely expressing an opinion is ...?
Is also expressing an opinion hmm

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 23:16:21

It could well be grammatically incorrect or spelt incorrectly Jalima although I do spend an inordinate amount of time trying to ensure it isn't.

Or, MawBroon, another version of a grumpy old women.

MawBroon Mon 01-May-17 23:30:27

Did you mean "effect" GGMk2?

As for grumpy old women maybe grumpy old girls?? grin
If OP's "rather nice chap" was getting on a bit, OP's 50 year old friend could have been young enough to be his daughter. Surely "girls" is excusable in the context??
I do find the "Hi" disconcerting though. Even as a child I was not allowed to use it to grown ups, it being only permissible among school friends ?
Surely it is better manners to say "Good morning " - ?

GracesGranMK2 Mon 01-May-17 23:40:50

Yet again I have no idea what you are talking about MawBroon. Did I mean "effect" where?

Aslemma Tue 02-May-17 00:16:36

It appears there are at least a couple of pompous twits on here. I am more than happy to be classed as one of the "girls"and don't have a problem with being one of the "ladies" either. I neither feel that the first is infantalising me nor the other is inappropriate in this day and age. I much prefer these forms of address to being called a miserable old git behind my back. My daughter and daughters-in-law, all between mid 40s and early 50s, always refer to themselves as '"the girls" when they are arranging an evening out.