MaizieD
Interesting illustration of the difficulties of a mods job. One poster mentions a fact and another leaps in saying it's a 'smear'. I'm sure that neither post would be complained about, but if they were, what would e the verdict?
I don't find 'robust' argument offensive but I do think that the mods should act on personal attacks. By which I mean not attacks on a particular 'group' but on individual posters.
Yes, personal attacks are one of the things we don't tolerate. Of course, not everyone has the same definition of personal attack but... And we do rely on people to report stuff to us, so are grateful when we are alerted to posts that aren't entirely in the spirit etc Obviously can't get into specifics on here