Gransnet forums

AIBU

Relative moving within three doors!

(82 Posts)
Dorset Wed 13-Jul-22 16:57:29

We have recently decided to move to another County, a much quieter area. We have been putting a lot of time, money and effort into looking at all the areas within that county, over the 18 months. Our buyer lost patience after three months as we are buying a new build which had paperwork issues. It is one of four and we are the first to buy, we have paid the most as it has two parking spaces and a larger garden. The paperwork is now all sorted, and we have found a buyer (short chain), so all looks positive. We visited again to pick new kitchen/bathroom/tiles recently, and Doctors. We are so excited. However today my husbands close relative, who lives two hours from this development, has phoned and said they have decided to buy one of the others (all our semi’s). AIBU to not want family so near, 20/30 minutes away, but right next door! I haven’t heard them say they want to move, they never go out exploring areas but seem to want what we have chosen. Am I just being a miserable old so and so. Up until now we phone each other and live 300 miles apart. We are never close enough to visit. I feel so guilty for now not feeling excited about our new home and my husband happens to feel the same ? advice please…

vickya Thu 14-Jul-22 13:39:06

We lived in the next door flat to my grandparents, who moved in there when I was 4. My dad died when I was 7 and I think it was a big help for my mum, who then went out to work after a bit. I could go back and forward and as only 4 when they arrived and they spoke mostly German I absorbed it and have been fluent since then, which has been very useful. My cousin, 20 years older, lived with them too and I loved being with her.

When my mum went into hospital when I was 15 I stayed in our flat but was able to go next door for meals and they looked after me. When my grandparents got old my mum and I were able to look after them. My gran ate with us every day after my grandfather went into a home and then died. She fell in her 90s and broke a hip and after initial hospital stay came home and we looked after her. I'd moved out, married, had 2 children, but was with her the night she died, giving my mum a night's sleep. I had a 6 month old baby and 2 year old by then but am so pleased I was able to be with my gran. I had loving grandparents who spoiled me rotten next door.

knessie Thu 14-Jul-22 13:39:27

?? It happened to us, moved into a lovely new house and six weeks later our son and daughter in law parents had bought a house ( unbeknown to us) two doors down!! We didn’t know them well and it was horrible. There was grandchildren involved, which set of parents to visit or visit both. Yikes, it was horrible for quite a while . Felt , why did they want to buy so close to us! I personally wouldn’t do that.
But over time things turned out ok. We respected each other space. Grandchildren would visit both houses most visits.
Now we have moved on after six years to another county to enjoy retirement by the sea.?

Dorset Thu 14-Jul-22 14:25:27

I thank the people who understand how I feel with all the research I have done, at a very long way. I am actually moving 20 minutes from a very close aunt and the same to another cousin. I was bought up by my Nan and grandad and value my family. What I don’t like, is the cousin in law drinks during the day (his business) and only a couple but my husband cannot say no so will, and is not nice in drink. The actual cousin feeds off me for recipes, shopping which is lovely but not every day. We are all far too close for me to say only pop in on Saturdays. Plus my husbands twin brother is also close to these cousins but my husband doesn’t talk to him! Writing this highlights the problems are with husbands family so best let him sort it out. Thank you for the positive comments though as I was feeling down. ?

Secretsquirrel1 Thu 14-Jul-22 14:42:10

Omg what a wind up ! You must be gutted. What does your other half think ?
How did they know exactly where your new house was?! X

Jodieb Thu 14-Jul-22 14:44:53

How rude not to ask you if you minded! They are space invaders.

StoneofDestiny Thu 14-Jul-22 14:57:56

It's amazing they didn't ask if you minded.

Grandmabatty Thu 14-Jul-22 15:33:50

Given your update I would seriously reconsider the move. Does your husband admit he drinks too much when with his cousin? He could promise he won't when you move, but what will you do if your fears are realised? By saying nothing and leaving it to your husband, you could end up moving and it becomes a prison for you.

NotSpaghetti Thu 14-Jul-22 15:37:06

I would personally prefer relatives 20 mins or a bit more away. I would not like them to just keep on popping in.

I can see the benefits of being close if you are looking after an agèd relative for example - or someone you care about who suffers from, say, serious mental illness - but I'd still rather be able to have a (kindly) break from them and not feel that they will be upset if we have cars arriving and they aren't part of things. I'd also rather not feel these relatives have to come along with me if I'm going out. I don't always want family to "do" everything with me.

It would be hard to exclude someone from say, a barbecue or birthday or just a casual get-together if they were just two doors away. Sometimes I want to be able to socialise with people I want to socialise with, not a cousin or a great aunt no matter how much I love them.

And yes, I do love them... and in small and not so small ways we all share this love. We each love and support each other (better I think than many "in your pocket" families), and regularly make the one hour, two hour, 45 minute, 20 minute, journeys to do this.

So GrammyGrammy on behalf of other "not-in-the-pocket" families and those of us who did cut apron strings, I find your remarks offensive and just wrong

Why do you all like living your tiny little lives alone in your little boxes keeping blood relatives away and out of things? I find this resentful, withholding, distancing and lack of familial care and love and warmth disgusting

Firstly, I don't think we have "tiny little lives" what makes you think that? And why do you think we are "alone"? Maybe if we were alone we might like it better!
Just because you don't want to live in someone's pocket does not mean you are resentful, or withholding or distancing and it certainly doesn't mean you have a lack of familial care and love and warmth.

I'm with M0nica on this one. If it's true, and the agent will know if it is, I'd find another house if it's not too late.

Treetops05 Thu 14-Jul-22 15:47:53

If 2 of my siblings moved close, I would secretly sell up and move, 1 sister I'd love to be near - and she nearly did move 40 yards away but sadly it fell through x

FarNorth Thu 14-Jul-22 15:48:59

I feel so guilty for now not feeling excited about our new home and my husband happens to feel the same

If you both feel that life will be difficult, with the relatives so close and the problems you mention, you could be better to cancel the new house and look for something else.
A lot of bother, obviously, but could be much less bother than the situation you'd be getting into.

You could go ahead with your own sale, then rent until you find somewhere else and you'd then have the money immediately available.

GrammyGrammy it's not nice of you to be so judgemental.
Surely you know that some relatives are best in small doses, or not at all.

SunshineSally Thu 14-Jul-22 15:53:11

Well said NotSpaghetti - totally agree.

Dorset - If it were me, given your further update I’d see if you can find out if they definitely are purchasing or whether it’s wishful thinking on their part. If it’s the former, then you have to weigh up whether it’s worth taking the risk and if this would affect your relationship with your DH. If it’s the latter then you can breathe a sigh of relief. Good luck x

greenlady102 Thu 14-Jul-22 15:58:48

Daisend1

GrammyGrammy
Many would, as many would not, enjoy living near relatives.
Choice

this ^^ I had relatives I would not have wanted to live near to. They have passed away now so not going to happen.

Kittye Thu 14-Jul-22 16:02:35

I’ve lived at the other end of the country from my sister for nearly 40 years, I’d absolutely love it if she came and lived close to me ?

coastalgran Thu 14-Jul-22 16:09:49

Perhaps you should have kept quiet about the move and not been a bit showy and smug then they wouldn't have known. Afraid that you are stuck with them, worse still they might have bought it as a rental and let it to highly undesirable people and the other neighbours in this small enclave will blame you.

NotSpaghetti Thu 14-Jul-22 16:14:52

coastalgran where us the evidence that Dorset was smug?
I took from it that she was excited.

Grancan Thu 14-Jul-22 16:17:07

Sounds like they’ll be a bit too close for comfort. You need to ask them what’s going on here, is it the area that they like or is it having you for neighbours. Otherwise if you cancel the purchase and find somewhere else they might follow you there!

queenofsaanich69 Thu 14-Jul-22 16:28:45

Reply you are delighted as when you get older and ill someone will be there to look after you ?
Don’t be too down it may work out well,but I can see how your heart would sink,they must really think your lovely people to want to be so near.

NotSpaghetti Thu 14-Jul-22 16:36:18

... maybe queenofsaanich69 - or maybe they just can't bear to miss out!

Grandmabatty Thu 14-Jul-22 16:48:11

Coastalgran that was a very unpleasant post. At no point has the OP been 'smug'. It says more about you than her.

maydonoz Thu 14-Jul-22 17:32:09

Dorset. Hi, if I were in your situation I would be inclined to sit down with your DH and his cousin and family and find out exactly what their plans are. You have done all this work to find your dream home and it would be a shame to waste all that time and energy you have spent on this project.
As others have suggested, they may be just testing your reaction to their "plans".
Then you can make an informed decision which way to go.
You never know, if you both families decide to go ahead with purchasing, you could be a great support to each other in your senior years.
I was touched by Vickya's lovely, heartwarming story of real family care and support for each generation as and when needed.

H1954 Thu 14-Jul-22 17:38:25

Could it be that they bought the house not knowing they would be so close to you? Have you asked them? Do you know what their intentions are? They might actually feel as horrified about it as you do.

Being so close doesn't mean that you have to live in one another's pockets though.

Kryptonite Thu 14-Jul-22 18:10:13

I once knew someone who didn't want to go to the same swimming pool as us! Very odd. Another person took up my special hobby, which felt like competition. I think sometimes people get very possessive about things or places and see them as 'theirs'. I feel a bit like this about a certain holiday destination. Completely irrational. People can go where they like, of course. But it's different if they have caused you problems or are trying to muscle in somehow.

Jess20 Thu 14-Jul-22 18:12:07

Oh hell, I'd hate that but then I'm an antisocial old bat. I'd tell them it looked like it might fall through and see if they still want to move.

happycatholicwife1 Thu 14-Jul-22 19:27:22

I agree with Grammy Grammy and the several others who would dearly enjoy and love family to be close. I find this to be a particularly English point of view. I don't know a lot of people amongst my neighbors who feel that way about their family, nor do I. If you know them to be a total PIA, that's different. But it sounds as if most of you don't want much to do with your families. Sad.

4allweknow Thu 14-Jul-22 19:36:21

Are the definitely intending to move in. They may be buying with view to rent the house out. A lot will depend on the relatives and the kind of people they are. Perhaps they have no intention of popping in every minute. You may be looking for problems that will never arise. If you are so uncomfortable with the situation pull out of purchase and look elsewhere.