Gransnet forums

AIBU

Food bank rollercoaster. Huge empathy to Fury!! Is it just me?

(167 Posts)
WhyWhyWhyohWhy Sun 04-Jun-23 18:54:54

I volunteer at a local food bank, there are several in my area. My role is to input into the computer the details of those who contact us so that they receive food from us which is usually delivered directly to their door with the exception of those who live closest to the distribution centre. People can self refer so no hoops to jump through and most of our users are also using the other food banks and charities where we live. I am a small cog in a big wheel, and just follow the rules of what I am asked to do, others make those rules.
We as a family are not well off but have the ability to manage our small income to make ends meet, if we can’t afford it we don’t have it, it’s that simple. I probably would qualify for help if I had our income and outgoings looked at but we prefer to stand on our own two feet. I was brought up not to waste resources and have tried to educate our children in the same way. I do know how lucky I am to be able to manage to get by. And here it comes…. The more I learn about the people who access our service the more flaming annoyed I get, there are genuine people who literally do not have enough coming in and to me this is who we should be prioritising and I get so annoyed that they are falling through the cracks and left behind. What I find more irksome is that week on week while the poorest fall further behind I receive what amounts to shopping/wish lists. Apart from those who have special dietary requirements such as Celiac disease and the like I am apt to think that folk should be grateful for any support that we can provide bearing in mind that we rely on donations from the public to redistribute, but honestly I do wonder if this monster that has been created actually helps the majority of our users to learn essential life lessons like budgeting at all? Some of the requests are to me outrageous so for example instead of asking for deodorant they ask for expensive brands like Dove this or that fragrance, last week someone requested freshly ground coffee which was a further step up from the usual requests for Nescafé, or Douwe Egberts, then there’s the mums who request really expensive formula and nappies to feed children they cannot afford whilst becoming pregnant with more children they cannot afford. Then there are those who obtain food so that they can buy illegal drugs with their money.
The icing on the cake this weekend has been from someone who has up until recently been given a store voucher one day and food the next day. The £25 weekly vouchers have stopped and the single person user isn’t happy because they usually buy fresh fish, meat and other ingredients with it and has now taken to contacting the local Conservative MP to complain. The irony of that isn’t wasted on me.
As a family of 4 who can rarely afford to buy fresh fish and meat ourselves but tries to be altruistic I’m getting a bit peeved at the rights over responsibility attitude of some people and I am beginning feel as though I don’t want to give or help, especially when the recipients are posting on social media their takeaways and grand days out.
I know I sound like a hard hearted bitch when in reality I know that you have to walk a day in someone’s shoes to know how it is for them but some peoples idea of being in desperate need completely contradict my knowledge of it. AIBU?

LRavenscroft Tue 06-Jun-23 05:41:48

Primrose53

I could never in a million years imagine collecting food for my kids from a food bank but spending £40 getting my nails done or anything else like Tattoos, Red Bull, cigarettes etc.

Even dressing it up as “a wee boost” to myself wouldn’t cut it! My biggest boost would be seeing my kids happy and well fed, they would always come before my own wants.

How could any Mother watch their kids go off to school with no breakfast because she has spent £40 getting her nails done?

A comment after my own heart.

Franbern Tue 06-Jun-23 08:09:23

Where in this long thread, has anyone said that children going to school hungry (and, sadly yes there are far too many who are these days), have Mums who are spending on having their nails done????? Talk about adding 2 plus 2 and making 5!!!!

I have NEVER been to a nail bar, but understand that gel nails last for several weeks, so that forty pound charge is probably working out less than a fiver a week!!!! I have, sadly, been in the position of having to bring up a family on benefits and eeking out a small amount of money to provide meals, clothes and entertainment for my children. Week on week, month on month.......and I know the toll it took on my own mental and physical health!!! Fortunately, this was all a long time ago for me, but will never forget it. Anything that could have given me some sort of boost would have been worth while just to keep me going!!

Until someone has actually walked on the shoes of those who are struggling, perhaps they should not criticise.

Primrose53 Tue 06-Jun-23 08:31:48

Franbern

Where in this long thread, has anyone said that children going to school hungry (and, sadly yes there are far too many who are these days), have Mums who are spending on having their nails done????? Talk about adding 2 plus 2 and making 5!!!!

I have NEVER been to a nail bar, but understand that gel nails last for several weeks, so that forty pound charge is probably working out less than a fiver a week!!!! I have, sadly, been in the position of having to bring up a family on benefits and eeking out a small amount of money to provide meals, clothes and entertainment for my children. Week on week, month on month.......and I know the toll it took on my own mental and physical health!!! Fortunately, this was all a long time ago for me, but will never forget it. Anything that could have given me some sort of boost would have been worth while just to keep me going!!

Until someone has actually walked on the shoes of those who are struggling, perhaps they should not criticise.

Wow … justifying getting expensive gel nails rather than feeding your kids!

That money passes through their hands at some point and I still cannot imagine handing over £40 to a nail technician rather than buying £40 worth of groceries!

I am sure many of us struggled when we were young parents so we do understand and in those days there were no benefits other than “family allowance” for the first child! I was very often first in the queue at the PO to collect mine to get us through a couple more days. I can hand on heart say that every penny of mine went on my kids, not myself.

Iam64 Tue 06-Jun-23 08:34:40

Well said Franbern. A few bad apples exist everywhere but that shouldn’t stop those of us who can, contributing to help others.

The key problem is how did our country become a place in which food banks are seen as acceptable. It’s shameful that the government sits back and lets charity step in to provide basics.

Doodledog Tue 06-Jun-23 09:00:40

Is it any wonder that benefits go unclaimed when people are judged for having their hair or nails done, or having others decide from their appearance whether they ‘need’ things or not? Do people want claimants to be in rags?

I have never had my nails ‘done’ so I wouldn’t miss it if I couldn’t afford it, but I get my hair cut regularly and would feel scruffy if I couldn’t. I cut it myself during lockdown with truly dreadful results.

The tattoos, gel nails and fake tan look mentioned above probably doesn’t suit many of us, but young women have always wanted to look attractive, whether their parents liked the look or not. How many on this thread didn’t look after their appearance when they were young- whether that was a shampoo and set, a beehive, a sharp bob, a Purdy cut, a Diana flick, spiral perm or a Mohican? Did you wear plain grey shifts whilst your friends had minis, cheesecloth or safety pins and chains? Most people follow fashion of some sort, at least when they are young.

I am no longer young, but I don’t begrudge young people the right to look how they see as attractive, and as sure as hell I would look my best if I had to go to a food bank or to claim benefits. They may well be doing it by shopping in charity shops and getting friends to do their hair and nails. It doesn’t have to mean that their children are starving or that they are frittering money away. The judgement is horrible- let people have some dignity, even if they don’t choose to express it the same way as you.

FannyCornforth Tue 06-Jun-23 09:06:54

The woman in question may very well have had her nails done for free!

I have lots of nail stuff and a curing lamp (shoot me now!) and I often do my step-mom’s nails and those of my next door neighbour.

I don’t think that I would have immediately linked the need for food / nails thing

MerylStreep Tue 06-Jun-23 09:13:31

Fanny
Your not alone, I have all the kit.

FannyCornforth Tue 06-Jun-23 09:23:38

Meryl I really like peel off base coat. Sensationail do a good one

biglouis Tue 06-Jun-23 14:10:19

@growstuff

I asked a valid and important question to which none of you who state that you volunteer for food banks have supplied an answer.

So rather than trolling over one word which you dont like perhaps you would care to explain how a housebond/mobility impaired/no transport person gets "referred" to your organization without having social services busybodies buzzing around.

FannyCornforth Tue 06-Jun-23 14:27:27

I’d be interested to know the answer too biglouis

growstuff Tue 06-Jun-23 14:38:32

biglouis

@growstuff

I asked a valid and important question to which none of you who state that you volunteer for food banks have supplied an answer.

So rather than trolling over one word which you dont like perhaps you would care to explain how a housebond/mobility impaired/no transport person gets "referred" to your organization without having social services busybodies buzzing around.

Presumably you have a GP.

It's not trolling to consider your attitude judgmental. You even can't resist having a "go" at social workers.

I doubt very much whether you're in dire enough straits to be eligible for a foodbank a couple of times a year. You're always saying how successful your business is, how you know all the loopholes and what a successful career you had.

I wouldn't have thought it beyond your wit to work something out, if you were eligible.

HousePlantQueen Tue 06-Jun-23 15:28:58

Foodbank referrals, certainly for the Trussel Trust, can be made by email, and if a client explains that they are unable to attend physically due to mobility issues, delivery can be made. Good kind people work these things out, you know.

growstuff Tue 06-Jun-23 17:48:31

HousePlantQueen

Foodbank referrals, certainly for the Trussel Trust, can be made by email, and if a client explains that they are unable to attend physically due to mobility issues, delivery can be made. Good kind people work these things out, you know.

The only foodbank I know much about is the local Trussell Trust one. I knew that they can deliver for some clients.

A significant number of referrals are because people's benefit payments are delayed and the DWP signposts people to foodbanks.

I don't know anything about the foodbanks run by other organisations which don't need a referral. People seem to think the Trussell Trust foodbanks provide unlimited supplies of food. They don't. People have to be desperate to be referred and can only have a limited number of vouchers.

Even the poorest and most downtrodden deserve a sense of self-worth and I don't suppose they're keen on people prying into every aspect of their life.

Franbern Tue 06-Jun-23 18:19:41

Perhaps those who need to use places like foodbanks, should have the appearance to show how poor they are. Unwashed (hot water and soap all cost money - even cold water does), unshaven , perhaps a special costume of sackcloth to wear tied with string. Definitely no make-up or jewellery, even costume.

Am I being ridiculous? Not when we read some of the posts on here.

Chocolatelovinggran Tue 06-Jun-23 18:30:44

We can visit to take details, or another agency can do this. Some of our folk are sent our way by the Probation Service or Health Visitors etc; and the housebound can nominate someone to collect on his/ her behalf. Many of our clients come on a bus.
Our support is limited to 12 lots of parcels. I hope that this answers the questions.

Ilovecheese Tue 06-Jun-23 19:23:37

Absolutely agree with Doodledog .
Not everyone is as perfect as some on this thread, but I bet the imperfect ones are kinder.

Chocolatelovinggran Tue 06-Jun-23 22:55:53

Oh and "social service busybodies" are not interested in foodbanks - they're just too ...well..busy, biglouis.

Sara1954 Wed 07-Jun-23 06:29:52

It’s very easy to be judgmental when you are looking on from a more comfortable position.
My husband always reminds me that we had practically nothing when we were first together, but the difference is, that we never considered it would last very long, and for a lot of families now, there doesn’t seem to be a way out of it.
There has to be a little joy in life, and while I think the children should always be fed before you get your nails done, if you manage to budget that in, and it makes you feel better, where’s the harm?

VioletSky Wed 07-Jun-23 07:20:51

Someone with their nails done could work at a nail bar or have the experience to do it themselves or it could have been a gift for their birthday.

It's too easy to judge when people don't actually know

If a thread like this put off even one person from donating that could translate to a meal a week someone is going without.

Iam64 Wed 07-Jun-23 07:54:54

What about all those mobile phones and flat screen televisions? Luxury 😏.

Referring to hard pressed social workers as busy bodies buzzing around adds another judgemental layer to this. Absolutely bonkers

Blondiescot Wed 07-Jun-23 07:57:46

The 'oh but they can afford mobile phones' comment always amazes me. Clearly some people don't realise that you need a mobile phone to do so many things like applying for jobs now. They're an essential part of life for most people now.

DiamondLily Wed 07-Jun-23 08:00:27

Primrose53

Franbern

Where in this long thread, has anyone said that children going to school hungry (and, sadly yes there are far too many who are these days), have Mums who are spending on having their nails done????? Talk about adding 2 plus 2 and making 5!!!!

I have NEVER been to a nail bar, but understand that gel nails last for several weeks, so that forty pound charge is probably working out less than a fiver a week!!!! I have, sadly, been in the position of having to bring up a family on benefits and eeking out a small amount of money to provide meals, clothes and entertainment for my children. Week on week, month on month.......and I know the toll it took on my own mental and physical health!!! Fortunately, this was all a long time ago for me, but will never forget it. Anything that could have given me some sort of boost would have been worth while just to keep me going!!

Until someone has actually walked on the shoes of those who are struggling, perhaps they should not criticise.

Wow … justifying getting expensive gel nails rather than feeding your kids!

That money passes through their hands at some point and I still cannot imagine handing over £40 to a nail technician rather than buying £40 worth of groceries!

I am sure many of us struggled when we were young parents so we do understand and in those days there were no benefits other than “family allowance” for the first child! I was very often first in the queue at the PO to collect mine to get us through a couple more days. I can hand on heart say that every penny of mine went on my kids, not myself.

No, nor me. A basic haircut was my lot when the kids were little.

It's all about priorities when you have children.

Other than the nail bar "sweat shops", where the girls are worked non stop for hours, springing up everywhere, I don't know a decent place where gel nails only cost £40.

I'm getting mine done next week, by a reputable nail bar, and it's £55 plus extra if you want spray art/patterns.

There will always be scams, with benefits and things like food banks, there always have been, but, of course, the majority of people are genuine.

Professionally referred food banks work best. The self referral ones have become a bit of a free for all.

FannyCornforth Wed 07-Jun-23 08:06:05

VioletSky

Someone with their nails done could work at a nail bar or have the experience to do it themselves or it could have been a gift for their birthday.

It's too easy to judge when people don't actually know

If a thread like this put off even one person from donating that could translate to a meal a week someone is going without.

Yes, I said much the same yesterday VS, the fact of having had one’s nails done is hardly synonymous with having money to burn (the new ‘huge flat screen telly’?)

Franbern - I loved your post! grin

Blondiescot Wed 07-Jun-23 08:30:43

DiamondLily - you can get gel nails done for less than £40 around here, and that's at reputable salons.

LRavenscroft Wed 07-Jun-23 10:10:37

Old wisdom: Cut your coat according to your cloth.