Gransnet forums

AIBU

AIBU Husbands new car

(56 Posts)
JOJO60 Thu 07-Aug-25 09:02:00

My husband's only vice is cars, and, with my encouragement he has recently bought a lovely 4 seater convertible. We used to have a 2 seater before, but due to hip and knee problems he found it difficult to get in and out so we sold it. This new one is larger and it's something he's always dreamed of. We planned to use it for nights out and daytime trips. We still have the old car for running around, shopping etc. The problem is, we give a lift to a friend on a friend one night a week and due to her being very overweight she will struggle to get into the back seat. As I drive home, and my husband has 2 knee and 2 hip replacements he won't be able to get in the back seat either. So, do we forego the nice car for her sake and use the old one? She has her own car, goes out every day in it, and often declines our lift if she wants to bring another friend with her. How do I tell her we're taking the convertible from now on and you won't be able to get in it?

Nanato3 Thu 07-Aug-25 09:14:22

I'd just tell her I've changed my car and I'm sorry but I won't be able to give you a lift anymore due to hubby not being able to sit in the back ! Just say it like it is . She has her own car so she won't be stuck.

Crossstitchfan Thu 07-Aug-25 09:15:10

Just tell her straight. “By the way, we have decided to make more use of our new car and will be taking that from now on. I’m afraid you’ll have to make your own arrangements. You’ve got your car though, so it shouldn’t be too much of a problem for you”
Enjoy your new car. Why should you not take it just because she is overweight and can’t get into yours? ‘Self inflicted, no sympathy’ is a phrase I like! She can use her own car and I don’t see why you should give up your pleasure to please her. If she didn’t have her own transport, and relied on you, it would be different. Not ok though! She is being needy and selfish. Be strong!

Mt61 Thu 07-Aug-25 13:02:22

Why do you give her a lift when she has her own car?

Astitchintime Thu 07-Aug-25 13:04:42

Just tell her…..no point flowering up the conversation and why can’t she give you a lift once in a while?

Jaxjacky Thu 07-Aug-25 13:48:58

If it’s a good friend I’d carry on in the other car, it’s only one night a week, a friendship is more important than going out in a new car to me.

GrammaH Sat 09-Aug-25 13:37:41

Perhaps he should have bought a 2 seater convertible instead and the problem wouldn't have arisen! We have a very nice main car in which we often take friends but they know, if we're going right into town where parking is difficult, we take the little old run around & they have to put up with it. Of she's a good friend, I'd take the other car once a week it won't hurt you. Anyway, I expect the novelty will wear off soon!

Romola Sat 09-Aug-25 13:38:00

Could your friend get into the front seat and you go in the back?

4allweknow Sat 09-Aug-25 13:44:22

Can your husband perhaps drive and you use the back seat enabling your friend to go in the front? Presuming you are insured of course. Your friend has her own car so possibly not a great hardship but that you had that arrangement must have been for some reason or why did you give a lift. If friend can't fit in new car and the swapping of driver isn't feasible you have no alternative but to tell your friend no more lifts.

Truddles Sat 09-Aug-25 13:54:57

Don’t be daft! It’s your husband’s dream. It’s putting this fat woman’s convenience before your husband’s dream. Just tell her you can’t give her a lift in the new car as your husband can’t ride in it comfortably if she’s in it. It’ll save your suspension, too.

cc Sat 09-Aug-25 13:59:05

You were helping her with lifts before but you are not obliged to choose a car that will enable her to continue. I also think that a larger two seater convertible would be better, if you don't need the back seats.

Hev1959 Sat 09-Aug-25 13:59:31

It says she drives home

Cambia Sat 09-Aug-25 14:28:27

Truddles tell it like it is!!! That’s just what I was thinking as I read and I laughed out loud!

icanhandthemback Sat 09-Aug-25 14:33:39

How does your husband feel about it? I would happily take the other car if it was me but my husband would probably want to take his. I would sooner let my friend drive herself than prioritise her needs over my husband's. It would be different if she couldn't drive.

Elsi Sat 09-Aug-25 14:39:02

What Truddles said!!

pluckyluckyme Sat 09-Aug-25 14:43:23

I don't see why the old car you still have for shopping etc can't be used for that one night a week . If it was my friend, that is what I would do. As for the friend being overweight, there are many reasons for that and I feel it is unfair to judge. We do not know this person or the things she has been through etc.

Barbadosbelle Sat 09-Aug-25 14:53:17

.

I'm baffled. How did the three of you manage when you just had the two-seater?
.

mabon2 Sat 09-Aug-25 15:02:16

Well, she'll just have to use her own car wont she, end of story.

Shelflife Sat 09-Aug-25 15:39:46

Think I am with jax If you value her friendship and it's only one day a week , why not use your other car?

Samsara1 Sat 09-Aug-25 15:44:46

I think I would be a little more kind and explain that 'we would love to give you a lift as before but would you mind sitting in the back as Fred cant'. She then has the opportunity to turn you down, and kindly I hope.

pably15 Sat 09-Aug-25 15:45:22

it's your car, enjoy it, your friend has a car let her use it

Colls Sat 09-Aug-25 15:48:09

Shelflife

Think I am with jax If you value her friendship and it's only one day a week , why not use your other car?

I feel Shelflife is right. But, ask yourself if you are possibly starting to resent giving such regular lifts? That would be understandable. Regular things like this can start to pall after a while. And considering she declines your lift sometimes and can drive herself, I wonder if it might be a relief for her possibly?
I would not forego the new car for this reason though. That would be far out of proportion in the circumstances.

RSALLAN2002 Sat 09-Aug-25 16:16:02

It must have been very cramped with 3 of you in a 2 seater car.

Mojack26 Sat 09-Aug-25 16:23:33

It's your car,not her's. Let her take her own car.

Witzend Sat 09-Aug-25 16:31:51

Cambia

Truddles tell it like it is!!! That’s just what I was thinking as I read and I laughed out loud!

Me too! If she’s got her own car, why does she need lifts anyway? Does she usually plan on downing a lot of 🍷🍷🍷?