Years ago, my husband and I and our two young daughters were expected to spend Christmas with either his parents or mine. No point arguing. If we did, that brought on sulks (my mother) and ‘collapsing’ (his mother) on the two occasions we tried it. So we gave in (looking back, we regretted that, but we were very young then). So, on Boxing Day, we would go to the parents we hadn’t spent Christmas Day with. We alternated this each year. So we were never allowed to spend Christmas on our own. My mother-in-law and my Dad hated each other, so we were never able to combine it all into one day together either. I didn’t like Christmas much!
This went on for years, then our elder daughter got engaged and was due to get married in May. We wanted to give her the best last ‘at home’ Christmas we could, so we asked her what she wanted to do. She immediately said she wanted to spend the day with us at our house, just us and her younger sister. No visiting and no visitors. Telling the parents was difficult. It didn’t go down well, but they all loved our daughter so it wasn’t too hard to persuade them to do as she asked. We had a wonderful day, just us and our two daughters and we all treasured it. Our future son-in-law happily did the same with his parents. It was the first time in 24 years we had been ‘allowed’ to have Christmas with just us. I have never forgiven both sets of parents for preventing us doing that before.
Obviously, we brought our daughter up to have more backbone than we did. On her first Christmas after getting married, she and her lovely husband said they wanted to spend it alone, but would be happy to get together on Boxing Day. We did that and everyone was happy (except the grandparents of course!). My husband and I visited both sets of parents but refused to stay for food. They didn’t like it, but tough! We just wished we had been stronger from the start.
Funnily enough, our daughters have had complete freedom to do what they want at Christmas, and, guess what? Most years they choose to spend Christmas Day with us!