Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Parents being used for constant childcare by sister

(57 Posts)
dorsetpennt Mon 20-Aug-12 11:34:00

Can't you and your other sister have a chat with the younger sister? I think Elegran has said it inasmuch as you should not be tactful. Maybe your sister doesn't feel confident and a bit overwhelmed by parenthood. Remove the computer, say it's gone to be repaired. Why can't your parents say to her enough, or come up with a plan such as her coming around a few mornings a week ONLY. Are you all able to chat to her husband? It seems you all complain but don't talk like a lot of families.
It's time for her to step up and take charge of her own family and let your parents enjoy retirement. She may get upset and make a few threats, but believe me she knows when she is well off.

Elegran Mon 20-Aug-12 11:15:53

Whose computer is it? Not easy to "break" it if it belongs to sister.

I think in the circumstances I would not be too tactful for too long. If things do not improve, she needs to realise that her parents are not Superman and Superwoman and that the children are hers, they are not primarily their grandparents responsibility. If she does not, she will find that they become too tired and ill to be any help at all.

absentgrana Mon 20-Aug-12 11:13:00

If it's not possible to have your parents come to stay with you for a break, how about going out somewhere on a day trip now and again?

Elegran Mon 20-Aug-12 11:11:43

Are you at home during the day? You could ask your parents round for the day as often as you can - without your sister - saying "I see them so seldom on their own" when you tell her that they will be at yours on such a day. If you are at work all week, how about them coming to you on a weekend day?

They could arrange to go out somewhere else, too, and not always be around.

You could say "Mum is looking very tired recently. I hope she is not ill. Is she doing too much? Keep an eye on her while you are there tomorrow and make sure she rests." Phone her in the evening after she gets home and ask how Mum was looking today. If she has any sensitivity she should connect daily childminding with tiredness without you mentioning it.

You could look look out for exciting things for children to do in the neighbourhood and tell her that they sound like just the thing for her children. Are there any playgroups or mother and child groups around? Sounds as though they need some romping in the open air too to get rid of some energy.

AlisonMA Mon 20-Aug-12 11:09:31

Can you 'break' the computer? At least then she would have no reason to leave your parents alone with the children?

I agree with Bags about getting them away and make sure your sister doesn't come too.

Could you be 'concerned' that your sister doesn't have many friends like her and suggest places she could go to meet them, mums and tots, todler gyms etc.? Places where she would need to take the children with her.

Bags Mon 20-Aug-12 10:57:28

Suggest she reads this article by Jilly Cooper about grannies not being nannies

Might be a start.

Could you have your parents come and stay with you for a break?

SallyAnn Mon 20-Aug-12 10:48:10

Background: Parents are pensioners - nearing 70. I am the eldest of three daughters. Sister in question is the youngest, late 20's. Myself and middle sister live about 1 hour away, youngest sister lives 5 minutes up the road. We all have children. Children of youngest sister: 2 and 5.

Problem: Sister is constantly around parent's house with said children. Parents are being used as childcare day in, day out. She will turn up in the morning - and stay put till her hubby gets back from work. She will go upstairs and sit on computer, checking facebook, mumsnet etc. Kids are left roaming around downtairs usually - mum and dad left watching them, dealing with food requests and general children wants and needs. If parents need to go out - sister and children will accompany them.

Mum has confided to me that she is very tired and having the children there almost constantly is becoming very draining. They start screaming and being loud as kids will and mum says that she finds herself starting to shake and becoming anxious. I will ring her up to see how she is early evening and I can hear them all romping and screaming in the background. I will say, 'it sounds busy, where is 'J'' - mum replies, 'she is sitting on the computer'. It is making my mum ill and she will not say anything to her. My dad is not in the best of health either.

We will go round to see them at weekends, and sister will even turn up then, depending on what her hubby is doing. I rarely get to see my parents on their own. This sounds petty I know but I would like to see them without having to see her and her offspring!

Mum says I mustn't say anything to her - I am not sure. I feel that if I start to say something I will not stop, there will be a huge fight. I feel she is being selfish.

So Gransnet - what should I do? Put up and shut up knowing my mum is becoming ill? Or start World War 3 by suggesting that she could perhaps look after her own children and stop abusing mum and dad's good nature. Am I just jealous because she has free childcare when I haven't? Sorry so long. Ask questions if you think I have left anything out. Thank-you.