Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Winter Flu Jabs - for or against?

(180 Posts)
grannysue05 Sun 08-Oct-17 14:27:15

The letters have dropped on our mats this weekend....You know, the invitation to attend for flu jabs.
DH and I have never opted for the jabs, and , fingers crossed, have only had real flu twice in all our years (late seventies).
We have friends who religiously take up the offer. Most have a 'reaction" within days, but that passes. The sore arm goes on for a week or more.
Most of the friends have then gone on to catch flu later in that paticular winter. Mostly from GC's .
I have read that the treated virus's are taken from the previous years' flu epidemic, and a mix is made up from this.
The flu that arrives each season has mutated from the previous year, so the actual vaccination serum is not really relevant.
Are we wise to keep pumping in these foreign bodies?
Can we not rely on our immune systems?

heath480 Thu 12-Oct-17 17:37:08

I would not deam of not having the flu jab every year.I had flu in my 30's,have never been so ill in my life.

Just had mine for this year,done at my local pharmacy,not even a sore arm.

W11girl Thu 12-Oct-17 23:02:32

I have had the jab for the past ten years, no flu, not even a cold!! and no sore arm. Me thinks I'll stick with it.

gordino Thu 12-Oct-17 23:11:01

When we get older, our immune system gets weaker,so the flue jab must help.

Granny23 Fri 13-Oct-17 00:28:39

In 1957 DH, then a 16 year old apprentice was offered the Polio vaccine at college but his mother refused to sign the consent form as she had heard that the vaccine had made some people ill and anyway there had been no new cases locally for a while. Later that year DH attended the Scouts Jubilee Jamboree at Sutton Coldfield, mixing with fellow Scouts from all round the world. When he returned home he went straight back to work although he was feeling increasingly unwell and weak. Eventually collapsed and was diagnosed with Polio and admitted to the Polio ward at the ID hospital - the very last patient to be admitted there. He lost muscle tissue in his left shoulder, arm and hand, has never been able to lift that arm above his waist and still has pain there daily.

Needless to say all our family, have had every vaccination offered.

Witzend Fri 13-Oct-17 05:57:17

I'll be having it - must remember to make appt!
Have only had real flu once, but it knocked my stuffing right out for a full 3 weeks. Especially since I now have very little Gdcs I see a lot, one of whom has been in hospital 3 times with bronchiolitis - thankfully, touch wood, he seems to be growing out of it.
Even when I was considerably better after my dose of flu, and out with dd walking the dog, I remember her saying, 'Can't you walk a little bit faster, Mum?'
'Sorry, darling, I really can't.'

People who call a bad cold 'flu' are apt to get a very nasty shock if they ever get the real thing.

Anya Fri 13-Oct-17 07:57:33

NanKate

Found this hope it helps.

Gemmag Fri 13-Oct-17 11:41:44

Each to their own.

My DH and I are having flu and shingles jabs tomorrow.
Much rather a sore arm for a day or two then a week in bed!.
2 of my friends are retired GPs and my best friends DH is a retired GP and others members of her family are doctors as is my DDiL. They all agree that it's better to err on the safe side.

CardiffJaguar Fri 13-Oct-17 12:27:58

My understanding of the vaccination is that it is harmless because it does not contain any ingredients. Every germ has an identifiable picture in 3D. Our immune systems are recognising the pictures of good and bad matter, lesving the good ones but attacking the bad ones.

So it recognises the picture of the latest flu jab and fights that if it arrives in our body. It does not need to know whether the inside is harmless or bad, it just fights it.

Latest research is trying to replicate about 10 flu virus pictures in one jab and making this so that a yearly jab may not be necessary. I know that the flu virus changes but somehow science has a way of dealing with this.

For the record I have never had any reaction in all the years I have been having the jab. My wife, however, has had a sore arm some years but no reaction. So it must depend upon the person, not the jab.

ginny Fri 13-Oct-17 13:29:50

48 hours on from having my jab. No effects of any sort not even a sore arm.

travelsafar Fri 13-Oct-17 13:43:17

My first ever jab this year. No effects what so ever. Being as i have returned to work with the elderly one day a week i am glad i had it done, they cant pass to me and i more importantly as i mix more, wont pass to them.

harrigran Fri 13-Oct-17 14:04:27

All my family are in the UK this weekend and have flown in from numerous destinations, I didn't want to be the one who caught flu passed on by plane passengers so have had my vaccine.

NanKate Fri 13-Oct-17 14:19:21

Thanks Anya ?

Anya Fri 13-Oct-17 14:51:39

CardiffJaguar there is something else to consider.

It sounds unlikely, but you can't make a flu vaccine without breaking a few eggs.
The only manufacturer of the flu jab in the UK is Novartis, based Liverpool - which makes 30 million of the jabs a year for the global market.
Chickens play a crucial role in the process.
Hens' eggs began to be used to grow the flu virus in the 1940's because they provided the right conditions and nutrients.
Five drug companies now manufacture the world's flu vaccines and 70 years later all of them use eggs to grow the vaccine.
The NHS buys nearly 16 million doses a year.
The person in charge of quality control on the Novartis production says : "Twelve times a day we get a delivery of 12 trolleys full of eggs. Each trolley has 5,500 eggs, so half a million each day. They stay in a warm room which is kept at constant temperature of 20 degrees Celsius."

When the eggs have come out of the warm storage room they are inoculated with a small amount of flu virus.
He added: "Each needle will go into an individual egg and inject it with 2 millilitres of flu virus. They then get taken into incubators for 72 hours.
"About 40 trolleys go into the incubators which are temperature and humidity controlled to 35 degrees Celsius and the virus inside will grow.
"When the eggs come out of incubation they go into the harvest area where we use a huge egg cutter to take the top of the shell off.
"The blade runs across the top and a probe will suck out the allantoic fluid, the liquid near the edge of the shell, and that is effectively a version of the flu virus. We start this process at 6am in the morning and it continues for eight hours."

The eggs are sourced from special farms based in the UK, where tight biosecurity controls and immunisations guard against diseases which might damage egg quality.

Anya Fri 13-Oct-17 14:56:21

Thought this might be of interest. And yes, they are looking at other ways of producing vaccines, but early days yet.

Granny23 Fri 13-Oct-17 15:03:21

Fascinating Anya

Anya Fri 13-Oct-17 15:06:22

Ain’t it just!

JessM Fri 13-Oct-17 15:56:28

wow! Interesting. Somewhere there are chicken farms supplying fertile eggs for this niche market.
I inspired young friend who has just started Cambridge to get one today. She reckons she can't afford a day off, let alone a week or more. Sensible girl.

Teetime Fri 13-Oct-17 16:00:28

Just off to get mine have had it for the last I don't know how many years since getting flu in the 80s which all but killed me. Never had it since. DH has just had his and meningococcus vaccine- we are both immunocompromised and don't take chances - or get reactions either.

Anya Fri 13-Oct-17 16:36:46

Does it say fertile eggs ?????..

JessM Fri 13-Oct-17 16:57:40

They do have to be fertile.

spottysocks Fri 13-Oct-17 18:46:13

Well, I've just had my first ever flu jab today in Adsa for £5. I'm 63 and have already had flu earlier this year and a chest infection and don't want another. Can't aford the time off work. So far my arm is a little sore but otherwise I feel ok. £5 well spent I think!

callgirl1 Fri 13-Oct-17 21:55:19

I was waiting for my prescription at the chemist`s this morning, and the pharmacist came and asked if I wanted the flu jab. I`ve been having them since I was 65, but missed out last year. He asked me to stay for about 5 minutes to make sure I was OK, after warning me that I could have a sore arm or feel unwell for a couple of days. Well, my arm is fine, and I feel OK, but for some reason I was extremely lethargic all afternoon, don`t know if it was to do with the jab or not. As I was leaving, he also informed me of the risk of
anaphylactic shock!

Anya Sat 14-Oct-17 08:04:15

The fact that the eggs have to be fertilised is mind blowing. I’m just thinking of the logistics of putting sufficient hens to sufficient cockerels; cleaning the eggs but then checking every single one has been fertilised.

I’m guessed it must all be done by some sort of automation process.

And that’s 500,000 a day.

JessM Sat 14-Oct-17 09:07:37

Yup it is amazing isn't it. I think the cockerels probably have a pretty good hit rate. smile They can probably tell if the egg is fertilised by shining a bright light through the eggs or something like that.
Gosh ASDA used to be £8 - which was roughly the cost of the vaccine. They'll be hoping you do some shopping at the same time! Boots is £12.50 and local pharmacists maybe cheaper. But I'd willingly pay £12.50 to not have a single day of flu.

annodomini Sat 14-Oct-17 09:37:51

Which reminds me, I must get organised and go to the drop-in session this morning. Wouldn't miss it!