Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Child minding.

(66 Posts)
thomsnannie2 Fri 13-Jul-18 09:13:51

My D.I.L has a new baby and a 4 year old. She has accepted my offer of helping out during the school summer break. Her suggestion is 3 days per week at 4 hours a day.She wants to pay me £5 per hour. I really can't accept this from her. I am so glad that she has accepted my offer to help as gets very anxious on these three days my son is working. What rate would you suggest. She was going to engage a nanny at £19 per hour in her desperation, which they cannot afford. But is adamant that she wants to pay me child minding rate. My husband is happy for me to help but concerned that at 69 and the hour journey each way justifies his reasoning that I should be paid.advice please.

crazyH Sat 14-Jul-18 17:49:20

Legs55 ....here it comes ...? .....duck !!!!’?
Neither well off nor a saint .....just stupid ?

amt101 Sat 14-Jul-18 18:02:41

I'm 73 and travel an hour each way to look after my beautiful granddaughter. I would never accept money as it's a joy looking after her and we have a wonderful bond. Do it for the memories she will have of you.

Greenfinch Sat 14-Jul-18 18:37:28

This is a difficult one : I would never accept money for looking after grandchildren but ,if the boot were on the other foot, for example if my DD offered to do some regular housework for me, I would not accept unless she accepted some sort of payment.

Jalima1108 Sat 14-Jul-18 19:23:25

I suppose acceptance of money is dependent on several factors - would it make the person who wants to give the money feel better? Are you existing on a very low income and this could make a difference between just surviving or living more comfortably? Are you giving up the chance of working for the joy of looking after the DGC?

Those who are comfortably off could do well to ponder other people's situations.

(not meaning to sound prissy!)

Nanna58 Sat 14-Jul-18 21:10:43

Very bewildered, does DIL work? If not why would she need a nanny?

NfkDumpling Sat 14-Jul-18 22:01:34

I’m with those who say take the money and save it for the DGC. If only to pay for treats and uniform when the oldest starts school.

This is a long term commitment though, maybe even until the youngest is old enough to walk home from school and be left alone (about twelve years?) - be sure you want to take it on.

Beau Sun 15-Jul-18 06:33:27

thomsnannie please be aware that people in that state of mind can be very unpredictable - speaking from experience it will not be all sweetness and light but hopefully as you can go home each night things will be fine. Keep the money for treats for the DGC and grow a thick skin, you might need it ?

cc Sun 15-Jul-18 16:12:53

I couldn't accept money either.
I don't live near to my grandchildren and am very happy when my DIL asks if I could help out with childcare in the holidays whilst she is working. She's never offered me money, but goes out of her way to let me know how much she appreciates my help, which is all I need.

gmelon Sun 15-Jul-18 16:23:11

When the six weeks holiday are up spend the money on school supplies/extra uniform/school bag for the elder child.

Or treat them to a day out.

I think the theatre tickets idea was very clever.

Humbertbear Mon 16-Jul-18 08:36:57

Take the money because it makes her feel better and save it to buy the children something when they are older. My DiL has never offered me petrol money (and we used to do 180 miles a week) and doesnt even leave us a meal when we babysit in the evening even if we are there to feed the children.

gmelon Mon 16-Jul-18 16:03:31

I've re read your OP. I think the hours journey on a bus is a bit much. Your efforts should be very much appreciated and I really hope that the heat or any type of adverse weather doesn't affect you on the two hour round trip.
Are you doing this as a long term arrangement? Can your husband drive you there and stay and help?

Riggie Mon 16-Jul-18 18:02:41

Can you suggest that she pays your travel expenses, provides any meal you have there plus out of pocket expenses (E.g. parking, admission food for kids and you when out).

If you don't want the money and she insists then pop it into an account to treat the kids to some days out.

Flossieturner Tue 17-Jul-18 09:26:49

Please take the money. This is very much about boosting her self esteem and giving her confidence, I think it is a bit unkind to reject it. Have you ever considered that deep down she really wanted the nanny, but is being kind to you?It would boost her morale to feel she is doing something for you, helping you as it were . Much better than being beholden to you which will add to her feelings of inadequacy,

I think that you should think about something specific that you want and perhaps take her with you to choose it. When ever I bought a gift for my mother she would say, “oh you should not have spent your money on me. You have enough to do with it”. Just once it would a relief if she had behaved graciously.

Bluegal Tue 17-Jul-18 10:43:58

I am looking after grandchildren during the summer holidays AND being paid. Reason being I cannot work myself during the time am looking after them. Depending on your circumstances I don’t think there is anything wrong in accepting payment for regular childminding. It generally saves the parents money and puts their minds at ease that they are not exploiting the good nature of GP’s.

glammanana Tue 17-Jul-18 15:42:45

I would accept payment if it makes your DIL feel better and save it for a long week-end away with your hubby at a later date.