Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

It really irks me!

(169 Posts)
Ali08 Tue 29-Jun-21 08:51:53

When I got married my maiden name was 'put in a box and forgotten about' for want of a better way to put it!
But why, even after 10 or so years, is Prince William's wife, Catherine, STILL referred to by her maiden name?
And Harry's wife the same?
Why do the media insist on calling them Catherine/Kate Middleton and Meghan Markle instead of using their husbands surname, Mountbatten-Winsdor?
And also, why have we women, in general, stopped being known as Mrs. or Miss but instead are referred to as Ms. or Miss regardless of marital statuses?
Is this just laziness of the media? Can't they be bothered to use our correct titles anymore?

greenlady102 Wed 30-Jun-21 16:53:40

sodapop

greenlady102

well yes but your birth name is another man's name too....

Not necessarily greenlady unless you go back further generations. My birth mother was unmarried so my first surname was hers.
I agree that changing ones name on marriage is now outdated. Men have never had to indicate their marital status in this way.

Indeed but in general, your maiden surname is your father's surname. When I married it was the 70's and the thing about not taking your husband's name was bubbling up with Lib. My take was that it didn't make any difference as I was just exchanging one beloved man's name for another.

Mamgujane Wed 30-Jun-21 16:52:21

The No! No! No! was for the suggestion the Ms was for divorced women. Well done you GrammarGrandma; we decided not to get married and even in the 80s I was criticised for having a child out of wedlock shock The name at the end of my hospital bed was Mrs. I changed it, which led to a row with the ward sister. And they automatically tried to send me to see a social worker instead of a health visitor; she had to admit I knew more about maternity leave, benefits etc than she did. Oh such dinosaur ideas!

Mamgujane Wed 30-Jun-21 16:40:24

No! No! No! Ms was created in the late 60s/early 70s by women like me (in the Women’s Liberation movement) who were fed up with their marital status being immediately apparent, unlike men who are always Mr.
There is no legal requirement for women to take their husband’s name (where on earth is the sense in that?) or to be called Mrs upon marriage.
It is a popular misconception that Ms is used for divorced women.
In the UK, you can call yourself whatever you like. You don’t actually need to do the deed poll thing, though it possibly makes things easier. If I wake up tomorrow and decide to call myself Poppy Tartt, I can.

GrammarGrandma Wed 30-Jun-21 16:36:04

I did not change my name on marriage in 1972. I had one of the first passports to have Ms on them (they don't put courtesy titles now.)

I am not Miss, because I am not single, and I am not Mrs H, because I am not married to myself! Ms is perfect.

notnecessarilywiser Wed 30-Jun-21 15:57:15

Ali08

Ms. is the shortened version of Mizz which notifies the woman is divorced!
Or, at least it did originally!!
So many things have been changed to suit new generations.

Sorry to disagree, but the original purpose of Ms was to give a title to a female that made no reference to her marital status, in the same way the Mr had always done for men. It was considered (righly, IMO) that the marital status was irrelevant to the vast majority of situations where a title was required.

Mumsyface Wed 30-Jun-21 15:26:41

I have a friend who changed his name to his wife’s when they got married. When I asked him why (idle curiosity, no judgment) he told me his family name had been ‘Bustard’ and he had been teased all through school because of it. Seems like a good reason to me ?

I’ve never used either of my husbands family names,. However, when I got divorced from the first one the clerk at the court insisted I sign the papers in a married name despite never had had or used a married name. I was too young and naive to fight back although I now think I should have. ?

4allweknow Wed 30-Jun-21 14:52:57

Shoud be Catherine/Megan Countess of ...... Quite a mouthful other than when being written. Media easier to identify which by using actual names. Sure if either women objected media would be told by the official parties. As to loss of Mrs/Miss females have driven this not wanting to be identified as married or not. Not too long until any kind of identification eg male or female will be lost too, we will be a them, they or it!

GoldenLady Wed 30-Jun-21 14:32:47

Maybe it's different here in America, but every woman chooses to use Mrs. or Ms. according to her preference. I don't think "Miss" is used at all any more. It sounds like a quaint anachronism.

The use of Ms. or Mrs. is entirely a matter of preference, and has nothing to do with whether a woman is divorced or not. No one to my knowledge uses Mrs. unless she is actually married, or has been. But I am pretty sure that most single women use Ms., regardless of the reason they are single. Some married women prefer it as well.

I am widowed, and switched from Mrs. to Ms. when my husband passed away. It has nothing to do with divorce.

Grandma70s Wed 30-Jun-21 14:24:37

I wish I’d kept my birth name. It was a much more interesting name than my married one, but very difficult to spell and pronounce, so I took the lazy way out! That was in 1968. I’ve been widowed for along time now, and still feel I have the wrong name.

My DIL has kept her own name, I’m glad to say, though the children have my son’s name. Other younger married women in my family have taken their husband’s name, which amazes me in this day and age.

My DIL knows a couple who didn’t like either of their surnames, so they chose a name they did like and use that. Good idea.

homefarm Wed 30-Jun-21 14:14:23

The whole thing can be very annoying at times. I have a so called friend who insists on introducing/writing to me as Mrs "John Homefarm" even though she knows I don't like it and I've asked her not to. I always used my maiden name for work.

Yangste1007 Wed 30-Jun-21 14:01:40

I changed my surname on marriage because I hated my maiden name. Also if you have children it makes life much easier if you all have the same name, especially when travelling. If I were to divorce I would not return to my maiden name but would prefer to use either my mother's or grandmother's maiden names. I always thought that Ms was used by someone who did not want their marital status known. A friend of mine, although divorced for many years, still refers to herself as Mrs. because she feels she gets more respect from tradesmen etc.

Grannycool52 Wed 30-Jun-21 14:01:27

Why would you want to change your own name to someone else's, even when you love them?
I have retained my own family surname although I am married. I also prefer to be addressed as Ms rather than Mrs, as my marital status should be irrelevant in most situations.

GillT57 Wed 30-Jun-21 14:01:16

Ms does not indicate a divorced woman. My married status is irrelevant in most instances. A Dr is a Dr. A Rev is a Rev.

StoneofDestiny Wed 30-Jun-21 13:49:54

Many women keep their own family name regardless of marriage. Many use Ms as they don't think their marital status is relevant to anybody but them. Certainly drives me mad being asked in the most ridiculous situations 'is it Miss or Mrs'.

I think we should just say it Rev - ?

StoneofDestiny Wed 30-Jun-21 13:47:12

When I went to Scotland looking up graves in a cemetery. I found all the women were given maiden name on headstone

It was common to have the mothers name as your second name - so Catriona Dalkeith MacDonald. Not double barrelled, just a second first name.

Stella14 Wed 30-Jun-21 13:45:48

I’m a Ms because my marital status is irrelevant in addressing me. I also think a woman changing her name to her husband’s is a patriarchal anachronism.

Ydoc Wed 30-Jun-21 13:39:57

When i went to scotland looking up graves in a cemetery. I found all the women were given maiden name on headstone

Lolee Wed 30-Jun-21 13:39:47

Ms denotes being single. If you're divorced in the UK, the formal address would be Mrs + your Christian name + your married surname. Informally, you can call yourself whatever you like, especially if patriarchy isn't your thing.

GrammaH Wed 30-Jun-21 13:29:20

I took DH's surname when we married 40 years ago. I wish now I'd kept mine as our line of the family has now died out. I could've double barrelled the 2 together & our children would've had it & I never thought to give it to them as middle names. Hindsight is great isn't it?!

sodapop Wed 30-Jun-21 13:15:50

greenlady102

well yes but your birth name is another man's name too....

Not necessarily greenlady unless you go back further generations. My birth mother was unmarried so my first surname was hers.
I agree that changing ones name on marriage is now outdated. Men have never had to indicate their marital status in this way.

Naninka Wed 30-Jun-21 13:10:55

I think of maidens dancing around a maypole with flowers in their hair. Nubile young virgins with flowing robes.
I'm the exact opposite. Lol.

Coco51 Wed 30-Jun-21 13:05:04

My neighbour changed his surname to his wife’s on marriage. I wonder how many others are out there?
I reverted to my maiden name on divorce. I used to hate the Ms title but now prefer it - and it does serve a purpose when you don’t know if you are addressing a Miss or a Mrs

SueEH Wed 30-Jun-21 13:00:52

I never wanted to get married or change my name but eventually had to conform. Kept my maiden name for work but then moved up north where it all got a bit confusing so I ended up as Mrs B.
Now happily divorced I’m back to my maiden name and Ms. I also address things to my adult daughters as Ms as consider their marital status to be no-one else’s business.
My own mother however insists on calling me Mrs (maiden name) as she feels that it’s more respectable at my age to be a Mrs hmm

grandtanteJE65 Wed 30-Jun-21 12:49:42

I believe it is quite rare for younger women to change their surname on marriage now in Denmark where I live.

When I married, DH would quite have liked us to both use my surname, but I was so tired of having my Scottish surname misspelt, misfiled and never pronounced correctly that I opted for us both using his Danish surname.

In the instances you cite, OP, I imagine it is just the media either assuming that we all know these young women by their family name, or assuming that they, like most young wives nowadays ,would be offended by the use of their husbands' surname.

It could be a form of snobbery: insisting on telling us all the time that neither woman is of Royal birth!

mumagain Wed 30-Jun-21 12:45:17

Ali08

Ms. is the shortened version of Mizz which notifies the woman is divorced!
Or, at least it did originally!!
So many things have been changed to suit new generations.

www.grammarly.com/blog/ms-mrs-miss-difference/
Ms doesn’t mean divorced