Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Cremation that no-one attends

(154 Posts)
Athenia Thu 12-Aug-21 02:18:35

My late ex-husband told none of his family or friends that he was terminally ill, and chose to have his body cremated with no-one present.
This is a new concept to me.
Does anyone have any members of their family who have chosen this?
It is obviously cheaper than a funeral, but seems very strange to me.

Witzend Thu 12-Aug-21 11:54:34

We have Parsee friends in India (well, just one now, since his wife died.). Their bodies go on a very high platform for birds and Nature to see to. IIRC the places are called, ‘Palace of the Winds’ - we saw the Mumbai one from a distance while we were there some years ago - quiet place, surrounded by trees.

Obviously not practical for many millions, but seemed like a nice idea to me.

Ladyleftfieldlover Thu 12-Aug-21 12:05:39

A couple of years ago our neighbour died. He had left instructions that no one should attend his cremation apart from the vicar. So the hearse arrived outside his house and in hopped the vicar. In the meantime his wife and family had gone to the local pub to celebrate his life.

MerylStreep Thu 12-Aug-21 12:09:32

My body is donated to science. I’ve been told that the family can have the body back after 3 years.
I asked my daughter if she wanted the body back. The answer was, Nooooo!!!!!!

Oopsadaisy1 Thu 12-Aug-21 12:22:30

merylstreep do you have a back up plan is case your body is not accepted?

jaylucy Thu 12-Aug-21 12:28:25

I have been to several funerals where the remains have gone to the crematorium without family or friends and even one where the deceased was cremated in the morning and the service was in the afternoon!
I think that the "simple cremations" companies that currently advertis on TV work on that principle that the remains are collected, cremated and the ashes returned to the family .
The family can still decide if they would like to hold a religious service or just a wake - the deceased, I think , has already gone so sadly will not be able to enjoy whatever is decided, it is more for the family and friends left behind

Pittcity Thu 12-Aug-21 12:34:09

I'm with Rosie in that I want my next of kin to decide what they want to do with me. I won't be there.

MerylStreep Thu 12-Aug-21 12:44:09

Oopsadaisy
Do you mean if the university doesn’t want my body ( bloody cheek if they don’t ?)
I’ll leave that to the family. They know my views on expensive funerals. ?

PippaZ Thu 12-Aug-21 12:46:50

There are quite a few companies doing this. I have looked at the one mentioned above. It just separates the "personal farewell" from the cremation. It's what I would like to do and my children don't seem to have any problems with it.

PippaZ Thu 12-Aug-21 12:50:31

Pittcity

I'm with Rosie in that I want my next of kin to decide what they want to do with me. I won't be there.

That would be more difficult if you pre-pay for your funeral. Then the company would be obliged to do what you had laid out.

tiredoldwoman Thu 12-Aug-21 13:03:34

I think David Bowie did something like this ?

tiredoldwoman Thu 12-Aug-21 13:05:15

Which made his death even sadder but it was what he wanted and I actually rather like his idea for me .

Oopsadaisy1 Thu 12-Aug-21 13:10:55

merylstreep I’m sure they will welcome you with open arms!
Apparently though if you have any ‘bits’ removed ie a kidney or whatever they don’t want you.
PippaZ MIL had prepaid for a ‘proper’ funeral, we had a direct funeral but no refund was given.

Zoejory Thu 12-Aug-21 13:12:01

My grandmother wanted to donate her body for science but they didn't want it. It's not as simple as it sounds.

Shinamae Thu 12-Aug-21 13:14:52

Mine is already decided, and paid for,Pure cremation, ashes return to the family and when they ready be that the next day,the next month or the next year they will scatter them at the beach that I frequented a lot as a child and then on the way home I want them to have a slap up meal and raise a few glasses to me ??that is far more personal than standing in a gloomy crematorium as far as l am concerned…I have been to a lot of funerals and people turn up to the funeral who the deceased has not seen or heard of for years… I find that particularly upsetting…Just coming to have a nose, see who’s wearing what and who provided the best Bouquet/wreath.. obviously not all funerals are like that but as a care home worker for many years I have attended many funerals to pay my respects… have also had heard some not so nice comments made about the deceased.. so not for me a pure and simple cremation..

Shinamae Thu 12-Aug-21 13:16:20

That last sentence reads as though pure cremation is not for me but it shouldn’t,it’s meant to say that it’s definitely for me!!

Mishy Thu 12-Aug-21 13:22:03

If I outlive my DH, I am having a no one present cremation as I am familyless. At least it keep everything simple.

Rosie51 Thu 12-Aug-21 13:31:30

I've prepaid for my cremation funeral, and although the hearse and one car has been paid for I shall be telling my children not to bother going along unless they need to for their grieving process. My parents were both cremated, with a service at the crematorium, but we never got the ashes back, didn't feel the need to personally scatter them. They were scattered by a worker from the crematorium in the garden of remembrance. My children can decide what happens to my ashes, I shan't care.

Hithere Thu 12-Aug-21 14:52:20

The idea of simple cremation looks great to me!

kissngate Thu 12-Aug-21 16:45:48

My DS fil requested this a few years ago when he was terminally ill. I thought it odd at the time but I dont now. He didnt want any fuss said they hadnt to waste money on a funeral service but after he died my dil said she was going to the crematorium regardless. He was a lovely guy with lots of friends and relatives but they honoured his wishes. Since then its become more and more common. There was a direct burial in the local cemetery the other week, no church service just a few words spoken by family around the grave.

GreyKnitter Thu 12-Aug-21 16:55:10

It’s a tricky subject isn’t it and every situation is different. I find it helpful to attend the cremation of close family and friends and be part of a uniting grieving process, where it in ok to shed a tear as we say our shared goodbyes. I really struggled with missing the cremation of a close friend at the beginning of the first lockdown - her death was not COVID a related but obviously all funerals were effected. Her children kindly sent me info re the music they were having and readings so I could share from afar. It was the bagpipes that got to me!

Chestnut Thu 12-Aug-21 17:02:10

I think the loved ones would benefit from a small cremation service. There are just a few of them, not to include the wider family or extra people. Then they could have a lovely tea and scones somewhere nice and quiet. Just simple but at least a chance for them to say goodbye. What to do with my ashes is the big question, and I really can't decide. I'd really like a headstone because I think it's nice for people to have somewhere to visit, but have no idea where.

Grannynannywanny Thu 12-Aug-21 17:16:28

With regard to donating your body to medical science it’s important to have a plan B. The final decision on whether a body is accepted is made at the time of death.

Several factors are taken into consideration such as types of illness, surgeries performed etc. Or quite simply the university anatomy dept may already have reached their quota for the year.

Hetty58 Thu 12-Aug-21 18:12:58

Athenia, I've chosen an unaccompanied cremation - and pre-paid for it too. My ashes will be taken to my daughter.

My family are welcome to have a party, get-together - or memorial service, though. They can arrange whatever they want, I just don't want my dead body there!

I've always found funerals so awkward and fake. A minister (or celebrant) asks family all about the person - then tells them (which is ridiculous) - leaving out anything too interesting or negative, of course!

LovelyLady Sat 14-Aug-21 10:44:39

I could accept this ‘no one at the funeral’ when the individual plans this themselves. When family arrange this, I feel sad. Every life is of value.
When some say, I won’t be there, so I don’t care - how selfish not to have put something in place to alleviate pressure of the ones left behind.

razzmatazz Sat 14-Aug-21 10:44:45

Spice101. This is exactly what I have chosen to do. I have paid for a cremation partly because I didn't want my family to have to pay thousands . This is a company which charges a minimal sum of £1,400 . I have told my family to have a get together and celebrate my life with a meal and laughter. I do not want anyone crying in particular my grandchildren . I want them to remember me with love and laughter and celebrate the happiness that they and all my family gave me .