Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Do you believe everything you are told?

(127 Posts)
Calmlocket Sun 07-Nov-21 08:37:43

Do you believe something because some people have told you it’s true, even though by simple research on your own you would find it is not, so you just believe them instead of doing the research, why?

Cossy Mon 08-Nov-21 11:49:55

I’m a real sceptic and check quite a lot of things either with others or Mr Google, especially science/medical stuff or things I’m not very aware/knowledgable about

StoneofDestiny Mon 08-Nov-21 11:50:27

If it was important I'd certainly check it out. More so if it was someone whom I had no reason to trust.

maddyone Mon 08-Nov-21 11:51:25

Smileless2012

It depends what it is and whose telling me.

Absolutely.

clair1966 Mon 08-Nov-21 11:53:13

I love the way the majority of Brits believe children can not catch Covid19 because the government told them so. Perhaps they think children are not actually human beings until they turn 16 at which point they can catch human transmitted viruses like the rest of the human race.

soldiersailor Mon 08-Nov-21 11:56:20

On so called climate change and the 'climate crisis' , absolutely not!!
It amazes me how many of the gullible public seem to have swallowed the announcements of imminent doom when with about 5 minutes of checking they can see factual information, baked up by science to prove the opposite.
Prince Charles really should know better.

sazz1 Mon 08-Nov-21 11:56:44

No I don't until I've researched it or checked it out.
However I have found some unbelievable things to be true told to me by customers at a cafe I worked at. Also an environmental health student warned me about BSE a year before it was public knowledge

Theoddbird Mon 08-Nov-21 11:56:44

I have learnt not to believe everything. Chinese whispers...hahaha. Things get changed without people even realizing that they have. Google is a wonderful tool grin

Brownowl564 Mon 08-Nov-21 11:59:03

Of course not, especially with all rubbish being touted about Covid, vaccines etc at the moment, but if it’s something trivial it would depend if it sounded reasonable or not but I wouldn’t pass it on as gospel if I hadn’t checked first

Lucca Mon 08-Nov-21 11:59:41

soldiersailor

On so called climate change and the 'climate crisis' , absolutely not!!
It amazes me how many of the gullible public seem to have swallowed the announcements of imminent doom when with about 5 minutes of checking they can see factual information, baked up by science to prove the opposite.
Prince Charles really should know better.

Very strange post I’m my humble opinion. “So called climate change”??

soldiersailor Mon 08-Nov-21 12:04:06

Brian Cox and Boris Johnson have both fallen for the 'We're all doomed' approach to climate change. Cox in particular wants to ban all debate, which is odd as when I was at university I was urged to always challenge, always question, as by this means and by healthy scepticism science, and thus civilisation, advances. But that has changed and no university would promote such an attitude these days.
In the last ten years we've taken a sizeable backward step and I fear from my grandsons' future.

vonnie1 Mon 08-Nov-21 12:05:08

Definitely not,there are so many stories going around,which totally contradict each other! I always discount what I read in the papers,they all have their own agendas.

christine96777 Mon 08-Nov-21 12:06:51

I'm the same as you thanks to my mum, people don't always tell the truth, which is not always the same as telling a lie

Josianne Mon 08-Nov-21 12:07:48

clair1966

I love the way the majority of Brits believe children can not catch Covid19 because the government told them so. Perhaps they think children are not actually human beings until they turn 16 at which point they can catch human transmitted viruses like the rest of the human race.

Where were we Brits told by the government that younger children can not catch covid?
I think the majority wouldn't believe.

Panda25 Mon 08-Nov-21 12:08:27

I believe nothing that the Government in Westminster say.

Shirlb Mon 08-Nov-21 12:10:32

No don’t believe anything told or read?

Calmlocket Mon 08-Nov-21 12:16:51

clair1966

I love the way the majority of Brits believe children can not catch Covid19 because the government told them so. Perhaps they think children are not actually human beings until they turn 16 at which point they can catch human transmitted viruses like the rest of the human race.

I love the way people who have been vaccinated think they are immune of catching /spreading covid, when they are not fully protected and can still catch/spread covid and keep blaming the unvaccinated.

Alioop Mon 08-Nov-21 12:22:48

Depends on the person who is telling me and the importance of topic we are discussing.

Buttonjugs Mon 08-Nov-21 12:39:07

Absolutely not. I have a son who is a pathological liar, he says things that aren’t true when it seems pointless to do so. Or my ex husband who prefers to say what he thinks you want to hear. I don’t believe anything a Tory MP says, ever. I prefer to get my news from Twitter rather than mainstream media. I tend to err on the suspicious side because so many people are liars.

Buttercup1954 Mon 08-Nov-21 12:40:22

Some people just believe what they want to believe even if it's very obviously untrue sadly.

Buttonjugs Mon 08-Nov-21 12:40:54

Josianne

clair1966

I love the way the majority of Brits believe children can not catch Covid19 because the government told them so. Perhaps they think children are not actually human beings until they turn 16 at which point they can catch human transmitted viruses like the rest of the human race.

Where were we Brits told by the government that younger children can not catch covid?
I think the majority wouldn't believe.

It was never said that kids couldn’t catch Covid, only that they would be far less likely to become seriously ill with it.

kjmpde Mon 08-Nov-21 12:43:25

Like the Covid vaccine is helping tackle the virus despite the number of cases rising? I

Buttonjugs Mon 08-Nov-21 12:44:35

soldiersailor

Brian Cox and Boris Johnson have both fallen for the 'We're all doomed' approach to climate change. Cox in particular wants to ban all debate, which is odd as when I was at university I was urged to always challenge, always question, as by this means and by healthy scepticism science, and thus civilisation, advances. But that has changed and no university would promote such an attitude these days.
In the last ten years we've taken a sizeable backward step and I fear from my grandsons' future.

If you’re worried about the future of your grandchildren, then you should get on board with Climate Change. It’s scientists, not the government, who are urging us all to act. They’ve been saying it for years and the government have finally been pressured to address it. It’s real. Don’t be an ostrich.

Alegrias1 Mon 08-Nov-21 12:55:40

I quite like Brian Cox. I never realised he was such a tyrant. wink

muse Mon 08-Nov-21 12:59:23

I'm selective.

I believe the qualified professional experts such as my hip consultant. I'd not know how to attempt to find out if they are incorrect, let alone try to argue that they are incorrect.

I do not believe the non-experts, who despite their passionate conviction, may not be as accurate as they believe they are, or twist facts to encourage our belief. Then, I would do some research. Whether or not I would want to argue with such a person, is another question.

muse Mon 08-Nov-21 13:05:00

Alegrias1

I quite like Brian Cox. I never realised he was such a tyrant. wink

You want to see him play Lear ?