Gransnet forums

Blogs

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 12-May-16 14:48:23

Why home schooling is better than school

Would you be happy to see your grandchildren home schooled? Author Vanessa Ronan was home schooled by her parents and maintains that it was the best, and most empowering, decision they could have taken.

Vanessa Ronan

Why home schooling is better than school

Posted on: Thu 12-May-16 14:48:23

(80 comments )

Lead photo

Is homeschooling better than normal school?

When I was little and other kids found out I was home schooled, the first thing they'd always ask was "Do you get to sleep in as late as you want?" Usually followed by the next question: "Can you go to school in your pyjamas?" Most of them were jealous I got to stay home all day. What they didn't seem to realise was, even though I was home, I was still working hard too!

My parents started home schooling my brother and me intending it only for a couple of years till we moved "someplace better". It didn't take long for us to move; in fact, we moved many times as I grew up, but we ended up home schooling all the way until college. My parents were both literature professors, so there was definitely a strong emphasis placed on our writing from a very young age. That being said though, my brother and I naturally gravitated more towards that side of our studies. Writing stories and poems was almost like a game for us, and we’d read and edit each other's work from a very young age. We lived in Patzcuaro, a colonial village in the mountains of central Mexico for two and a half years. I was nearly eight when we came back to Texas, but I remember clearly how my parents sat my brother and me down and asked us if we wanted to go to 'normal school'.

If one particular subject matter fascinated, we were allowed and encouraged to study it to the fullest of our capabilities. It is only as an adult that I have realised what a truly remarkable gift that was.


In many ways, home schooling kept learning fun. When we were little, we were given breaks throughout the day to play for 15 minutes while my mother prepared our next lesson. Or else, we would be rewarded with getting to read a storybook just for fun! We then would come back to our studies twice as attentive, excess energies exhausted, minds ready to absorb again.

Home schooling let me learn at my own pace. I started at four, completed third grade in three months, graduated high school when I had just turned sixteen. I think I would have gotten bored quite easily had I been forced to adhere to the pace and rules of a classroom at too young an age. Bullying was never really an issue for us, but, through sports and activities, we still had friends.

Of course (especially closer to college), there were government requirements of certain things we were expected to learn, certain tests we had to take, but, as we grew, by and large my parents empowered us to study what truly interested us. If one particular subject matter fascinated, we were allowed and encouraged to study it to the fullest of our capabilities. It is only as an adult that I have realised what a truly remarkable gift that was.

Our creativity was nurtured and empowered though home schooling. We were encouraged to be ourselves. We were taught to think for ourselves. And yes, sometimes we even got to go to school in our pyjamas.

Vanessa's book The Last Days of Summer is published by Penguin Ireland and is available now on Amazon.

By Vanessa Ronan

Twitter: @VRonan

Leticia Thu 19-May-16 07:14:40

My friend who does it has the same- inspections, very friendly relationships durhamjen so perhaps you are unaware that you don't have to do this and there is little the inspector can do if they don't co operate. They have to rely on a written report. You seem to have common sense and perhaps it hasn't occurred to you that some families are hostile and shout 'go away' through the letter box. ( I am not making this up!)

granjura Thu 19-May-16 12:31:21

So it seems inspection is hit and miss- and that those who do it properly are inspected, and those who do it disastrously, do not! Makes sense ... not!

In parts of Switzerland where it is allowed- only qualified teachers are allowed to teach the children (not allowed in some C/Kantons at all- as where I live). I teach 3 French students who are musicians and homeschooled (secondary and post 16)- but they have to by Law follow the same curriculum and have the same exams as their peers- to ensure they have the same choices of further ed if they want to.

Leticia Thu 19-May-16 13:35:46

Not exactly, granjura . Some who do it really well refuse inspections because they don't see why they need to be accountable to the state and they don't want any involvement.
I expect that the majority are doing a good job, it isn't something anyone would enter into lightly. However, it is open to abuse or simply incompetence, and children can slip through the net. They are safer if they started in school and de registered because the authorities are aware. If they never start school they are more or less invisible.
I think it an appalling example to set to a child if you shout through the letter box rather than have a civilised conversation!
I think Switzerland is too tough if they have to be a teacher but I do think that parents who wish to do it must be registered, and have to be seen with access to the children. If they won't do this then the home education option should be taken away from them.
However it should be consistent across all local authorities and they should be inspectors who are enthusiastic about home education.

JessyPinky Tue 24-Nov-20 23:43:43

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

GMboxSMG2 Tue 22-Feb-22 15:58:49

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

LenaOan Tue 29-Mar-22 11:15:19

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.