Gransnet forums

Chat

Moving out of the family home due to age/mobility issues?

(33 Posts)
SummerOf75 Thu 15-Nov-12 16:28:20

Hello

I have come over from Mumsnet for some advice please!

My mum and dad are now in their mid 60s and mid 70s respectively. Dad has had problems with his spine for a number of years and is now struggling with his mobility - walking is painful and he finds getting in and out of the bath hard.

He is waiting to see a surgeon to find out if he is a good candidate for an operation.

They live in a 3 bed house with largeish garden and no downstairs WC/bath about 20 miles away from me and my family.

As I see it they can;

Stay where they are and struggle (I am NOT going to allow this!)

Stay where they are and add a downstairs WC/shower (I think they can probably afford to do this)

Move into a bungalow or retirement flat (financially the best option I think, they have paid off their mortgage and should theoretically be at least £30k up if they do this, a lot more if they go for a flat, and then they could have a few more luxuries)

Have any of you been in a similar situation? What did you do and how did you arrive at your decision?

I know they really don't want to move but I don't see how they can carry on living somewhere with no downstairs loo if my dad is struggling to get upstairs. There is plenty of scope for him to make a bedroom downstairs if he wanted.

Any words of wisdom for me? I would like them to move nearer to us but I understand why they want to stay where they are, they've been there a long time and have friends locally. Ultimately I think they have to consider the practical side of things wrt the house, if it doesn't suit their needs they will have to move somewhere that does.

My argument is that it would be better to move now while they are in relatively good health and can make the place how they like it, get out and about to meet new friends and enjoy any money they make on the house rather than be forced to move when they are ill/widowed/whatever.

I don't have any vested interest financially, I am the only child and tbh would rather inherit nothing than have them live a miserable old age.

I've been quite blunt with my mum about it (she can take it!) and am prepared to have the same talk with dad...

It occured to me that we could maybe sell our house too and buy somewhere big enough to share but dunno if my OH or my parents would like that! We have little kids too so maybe too noisy/stressful for oldies.

annodomini Thu 15-Nov-12 16:32:11

Your parents are lucky to have such a caring daughter. All the possible solutions sound feasible but I do understand why you'd like to have them closer to you. See how your dad gets on with the consultant and if he does have surgery that helps with his mobility problem, then the options may change. Good luck to all of you.

matson Thu 15-Nov-12 16:33:26

if they are happy where they are, i would be inclined to invest in a downstairs loo and shower room and if money allows a stairlift. then review the situation again in a few years. its good to keep as much independence as you can.

tanith Thu 15-Nov-12 16:36:02

Have you actually asked your parents what their opinion is of all that you seem to be planning for them? Forgive me but its not your decision to make after all , and if it were me I'd want to make my own decisions about where what how and why I lived my life..

nanapug Thu 15-Nov-12 16:39:03

What lucky parents to have someone who cares and is prepared to support them through this difficult time.
I feel quite strongly that if my OH and I are struggling to cope, we should do whatever is easier for our DDs, so they are able to support us on their terms with the least amount of agro for them. I hate the idea of being a burden and so their wishes are paramount.
I suggest you think about what will be easier for you to cope with, and put it to them with the pro's and con's. Buying and selling together can work, but also can have big pitfalls. It depends how you all get on. IMHO it is vital that you have your own front door and be independent from each other. My Mum lived with us for quite a while and it wasn't easy not having any privacy.
You all need to agree to be totally honest with each other from the start, when discussing the future, so you all know where you stand.
Good luck x

SummerOf75 Thu 15-Nov-12 16:39:33

Thanks!

I've suggested grab rails in bathroom and getting some quotes for adding a downstairs bathroom. Then if the surgery is a no they can at least get on with the works while Dad has some mobility.

granjura Thu 15-Nov-12 16:44:30

I really feel for you Summerof75 - (I've been there, done that ... with my own parents) but I agree with Tanith. It is THEIR decision, and all you can do is support them best you can. If they want to stay in their own home, then it is again, their choice. So getting more help for them, and getting a shower suitable for disabled and a loo downstairs would be great.

I've known friends who bought a huge house with their parents to share- and in every instance it turned out to be a disaster all round, as the needs of different generations differ so much. And also known friends who up-rooted their parents to come and live near them- and it just didn't work out, as they missed their friends and familiar surroundings too much.

I intend to listen to my children and take on board their advice and accept their help, when the time comes- as long as I feel I am in charge of my own destiny. I intend to get help here with the big house and garden as and when, and have no intention of going to live in a 1 bed bungalow or an OAP home- and would really resent it if I was pushed in that direction against my will.
Hope you find a way to feel re-assured and yet allow them to make their own decisions.

SummerOf75 Thu 15-Nov-12 16:47:19

tanith I used to work with older adults, I've seen how some people struggle at home and it's crap. I just want them to be happy. I know they love their house as it is but if Dad can't manage stairs it needs addressing. His family tend to make old bones so he could well have 20+ years of reduced mobility & I think if we take positive steps now to deal with it he can enjoy the rest of his retirement.

SummerOf75 Thu 15-Nov-12 16:56:14

Hi granjura, I'm inclined to agree wrt living together! I know a couple of cases where it's worked well but only when it was one widowed parent and they had their own little suite of rooms. One of mum's friends lives with her daughter now and it sounds a bit fraught.

I re read my OP and it does sound like I'm trying to force them to move, I'm not, but my mum is understandably not keen to change anything (the age difference is quite pronounced now - she seems middle aged while dad is more of an old man). I'm introducing the idea of moving and trying to be really positive about it so that she at least considers it properly.

I did mention that a downstairs shower/WC would probably add to the value of the house if/when they do want to sell and told her I'd been watching Phil Spencer, so maybe she'd feel better if she could say that's why they did it...

My heart says if they can afford the alterations they should do them but if not they do need to look at moving. Where to is another matter, cross that bridge when/if we come to it!

granjura Thu 15-Nov-12 17:09:02

i am so glad you took my comments well, as they were certainly meant wellsmile

This is so hard, but if your parents chose to live in squalor, but stay put, it would still be their choice, somehow. Perhaps with a WC and toilet downstairs, maybe your dad could live downstairs with a proper hospital type bed, and maybe get rid of the dining-room?

gracesmum Thu 15-Nov-12 17:10:15

It sounds as if you have covered all the options. 60's and 70's is not very old to feel it is necessary to move/downsize, but I think you made a good point about doing it before a person is forced to by disability or old age. 20 miles is not that far, so if a move is on the cards, is there the likelihood of anything near where they live now? As to the downstairs loo/shower room, I think this would always add value to a house (a wet room or at least a walk in shower is best) If your Dad moved downstairs, it wounds as if upstairs would be underused which does not make good financial sense, so in my mind the jury is out regarding moving or not. They are also going to have to accept the increased expense of help in the garden even if(or especially if) your father is a keen gardener. Good luck - you sound a very caring sensible daughter!

merlotgran Thu 15-Nov-12 17:16:13

SummerOf75, My in laws moved from a three bedroomed house into a one bedroom flat in a retirement complex when they were in their mid sixties. FIL had diabetes and a heart problem. We thought they were crazy. It seemed too soon to be putting themselves in 'an old folk's home'. How wrong we were. They soon made friends, had a great social life, extra money for holidays and when FIL died, MIL had loads of support and was able to get her life back on track without too many problems.
My mother, on the other hand, refused to move from her bungalow into a retirement flat, despite having had a stroke, until she was 89. It was too late for her to really enjoy the benefits and now her health has declined, to the point she cannot leave her flat, I think she has missed out.

It's a tough call. Good Luck.

Mishap Thu 15-Nov-12 17:32:00

We have a very strong emotional bond with our home - the views, the community, the neighbours, the activities in the village etc. And also the alterations we have done to make it suit our needs and personalities etc. - and all the memories. We would find it very hard indeed to move from here, even though our rational minds fully understand the practical problems (steep hill, steps up to the house, steps inside the house, no buses etc.). And we would find it very hard to face the necessary upheaval.

What I am trying to say is that the decision is not just a practical one. I am sure you can see all the practical considerations - and I am equally sure that you are right about them - but that does not mean that it would be easy for your parents to tear themselves away from their home.

If they cannot afford to make the necessary alterations, there are grants available and the local SSD should send an OT to assess what is needed. If his/her recommendations were for the alterations then they would have support in applying for financial help.

I worked as a SW with elderly and disabled for many years and these decisions are always very hard. I have seen some people make the sensible move and be thoroughly miserable and never feeling at home in their new place; and other situations where it has worked out well. In the end they need to be 100% behind any decision.

I do also understand how worrying it must be for you and how lucky they are to have your thoughtful concern.

jeni Thu 15-Nov-12 18:24:30

Is there any reason a stairlift cannot be fitted?

MargaretX Thu 15-Nov-12 19:19:39

I would try to get a lift and a shower/WC put in. Leaving the family home can be very saddening. My MIL moved to be near us but was aged 86 at a time when she knew she just couldn't manage anymore.
Her immobility was making her unhappy and she had found herself in a couple of desperate situations.

I shall leave it myself until that point in my life arrives.

HUNTERF Thu 15-Nov-12 20:23:49

I am in a different situation in the fact I was bought up in my parents house in Birmingham, got married,moved to London, had 2 daughters who went to Birmingham University and settled in Birmingham then sadly Mum and my wife passed away.
Mum and Dad split their house into tenants in common ownership and I inherited Mums half.
I then got early retirement in London and Dad and I agreed there was no point us living in separate houses.
As Dad was in his mid 80's at the time I thought it would be best if the house was sold and we should by a bungalow.
At that time Dad was enjoying very good health for his age and I think he could have been of some help in setting up the new bungalow.
Unfortunately Dad just took the view he had lived in the house for 60 years and that was home and that is where he wanted to stay.
Luckily Dad never got many physical problems and he passed away earlier this year when he was nearly 90.
I was there for Dad if he had needed care but he did not need much but I took him to several places which he wanted to see while he was alive.
I am now the full owner of the house at age 63.
I am now thinking of selling the house and purchasing a bungalow as I am not exactly a spring chicken.
I think I will be a little sad if I do move as I tended to regard that house as home.
I now have my 2 daughters, 2 son's in law and grandchildren living a mile from me.
I just hope they stay in Birmingham.

Frank

Ariadne Thu 15-Nov-12 20:40:30

Our very recent move was, in part, a planned move with a bit of a view to our future, together with a wish to be nearer to our children (and the sea.) Also, having tried very hard to look after my mother at a distance while working full time, I was aware of the problems and stress it can cause.

We haven't downsized much and so far I am loving it all - the pace of life, DGC popping in (never known this) and, of course, we do know lots of people here; but there is one thing of which I am certain - I would not like to do the whole moving thing again, and certainly not when I was older. It was exhausting and stressful. But it was our decision, and ours alone. That, too, is important.

FlicketyB Fri 16-Nov-12 08:45:53

I am torn on this issue. After my mother died in her late 80s my father remained in their bungalow (bought when they retired) for the next 10 years until he died in his early 90s. He was very fit to the end, physically and mentally. Both my sister and I lived a 100 miles away so frequent visits were not practical but my father was embedded in his local community, an active member of three different community groups, he also was part of a large social group and was seeing friends or attending or organising events almost daily. It was absolutely the right decision for him and for us. BUT

I also have a friend, unmarried, who spent most of her working life overseas. When she retired she bought a large retirement bungalow in a development close to where she grew up. Although she is fully fit and independent she thought this was the best solution as she was moving back to the UK after a longtime away and her friends, like me were scattered over the UK and the development gave her a built in social group while she built up her own social network in the town she now lives in and as she gets older she will be able to stay in the development no matter how her health and fitness decline as it also includes a care home.

At the end of the day it is a decision to be made by the couple themselves, hopefully in discussion with immediate family but whatever that decision is both sides of the equation have to live with the choice made.

Gagagran Fri 16-Nov-12 09:44:26

Ariadne your post could be mine - it describes more or less everything we think following our move to be near DD + DGC (and the sea) earlier this year.

I would say that leaving an area where you have built up good friends and contacts is a bit daunting and you have to be prepared to go out and start building them again in your new area. I do think it is best to do it whilst you have choices and the energy necessary for what is a major change. The thought of being forced into hasty decisions if/when health or other problems strike in later life is not one we relished.

The other thing I would recommend, as has been voiced already, is to have full and frank discussions with DD (and DSiL) to ensure that both parties are happy with the proposed move and are clear about what would be involved. We said that DD could call any time but we would not call on her unless invited - her and DSiL's privacy is more important to them than ours is to us. I love it when she and /or DGC pop in for a coffee or a chat!

I do occasionally get a twinge of missing my old life but a brisk walk by the beautiful coast and I am back to counting my many blessings!

gillybob Fri 16-Nov-12 10:33:52

Hi SummerOf75 I was in a fairly similar situation a couple of years back. My parents were in their late 60's at the time and whilst my dad was extremely fit (still is) my mum was in very poor health and had to be literally carried upstairs to use the bathroom. Unfortunately their ex-local authority home was worth very little compared with how much it would cost them to buy a bungalow and building on to their existing home was not an option. After several meetings with the local authority and letters from consultants etc. they were given priority status to be rehoused into a local authority bungalow which they moved into about a 3 years ago. They went on to sell their 3 bedroomed terraced house but now have to pay full rent to the local authority which at £90 per week is not cheap but a small price to pay for safety, security and comfort.

Their bungalow is on a small estate of 25 similar properties and my parents (who are both in their 70's) are now the young couple who live in the corner.

Greatnan Fri 16-Nov-12 11:27:38

I recently posted a list of rules I had drawn up for myself when I go to live close to my daughter in New Zealand. At first, the intention was that I would buy a cabin and site it in her garden. On further reflection, we have both decided that this could create problems if they ever want to sell their present house and move further out of town, to get more land. I don't think I will be able to afford to buy a property in NZ so I am looking at the market in long-term rentals, which would leave me the capital from the sale of my small flat in France.
The alternative which we have discussed is that they buy a property that actually has a smaller house on the land - this is fairly common in NZ, where land is freely available and many farms have houses for extended families.
In that case, I would contribute towards the cost of the property.
I want to emigrate whilst I am still fit enough to enjoy the outdoor lifestyle which I love -their village is about 12 miles from the beautiful beaches around Richmond, there is wonderful walking in the National Park, and I intend to take up riding and kayaking.
I think even mothers and daughters who love each other dearly, could find the loss of privacy difficult. I know I would. The idea is that I will be near enough to my daughter for us to see each other often - but by appointment! No dropping in unexpectedly especially once her last two children have left home and she and her husband can enjoy a second lease of romance!

Mishap Fri 16-Nov-12 11:58:13

How is your DD getting on with her broken ankle greatnan?

jeni Fri 16-Nov-12 12:06:20

Greatnan kayaking,riding?shock I would have thought you'd have included rock climbing, parachuting and bungee jumping as well! [stark staring bonkers] emoticon!

Riverwalk Fri 16-Nov-12 12:41:09

Greatnan a Kiwi colleague told me that when she moved a few years ago - she really did 'move' the house!

She wanted more land but loved her house, so as is apparently the done thing there, the large house was cut in half and loaded on the back of two transporters and driven to the new plot and put back together.

I don't think there would be a problem in you taking your cabin here and there!

annodomini Fri 16-Nov-12 12:45:14

jeni, don't give her ideas!! grin