Gransnet forums

Chat

One upmanship

(192 Posts)
GagaJo Tue 23-Mar-21 09:27:58

So, over the last few weeks I have seen one upmanship on GN about the following:

Curtain v plantation shutters
Paint v wallpaper
Sausages (cheap and fatty v butchers)
Easter eggs
Holidays (2nd home v beach and poool)
Houses (detached v anything else)

Have I missed anything?

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 13:18:07

Football manager?

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 13:18:38

Ellianne

Football manager?

In reply to Lucca.

Lucca Tue 23-Mar-21 13:20:00

Oooh I suspect inside knowledge.....

CherryCezzy Tue 23-Mar-21 13:40:22

Is it that important what other people on gn have or don't have?
A detached house, a one bedroom flat, an old Ferrari or an old ford Ka? A detached house in one area of the UK can have the same £s value as a one bedroom flat in another part. Some people have inherited, some people haven't. Some people have divorced and had a good settlement and others have lost everything. Some people have had good earnings in their lifetime, others have not.
What's important?

I haven't seen any one-upmanship on gn really. Gn has a mix of people posting, each poster is different, each poster has their own background, their own story to tell. Some people reveal a lot about themselves, background, what it's like to live where they do etc, etc, etc. Other posters do not. We only know about people's homes or possessions because they reveal it, are they boasting or just posting about themselves and their family? I'm inclined to believe it's the latter. Should people not reveal anything about themselves, where they live etc?
What is gn for? Should people be banned for telling us about the easter eggs they've bought?

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 14:23:57

Will I be caught out if I post this and say I've just been for a nice swim in my pool?

Clue .... the owner lied she'd actually got married, when she hadn't.

Seems showing off doesn't pay!

Callistemon Tue 23-Mar-21 14:39:36

Casdon

Oh no, I responded to the thread about animals this morning and said my dog can tell the time (he can!) was that one upmanship? (Oneupdogship?)

We had a dog that could hear DH's car from a mile away; he'd go and wait by the door although DH rarely got home at the same time.
The dog could also talk - yes, truly, some words.

Now, wasn't that the cleverest dog in the world?

grandmajet Tue 23-Mar-21 14:44:16

Cherry, my favourite car ever was a Ka. I had it for 10 years, and only had to give it up due to terminal rust. It was great if I ever went the wrong way as it could turn on a sixpence!

Urmstongran made a good point about the sacrifices they’d made to have a holiday home, and while many of us can make choices like that, some can only afford a very modest lifestyle however careful they are financially. Without knowing someone’s whole background it’s impossible to say and certainly not our place to judge.

I just enjoy the glimpses we get on GN into the lives of other folk, the differences of opinion, different values, the sense of fun in many in spite of all that is going on at the moment. I’ve never sensed any overt oneupmanship in all this.

I’m off to the stables where I hope the groom has my Arab mare ready for my afternoon hack.

Callistemon Tue 23-Mar-21 14:45:41

I don’t mind that ! I do mind not knowing who he was.....I’m very nosy/nosey.

Me too!!

Callistemon Tue 23-Mar-21 14:51:03

Ellianne how did you get hold of that photo of one of my holiday homes?

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 14:52:39

Callistemon grin I hope you're going over to check on it next week so it's up to my usual standard!

Maggiemaybe Tue 23-Mar-21 14:59:59

Callistemon, I’m going to one-up your clever dog with a clever cat who used to do the same. And at the risk of fellow cat-women shouting me down, I think a clever cat is rarer than a clever dog.

FarNorth Tue 23-Mar-21 15:12:18

Oldwoman70

When the butler brought me my mid morning coffee, I was sitting in the orangery looking out at the pool, he assured me that I have never indulged in oneupmanship

gringrin

Just saw your lovely post after I finished instructing my household staff.
Now I must check how my gilt-edged investments are getting on.

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 15:19:09

I've just had my Fortnum's delivery. Rare breed pork and leek sausages. Is that what the OP meant?

Flicker Tue 23-Mar-21 15:36:21

Ooohh, Ellianne ?

I think sometimes it is terminology.
I once gphad my... ahem...bum handed t9 me when * referred to the back kitchen and boot room.
No, i dont have a huge pile in the country, but with dogs, converted a garage into a boot room, complete with dog cleaning facilities.
The back kitchen is the utility room ? I have always known it as the back kitchen, but am apparantly a major snob to refer to it as such?

Flicker Tue 23-Mar-21 15:37:38

Oh for an edit button.....

I once had
Handed to me......

ginny Tue 23-Mar-21 15:39:43

Oh for goodness sake. Whilst there may be the odd person who likes to think they are better than others, mostly it is just a difference of ideas , preference or taste. Boring world if we were all the same.

ginny Tue 23-Mar-21 15:42:16

Besides, my house is bigger than yours. My second car is a Porsche and all my children and Grandchildren are geniuses.

M0nica Tue 23-Mar-21 15:56:24

What I like about GN is that it does represent a cross section of society and on it one is meeting people from far more varied backgrounds than one could ever hope to meet in ordinary life.

I see very little upmanship of possessions, but more people claiming the moral high ground and self righteous virtue. But even that occurs only infrequently.

Maggiemaybe Tue 23-Mar-21 16:10:26

ginny

Besides, my house is bigger than yours. My second car is a Porsche and all my children and Grandchildren are geniuses.

Well I have a whole fleet of vehicles and a host of liveried drivers at my command. The local corporation manages them for me.

In return, I kindly allow less fortunate members of the public to share my conveyances.

Callistemon Tue 23-Mar-21 16:18:28

Flicker my friend had a butler's pantry! Her house was what you might term substantial but certainly not large and in rather desperate need of some TLC.

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 16:20:02

I agree, Monica, and there are plenty of GNs who are adept at injecting some humour and humility into their posts, as on this thread.

I think what upset me on one occasion was when a poster remembered something I wrote in say April or September about my lifestyle and then proceeded to launch attacks much further down the line.

I must admit I can barely remember who said what about their wealth or status. It just isn't important.

Grammaretto Tue 23-Mar-21 16:38:05

I have never noticed any of these oneupmanship threads. What have I missed!?

Although wait, some threads can sometimes sound like competitive misery.

I am an inverted snob but I try not to boast. grin

I get wistful at times when I read about so many of you who have seen their DGC recently or who live close to them.
envy

CherryCezzy Tue 23-Mar-21 16:59:19

grandmajet my belated sister(in law) loved her Ka too ☺️. I won't tell you about the cars she had before it, it may be interpreted as boasting ?.
I agree that some threads can sometimes sound like competitive misery Grammaretto. Why anyone would want to compete that way, it defies my logic. Though sound like may be how they appear rather than anything else.
Now where's that gilt edged Easter egg ....

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 17:13:13

Now where's that gilt edged Easter egg ....
Did you know Fabergé eggs were first designed for the Tsars to give to their wives at Easter. I wonder if they could send me the catalogue?

Jaxjacky Tue 23-Mar-21 17:25:15

I’ve never noticed any, or I’m oblivious to it. I’ll pay more attention ? ‘could do better’ was often on my school reports.