Gransnet forums

Chat

AIBU?

(59 Posts)
Wake Fri 15-Oct-21 16:12:50

Has anyone else noticed that people seem to shy away from the word ‘died’. Since when did it become the norm to say ‘passed away’ or even just ‘passed’. I have no problem saying ‘died’. Anyone else agree or am I being a bit picky.

Wake Fri 15-Oct-21 16:13:48

Apologies. Forgot all my question marks. ??

Baggs Fri 15-Oct-21 16:15:12

Yes, I've noticed it too and I don't get it either.

Riverwalk Fri 15-Oct-21 16:15:37

In light of today's events, does it really matter right now?

Baggs Fri 15-Oct-21 16:16:36

People have issues with the word 'old' as well, even when it's appropriate.

I guess it's based on a kind of fear.

Hithere Fri 15-Oct-21 16:16:58

I think it all depends how the person grieves

"Died" is more direct and factual than "passed away" or similar.

Baggs Fri 15-Oct-21 16:19:56

I can't remember where but some years ago I read somethng about doctors having to use the word died because euphemisms could be misinterpreted and that usinf died overcomes that because it is direct and factual, and not about how anyone feels.

Baggs Fri 15-Oct-21 16:21:01

Facing up to the death of a loved one is hard.

midgey Fri 15-Oct-21 16:23:25

I am so with you Wake, it drives me mad. It’s almost as if the actual death has been glossed over.

Charleygirl5 Fri 15-Oct-21 16:26:37

I could not agree more- if somebody has "passed" to where have they passed? They have died, end of.

Humduh Fri 15-Oct-21 16:34:55

I say passed to kids trying to be gentle but now it has become a habit. Funny thing is the kids seem fine being blunt about saying dead so maybe am trying to be gentle with nyself

Farmor15 Fri 15-Oct-21 16:45:51

I would always say died and am another one who dislikes "passed".
On a related note, I prefer to say "toilet", than the various other words often used - though "loo" is ok. I particularly don't like "bathroom", for toilets in public places which don't contain a bath!

Baggs Fri 15-Oct-21 16:57:39

Bet you love “rest room”, farmoor ?

Baggs Fri 15-Oct-21 16:58:10

Oops! Sorry for miss-spelling your name

JenniferEccles Fri 15-Oct-21 17:00:07

I agree and I also am not keen on the euphemism ‘lost’ to describe a death.
It seems strange to me because we lose someone in a busy shopping mall or supermarket.

I guess though if the bereaved person finds comfort in using these words, who are we to criticise?

BlueBelle Fri 15-Oct-21 17:03:36

Everyone has their own comfort zone, say what suits you I think of and use the word died but I haven’t got a problem with any other words All I can’t stand is when animals ‘cross over the rainbow bridge’ I feel quite sick then and the other one is when a man says ‘we are pregnant’ I inwardly scream no your not pregnant, your wife is

Hetty58 Fri 15-Oct-21 17:06:56

JenniferEccles, yes 'lost' can cause problems. I explained, to my granddaughter, that I was hugging a neighbour because - she was sad as she'd lost her baby. GD instantly looked horrified, and said 'Where did she leave it?'.

MerylStreep Fri 15-Oct-21 17:07:05

My Mother in Law had a neighbour who was always loosing people. Very unfortunate turn of phrase.

Blossoming Fri 15-Oct-21 17:07:18

Yes, we all noticed. It’s been discussed a few times.

MissAdventure Fri 15-Oct-21 17:10:17

I couldn't care less if others don't like it, if I want to say my daughter passed away, or I lost her, I will.

Luckygirl Fri 15-Oct-21 17:12:18

I have used the word died since my OH died - I use it with the GC and anyone else with whom I am having a conversation about it. It is real and it is clear.

MissAdventure Fri 15-Oct-21 17:16:10

If people don't understand what is meant by losing someone, or them passing away, then I feel sorry for them.
Mu mum died, my girl passed away.
Allow the bereaved to deal with it in their own way.

sodapop Fri 15-Oct-21 17:31:38

I agree MissAdventure although I don't particularly like the term 'passed over' it's more gentle maybe than saying the person died.
Each to their own whatever gives them comfort.

MayBeMaw Fri 15-Oct-21 17:38:37

I don’t think this is a modern phenomenon at all. People have said “passed away” , “passed over” (Victorian) ) or even “gone to glory” for decades.
“Passed” on its own is more recent however - US influenced perhaps?
Does it matter to anybody but the bereaved though?
Respect for their feelings should be paramount.
(I think there are much worse things to obsess about. )

MissAdventure Fri 15-Oct-21 17:39:13

I've read in here before that it makes people want to scream.
Try saying "my child is dead. End of", when someone doesn't know and asks how they are.
That will make you want to scream.