Gransnet forums

Chat

Staying on topic- threads in general

(639 Posts)
trisher Sun 24-Oct-21 10:01:44

Do you mind if a thread de-rails after it has been running for a while and extends into other areas? I would have thought this was a natural progression of any discussion and sometimes the original subject returns with new light cast on it. It certainly seems in my opinion an odd reason for deleting any thread.

Doodledog Sun 24-Oct-21 17:57:46

You mean mention of court cases and so on? I think people had posted a couple of those before I broke the rules for reasons of personal hygiene ?.

See, if that is the case, why not delete the posts and say that such links are not allowed? At least everyone would know where they stood.

Galaxy Sun 24-Oct-21 17:58:01

Oh I love her scones. She seems to have mastered a look of disdain.

JaneJudge Sun 24-Oct-21 17:58:04

who is Peter?

JaneJudge Sun 24-Oct-21 18:00:02

Is Peter out or is he out out? I went out out last night so I think missed whatever happened confused

I think some of you might think I am being paranoid but I'm not actually convinced it was anyone posting on the thread that led to its deletion

FarNorth Sun 24-Oct-21 18:00:35

Does the fluffy rabbit make scones?

Doodledog Sun 24-Oct-21 18:00:37

JaneJudge

who is Peter?

I’m lost now.

FarNorth Sun 24-Oct-21 18:02:11

I think we on GN actually get away with a lot more, in some ways, than they do on MN.
(Shsh, don't tell anyone)

Galaxy Sun 24-Oct-21 18:02:13

Yes I wasnt blaming you doodledog. It's just from experience on MN.

JaneJudge Sun 24-Oct-21 18:03:59

Doodledog

JaneJudge

who is Peter?

I’m lost now.

You'll get used to me eventually grin

Doodledog Sun 24-Oct-21 18:06:17

Galaxy

Yes I wasnt blaming you doodledog. It's just from experience on MN.

Oh, I know?. It was just a comment in response to your theory.

trisher Sun 24-Oct-21 18:14:39

Never mind deviation what about confusion!!!!

Scones Sun 24-Oct-21 18:24:11

The fluffy rabbit definitely eats scones.

Were you out, out out or out out with Peter JaneJudge?

freedomfromthepast Sun 24-Oct-21 18:25:00

Based on my experience with forums, likely no one reported it.

Mods do not read every thread, they do not need to. But when a thread goes from a few posts to almost 1000 posts in just a few days, a mod will notice. Usually a thread reaching 1000 posts will take weeks or months.

As a mod, when a thread gets that big that fast, it means the topic of discussion is highly charged and needs to be looked at. It is highly unlikely that someone reported the thread, though it was such a sensitive topic, it may very well be true.

As for thread moderation and deletions, it is all laid out in the guidelines.

"Thread deletions
We don't generally delete whole discussion threads, unless they're libellous or racist or otherwise break the law, because it's frustrating for people to write carefully considered responses that, minutes later, are removed. That said, we're here to make people's lives easier, not the reverse so if a thread derails or becomes seriously unpleasant or a bunfight, we may decide it is best to delete it.

Also, if you have a pressing reason for wanting a thread you have started to be deleted, please report it to us (by clicking on the Report link, above and to the right of the post in question) and we'll take a look.

If a thread is deleted, please resist the temptation to start a new one, repeating and rehashing everything that has been deleted: that would be very bad manners and, of course, it's highly likely that the new thread will be deleted, too. Similarly, we will delete threads about other ongoing threads, as it causes too much confusion on the forums"

I suspect that this thread will also be deleted because it about a deleted thread.

trisher Sun 24-Oct-21 18:37:38

If we keep posting pictures of fluffy bunnies maybe the moderators won't notice!

Doodledog Sun 24-Oct-21 18:41:34

If that’s the case it would be good if the mods read it first, and responded to the points raised. If it’s bad manners to start a new thread, it is surely also bad manners to simply nuke an existing one with no explanation?

JaneJudge Sun 24-Oct-21 18:46:50

confused

freedomfromthepast Sun 24-Oct-21 18:48:17

You make a good point Doodledog. However it is their sandbox, we just bring the shovels and pails. Sometimes they will rake the sand when they think it needs it. All we can do is wait and on the wings and return with our pails when they are done.

Iam64 Sun 24-Oct-21 18:53:06

I was following the deleted thread. The robust debate was largely informative and interesting. I last read it early evening and when I looked this morning it had gone. Why?

Chewbacca Sun 24-Oct-21 18:57:32

The vanished thread was neither libellous nor racist or otherwise broke the law. All of the links provided, by all sides of the discussion, we're bona fide and their were a lot of carefully considered responses too. It only went pear shaped when it was, imo, deliberately side tracked, probably for the reasons given by Doodledog @ 17.49. It's very difficult to bring any thread back on track when that happens, especially if the sidetracker is grimly determined to derail it and cause problems.

freedomfromthepast Sun 24-Oct-21 19:06:12

If GN believed it was none of those things, then it may very well have been:

"becomes seriously unpleasant or a bunfight, we may decide it is best to delete it"

Again, this is GN's platform. They have final say.

You could message a mod and ask why it was deleted and ask to have it reinstated. I do not think it is unreasonable to ask the mod who removed it to post here and explain why.

I would much prefer they lock threads vs. deleting them. But I am sure they have a reason for not doing so.

Chewbacca Sun 24-Oct-21 19:32:16

Possibly freedomfromthepast. They might have decided that when the slur "TERFS" was used to describe posters, it had gone too far and was time to can it.

FarNorth Sun 24-Oct-21 19:36:40

No one here is talking about a current thread, tho, so we should be fine.

Here are some flowers.

FarNorth Sun 24-Oct-21 19:37:36

.

FarNorth Sun 24-Oct-21 19:38:44

shock
I certainly didn't mean to put 3 pics up, but I hope you like them.

Chewbacca Sun 24-Oct-21 19:39:50

I did FarNorth! thank you!