Perverted man claims to be a woman - may be housed in a women's prison

Do you have access to his files, GagaJo?

There must be very many people in jail who are not sane, but it's up to psychiatrists, criminologists and the courts to decide.

Definitions of insanity are extremely tricky, and without detailed knowledge of the case we can't possibly diagnose from our armchairs. I agree that dog rape doesn't sound like the action of a sane person, but in the end it is power over another being, which is arguably what all rape comes down to.

Do you think he should be in a women's jail, and do you think that anyone should be able to change gender id when a trial is pending?

Before anyone starts one of my sons is gay so I’ll save you the bother of trying to twist my words!

The story of the man who had sex with cadavers was far worse !

He murdered two women as well EV. A truly depraved and evil man.

But he is not going to a secure mental hospital GagaJo.
He has been sentenced to prison.
What safeguards would you like to see to ensure that someone like this man, claiming to be a woman, is not inflicted on women prisoners?

From my OP -
Possibly some on this site think this is non-controversial non-news of a vulnerable transwoman.

I'm glad to hear that no-one who has commented so far does think this.

What difference would it make if this person was a genuine trans person. Then it would be ok would it for them to be in a womens prison? Nope. No men in womens spaces.

But GJ I thought you were the UTP.
Sorry I got that wrong. Paedophiles, whatever the sex of their victims, and those indulging in bestiality should be in a secure mental health facility. Agreement at last.

It has been sent to a male prison.
And yes, I do mean it

I think he should be in a secure unit which deals with sex offenders, Unfortunately these units are vstly oversubscribed and mix first time offenders with long term and dedicated offenders. They have been criticised as places where ideas and knowledge about sex perversions is shared and younger offenders are educated. So they are not ideal.
There are currently two prisons which accommodate women category A prisoners. Although the safety of those prisoners is questionable. Rose West had to be moved from one because of threats. She was then beaten up at Low Newton.

This person should not be in a women’s prison
As he’s been sentenced to prison it is probably safe to say any mitigating factors were considered.
I read that the presentence probation report described him as not acknowledging the impact of his crimes, unrepentant
If every individual who acted on their sexual interest in children and beastiality was sent to scarce mental health facilities we’d have to build many more
Maybe we should but some criminals need incarcerating

yes, it's tricky.
to ordinary decent reasonable people many crimes seem incomprehensible, esp offences against the person, eg gangster violence, torture, intimidation; modern day slavery; child cruelty.
we often say, why would anyone even think to do that, they must be mad.
but the definitions in the criminal justice system are very precise as to what constitutes mental disorder causing offending.

What difference would it make if this person was a genuine trans person. Then it would be ok would it for them to be in a womens prison? Nope. No men in womens spaces.

This. All. Day. Long.

Chewbacca

^What difference would it make if this person was a genuine trans person. Then it would be ok^ would it for them to be in a womens prison? Nope. No men in womens spaces.

This. All. Day. Long.

As long as it takes to get the message through!

Thank you for that info MerylStreep.

I wonder if he will be wearing one of his wigs and introducing himself as Claire to his cell mates, they will think Christmas has come early ?

Yes, that would be interesting to observe. I don't mean any sexual stuff, but to see how far the identifying would go, when I would think it wouldn't be an advantage.

How does he think he could possibly pass as a woman, even a very ugly one? Despicable person. Because of what he did, not who he identifies as.

Shep it has nothing to do about ‘passing’
He says he’s a bird and hey presto he is one

Just a little of his past, when he identified as a man:

2005
John Ernest Goodier, of Spencer Street, appeared at Northwich Magistrates' Court on Thursday and admitted seven charges of taking indecent photographs of a child, nine charges of making indecent or pseudo photographs of a child and possessing 187 indecent photos of a child for distribution.

The 44-year-old also admitted two counts of causing or indicting a child aged 13 to 17 to prostitution or pornography and distributing eight indecent photos of a child. The offences occurred between July 19, 2004, and on or about July 30 this year.
Chairman of the bench Don Beckett said the case was 'far too serious' for magistrates to hear and conditionally bailed Goodier, with the provision he did not have any direct or indirect contact with any person under 16 years, until he appears at Chester Crown Court for trial on January 4 2006

He was also ordered to join the sex offenders' register within three days.

. You have a womb a woman, you have a penis a man. I’m not really interested in how he feels about where he goes, he lost that right.

Jorgensen Seren a transgender paedophile jailed for 15 months after being convicted of kissing little girls in the street. Police found images of child sexual abuse on a computer at his home. He attended court dressed as an elf, holding a doll. He sucked his thumb throughout the hearing. He identifies as a five year old girl.
His defence barrister told the Court that whilst born male, he identifies as female. Psychiatric assessments diagnosed personality problems, not mental health problems.
That was the point I made about the individual in this OP. Some posters take the view that mental health problems must underpin this kind of depraved abusive behaviour. That isn’t the case

If sex with animals isn't insane, I don't know what is. Criminal also of course.

Personality problems are a form of mental health problems. You can’t exclude them from it
www.mind.org.uk/information-support/types-of-mental-health-problems/personality-disorders/types-of-personality-disorder/

I’ve not read the link yet but - the psychiatric position has long been that PDs are largely untreatable therefore not mental health disorders