Gransnet forums

Chat

Another missing poster

(311 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

merlotgran Sat 31-Aug-24 11:19:41

If this were a light hearted thread, I’d be tempted to suggest that Gransnet is beginning to feel like Midsomer Murders. Yet another poster has disappeared in mysterious circumstances.

It’s deadly serious though. Attempts to contact Urmstongran are falling on stony ground and many of us are concerned because we know how challenging her life is at the moment.

Many of us have received messages of support from Urms when life has dealt us the cruellest of blows and yet we are unable to contact her via pms.

She always let us know when she was taking a break from GN so to go on a long awaited holiday and just disappear is out of character.

I suspect foul play and I’m not taking the p**s!

Oreo Sun 01-Sept-24 10:28:55

There are some good forums out there as well as MN.
Marydoll I just won’t read eight pages of waffle but have been assured that Callistemon has been banned, but now you say that isn’t so?I need a lie down.

MissAdventure Sun 01-Sept-24 10:30:03

grin

Doodledog Sun 01-Sept-24 10:32:30

Have you forgotten former Labour MP Tracy Brabin?
No, I remember. Another woman getting treated in a way men are not.

I also remember Theresa May getting a lot of sniggers about her choice of footwear and big, chunky necklaces.
More of the same, but less sexual, and more about the styles. I liked her necklaces, but thought her trousers always looked too short, for what that's worth. Nobody suggested TM was a tart though, although it was implicit in some of the comments about (the Northern, working class) Tracy Brabin.

NittWitt Sun 01-Sept-24 10:47:49

Male politicians have a 'uniform' of suit, shirt & tie.
That makes things much easier, tho boring, for them.

LauraNorderr Sun 01-Sept-24 10:56:20

I just wish that all of the petty reporting would stop and we, as experienced adults could be left to judge for ourselves and challenge those who are rude or downright out of order.
I’d like to see all posters return and those who have GNHQ on speed dial reprimanded.

Doodledog Sun 01-Sept-24 10:56:44

NittWitt

Male politicians have a 'uniform' of suit, shirt & tie.
That makes things much easier, tho boring, for them.

Yes. I think TM tired to copy that, but feminise it with the necklaces and shoes. It doesn't matter what women do, though. Other women will criticise their taste, their looks, their personal lives, their families - anything rather than see them as successful professional women who may well have done better than their critics, often in the face of difficult circumstances.

NittWitt Sun 01-Sept-24 11:10:12

I actually think Nicola Sturgeon's stylist got it right for her as First Minister, with outfits of jacket + skirt/trousers in solid colours.

rafichagran Sun 01-Sept-24 11:15:58

Oreo

Why on earth is this a third thread about missing posters?🤔

I suppose because people want to post about it. I have just looked at Gransnet. Petra are you saying equating someone to a tart is alright then. It is not however much you try to dress it up.

biglouis Sun 01-Sept-24 11:21:45

Tarty is a (mainly working class) adjective which was often thrown about in my native Liverpol when I was younger. I dont know if this is still the case as its 40 years since I lived there. The equivalent insult for a male was to call him a "prick" which carries both sexual and social class connotations. "Oik" and "twat" were two others.

MissAdventure Sun 01-Sept-24 11:24:34

Those male insults don't pertain to a mans sexual values where I come from.
There isn't a male version, except "man whore", and doesn't that just sound wonderful?
Yet people think its acceptable to fling it around about Rayner.

Doodledog Sun 01-Sept-24 11:38:19

biglouis

Tarty is a (mainly working class) adjective which was often thrown about in my native Liverpol when I was younger. I dont know if this is still the case as its 40 years since I lived there. The equivalent insult for a male was to call him a "prick" which carries both sexual and social class connotations. "Oik" and "twat" were two others.

Nellie Boswell used to call Lilo Lil a 'taaaart', in Bread grin.
I agree it's not an insult that does the insulter any favours.

I disagree that your other examples are the same though. 'Oik' is a snobbish term for state school pupils, I believe. I dare say it is/was more often used against men and boys, as in the days when it was current more males than females were educated. 'Prick' is relatively mild, and just means the same as 'prat' or 'pillock' - it's not the male equivalent of 'tart', as it doesn't have sexual connotations despite its alternative meaning, and anyway those connotations are far less derogatory when applied to a man.

'Twat' is another word that shows the disdain some have for women - much like the 'C word' which uses the female sexual anatomy as the worst thing someone can be called. I know that is different in parts of Scotland, though.

Doodledog Sun 01-Sept-24 11:38:49

MissAdventure

Those male insults don't pertain to a mans sexual values where I come from.
There isn't a male version, except "man whore", and doesn't that just sound wonderful?
Yet people think its acceptable to fling it around about Rayner.

That's what I was trying to say grin

JaneJudge Sun 01-Sept-24 11:39:21

I don’t think Raynor’s attire if a trouser suit was stereotypically tarty though and that’s where the problem lay as there were further comments about illegitimate children and so on with the implication of having no class.

The working class need representation in parliament, AR is just one of those people 🤷‍♀️

Primrose53 Sun 01-Sept-24 11:41:47

How has this thread gone from missing posters to this? 🤔

JaneJudge Sun 01-Sept-24 11:43:22

It always does. I think if Gransnet just answered the questions it wouldn’t continue but they don’t seem that bothered 🤷‍♀️

MissAdventure Sun 01-Sept-24 11:44:05

Don't worry, I'm sure someone will start another thread on missing posters soon.

Norah Sun 01-Sept-24 11:48:10

MissAdventure

Don't worry, I'm sure someone will start another thread on missing posters soon.

grin

AGAA4 Sun 01-Sept-24 11:48:56

Doodledog I have heard similar words used using the male genitalia as insults. So not just women but in all other respects women do have a worse time. Even now women are the worst critics of other women.

Jaxjacky Sun 01-Sept-24 11:50:40

Thank you GrannyGravy13 I’m pleased Callistemon isn’t banned.

Allira Sun 01-Sept-24 11:50:58

Nellie Boswell used to call Lilo Lil a 'taaaart', in Bread grin

Has anyone noticed that Aveline from Bread is now Nurse Clinical Lead in Casualty?
(Sorry, off-topic, well).

Allira Sun 01-Sept-24 11:52:10

Doodledog

MissAdventure

Those male insults don't pertain to a mans sexual values where I come from.
There isn't a male version, except "man whore", and doesn't that just sound wonderful?
Yet people think its acceptable to fling it around about Rayner.

That's what I was trying to say grin

Gigolo?
But that sounds rather glamorous.

JaneJudge Sun 01-Sept-24 11:53:08

Women are always reduced to their appearance, always

It doesn’t matter who they are, where they are from, what they’ve achieved, what they lived through. All that matters is what they look like and what they are wearing.

Doodledog Sun 01-Sept-24 11:57:44

JaneJudge

It always does. I think if Gransnet just answered the questions it wouldn’t continue but they don’t seem that bothered 🤷‍♀️

I agree that it was the idea of having a working class woman in power that caused so much of the fury. For some, a woman from a council estate with O levels having a better job than someone with professional qualifications is against the natural order of things. Having such a woman in a position of power over them is simply unconscionable. grin

I also agree that deleting threads is a bit pointless, particularly when we are only told in the vaguest of terms why they have gone. People want to have their say, plus we can't see what's already been said if it's been deleted.

OTOH, if HQ got involved in discussions they would go on forever, and they won't want to go into detail if there is a backstory to any of the bannings, so I understand. In their shoes I would probably just wait till everyone is bored with it all and it fizzles out.

ixion Sun 01-Sept-24 12:01:34

Allira

^Nellie Boswell used to call Lilo Lil a 'taaaart', in Bread^ grin

Has anyone noticed that Aveline from Bread is now Nurse Clinical Lead in Casualty?
(Sorry, off-topic, well).

Is that an old Casualty?

Aveline/Gilly Coman died in 2010.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-10655320

Allira Sun 01-Sept-24 12:06:20

It's Melanie Hill, ixion
She was also Aveline