Gransnet forums

Christmas

The King's Speech

(317 Posts)
Sparklefizz Mon 26-Dec-22 07:20:35

What did you think? I caught up with it on iPlayer last night just to see how it went as it was his first Christmas speech, and I thought he did quite well.

I also thought it was a very good idea not to be filmed sitting at a desk surrounded by personal photos which could then be picked apart.

Normandygirl Mon 26-Dec-22 12:13:09

volver

Couple of minutes about his mother - understandable.

Then a thank you to the armed forces. Made me think that this generation of royals needs to move forward a bit - the armed forces aren't the centre of everyone's lives anymore.

Couple of minutes reminding us about the dedication of people in public service. And trying to align himself and his family with those people.

"A time of great anxiety and hardship"...which he is doing nothing about except making charitable donations with other people's money and reminding us to be nice to each other. What's your government doing about it, Sir?

All those religious organisations providing support for those who need it? I'd rather his government did something about that.

Remember that character is "Are You Being Served" whose line was always "you've all done very well."

What did you think? Well, you did ask.

Oh come on now Volver, I'm sure all the millions of people shivering under their four blankets, struggling to put food on the table and facing the prospect of worse to come, were inspired and uplifted to hear that the richest and most privileged man in the country can identify with their pain.smile

Glorianny Mon 26-Dec-22 12:20:11

it is a tale, told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
Except there wasn't much sound and fury really!

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 12:34:33

Calendargirl

Think your thoughts look to be in the minority so far Volver.

On here, certainly.

That doesn't make them wrong, though.

nadateturbe Mon 26-Dec-22 12:49:44

Oh come on nowVolver, I'm sure all the millions of people shivering under their four blankets, struggling to put food on the table and facing the prospect of worse to come, were inspired and uplifted to hear that the richest and most privileged man in the country can identify with their pain.
Yes, it helps a lot 🙄.
He said what he had to say.

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 12:55:22

I'm with you on that, Normandygirl wink

If it encourages people to hear Charles saying what he did nadateturbe, all well and good. I'm happy for them.

Did nothing for me. I don't understand it. Well off posh bloke tells us we're all doing well? 🎵 That don't impress me much...🎵

Lathyrus Mon 26-Dec-22 12:56:15

It was a Christmas message by a Head of State. Pretty similar in general content to a number from around the world including republics.

Not quite sure what Republicans think would have been different if it had been a President delivering it. Including the wealth and comfort of the deliverer. Ive yet to see an impoverished President😬

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:02:34

The President might be able to actually do something about it, and we wouldn't have to spend millions that could be spent on supporting the population of this country, on watching some religious fella putting his jewelled hat on in a televised ceremony.

Here's an impoverished President. You said you'd never seen one? Well here he is:
simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Mujica

Also, I'd like to point out that the OP asked what we thought of the speech. It's not the Republicans who have decided to make this about systems of government.

Mollygo Mon 26-Dec-22 13:12:44

Well done! We made it to 21!

Baggs Mon 26-Dec-22 13:14:43

Well off posh bloke tells us we're all doing well? 🎵 That don't impress me much...🎵

Except he didn't say that.

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:17:59

Did I watch a different speech?

That's not unlikely... 🤣🤣

I particularly want to pay tribute to all those wonderfully kind people who so generously give food or donations, or that most precious commodity of all, their time, to support those around them in greatest need, together with the many charitable organisations which do such extraordinary work in the most difficult circumstances.

Thanks, Chuck.

Baggs Mon 26-Dec-22 13:22:46

volver

Did I watch a different speech?

That's not unlikely... 🤣🤣

I particularly want to pay tribute to all those wonderfully kind people who so generously give food or donations, or that most precious commodity of all, their time, to support those around them in greatest need, together with the many charitable organisations which do such extraordinary work in the most difficult circumstances.

Thanks, Chuck.

That is not all doing wonderfully, which is what you said he'd said.

the people who needed the food handouts were not included in the paragraph you quote.

All has one meaning and it doesn't mean most.

Baggs Mon 26-Dec-22 13:23:42

Corection: all doing well

Substance remains unchanged.

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:24:10

That is not all doing wonderfully, which is what you said he'd said.

No its not. confused

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:24:30

oops, cross post.

Oreo Mon 26-Dec-22 13:28:02

Really good first speech by Charles, liked it much better than any by the late Queen.
Well done to him!😃

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:28:48

I, personally, don't need people with inherited status telling me what a good citizen I am. I don't actually need people in any position of power, elected or not, praising me for doing something which is essentially being a normal human being with a normal response to people in trouble. It's patronising.

Just the way I think, I suppose. But there are many like me, I imagine.

Oreo Mon 26-Dec-22 13:35:21

Noted Volver 😂😂

But you must note that there are also many like me who liked his speech.

Lathyrus Mon 26-Dec-22 13:38:34

A thank you sometimes goes a long way………

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:38:37

But you must note that there are also many like me who liked his speech.

Yes I know. I just didn't and I've posted about it. I'm not the one getting all bent out of shape with people who disagree with me. confused

BaBaBoom Mon 26-Dec-22 13:41:40

Think your thoughts look to be in the minority so far Volver.

That's the way she likes her it. wink

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 13:43:38

See what I mean Oreo?

Parsley3 Mon 26-Dec-22 13:48:38

He seemed to me to be giving Royal approval to the need for volunteers to support those around them in greatest need and that depresses me. However, I do like him and at least he has had some experience of life outside the confines of Royal palaces. I rarely listened to the Queen's speeches but I was surprised that the young Parsleys wanted to hear what Charles had to say. Perhaps the RF are offering something to the younger generation with the promise of revealing a human touch.

Oreo Mon 26-Dec-22 13:50:57

Hmmm, well I think it comes down to you usually being in the minority with the way you think on every subject and thread Volver but if you don’t care about that, it’s all good.

Rosie51 Mon 26-Dec-22 14:00:33

Volver Here's an impoverished President. You said you'd never seen one? Well here he is:
simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Mujica

Except he's not impoverished from lack of pay, he voluntarily donates 80% of his pay. No country pays its president an impoverished wage.

volver Mon 26-Dec-22 14:05:33

Oreo

Hmmm, well I think it comes down to you usually being in the minority with the way you think on every subject and thread Volver but if you don’t care about that, it’s all good.

Nope, don't care.

Don't care that people try to make out I'm an argumentative old so-and-so only doing it for attention either.