Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Should I send my estranged daughter a birthday card …

(38 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

Dibbydod Mon 25-Jul-22 11:00:32

Hi , some of you may remember couple years ago I’d posted on Gransnet the very same question .
Well, it’s two years down the line and my estranged daughter is still not taking to me . I feel I’ve done everything I can to reconcile with her , but have got nowhere . I’ve sent her lovely hand written messages saying how much I love and miss her , poured out my heart to her , but still nothing . My son & even her dad has tried to talk to her but she just closes down . Last Christmas I’d sent her a beautiful card with Daughter on it , also wrote a heartfelt poem inside , I did think that maybe that would soften her heart , especially as it were Christmas, but no , absolutely nothing .
Anyway , the reason I’m writing this again is because it’s her birthday coming up , yet again , and I’m at a loss as to what to do . Just a couple weeks ago we’re my big milestone birthday , I hoped & prayed that she would remember and send me a card ..but no ..absolutely nothing . This time it hurt me much more than other times because it were a milestone birthday .
Now I don’t know what to do , part of me is telling me to just give up and leave well alone , not send her a card , but , the other side is telling me to send her a card as I’ll regret it if I don’t . I would very much appreciate the views of other Gransnetters as I know that you all can be so very kind and helpful .

VioletSky Mon 25-Jul-22 18:30:06

Maybe daughters partner just felt awkward or embarassed.

But definitely a good thing if you feel a bit stronger

Dibbydod Mon 25-Jul-22 19:33:42

Smileless2012

You don't have to apologise for what you've posted Dibbydod, please don't think that you do.

FWIW I think it's good that you now feel you have to put the whole experience behind you, despite the unpleasant incident that brought you to that conclusion.

Sometimes we need to be angry to find the strength and the courage to do what must be done.

From 'Dead Babies and Seaside Towns' by Alice Jolly
"All who live should rage. People who are angry get up int the morning, people who are sad sometimes don't."

Thank you smileless 2012 I agree with what you say . I’ll sleep on it , tomorrows another day .

StTrinians Sat 28-Feb-26 10:28:01

Thanks.

NotSpaghetti Sat 28-Feb-26 10:46:24

I would do as Maw says but might write even less.
A card with "daughter" on - or words/poems would be a no-no (and arguably triggering).

I'd probably just say "thinking of you, love, Mum"

fancyflowers Sat 28-Feb-26 10:46:32

I would do as Maw suggested and send an ordinary card.

You never know, one day something might happen in her life to make her realize how much she is missing out. Don't give up. This rejection must be very hard to bear.

Cossy Sat 28-Feb-26 10:50:35

Chewbacca

Maw's suggestion sounds perfect; shows you're thinking of her but putting no pressure on.

I agree. Tbh my heart goes out to all families finding themselves is this situation, whether there is blame or fault, it’s heartbreaking.

NotSpaghetti Sat 28-Feb-26 10:52:33

I am deeply sorry that you are so missing your daughter but you are fortunate that have a family and friends. Cherish the ones that you can.
I hope you are finding love and peace elsewhere.
flowers

SORES Sat 28-Feb-26 11:16:58

StTrinians

Thanks.

reported

SORES Sat 28-Feb-26 11:17:25

zombie thread

AnnieGransnet (GNHQ) Sat 28-Feb-26 11:39:56

Just a heads up that this thread was started in 2022.

NotSpaghetti Sat 28-Feb-26 12:15:01

Oh thank you.

I suppose it will still help someone.
Fingers crossed!

Maremia Sat 28-Feb-26 12:16:55

Third Zombie Thread today.