I am in the odd position of choosing to no longer see my mother, and my daughter choosing to no longer see me, all at the same time. They now live together on the other side of the city we live in, and whilst my daughter is there, she will not come back into our lives because my mother is so negative about me -- she believes she is loving towards me, 'despite' her belief (often expressed) that I am a liar / cheat / generally bad person. I am none of these things, and the only people who think this are my sister, mother and daughter.
Family legend has it that a few months after I was born, my sister told my mother that she could 'take Rasamara back to the hospital now, we don't want her'. She would have been almost 3 at the time, and having witnessed just how obsessed my mother can get with newborn babies, I can picture how much my sister was left out and ignored in this time. But having realised this wasn't going to happen, my sister set about doing everything she could to get me into trouble, particularly when she herself was either about to be told off, or was unhappy. And it wasn't difficult -- I wanted to be her friend, and would do pretty much anything for her, and would often get into trouble as a result, whilst my sister looked on, smirking. When I didn't comply with instructions, it was really easy for her to provoke me into retaliating, and then rush to my mother to tell her what the latest thing I had done was. Over time it was established that this was how my sister would make herself feel better when she was upset (by watching me get into trouble) and that I was quite simply a 'bad' child. Friends who have known me since childhood said it was obvious then how I was treated, and how my sister was always 'the golden haired child who could do no wrong'. And yet it is me that my mother has always had a very unhealthily enmeshed relationship with, meaning it was very difficult for me to separate from her.
A few years ago -- I am in my late 50s, my sister is in her early 60s -- I decided I'd had enough. Friends had been telling me for decades to stop seeing them, but I've always just wanted them to like me. Now, I don't speak to either, and as a result my confidence has begun to grow. Sadly, as I was separating from my mother, her influence in my daughter grew -- possibly because I was no longer enmeshed with her and she needed a replacement. It did not help mine and my daughter's relationship during her very fractious teen years. I've not seen my daughter for almost 3 years now, which breaks my heart every time I dare even think about it (like now). And yes, the shame around that is overwhelming, and I don't talk about it to anyone other than close friends. When others ask how she is and what she's doing, I invent things and as quickly as I can move the conversation on.
I hope one day to be able to mend the relationship with my daughter. But I also know that if she feels she is better without me then I must let her be, because I will do anything to add to her sense of well-being, even if it means never speaking to her again. I genuinely just wants her to be happy, even if that's at the expense of my own happiness. And the part of me that will always wish for a mother that believes in me will never go away, but it is making peace with the knowledge that I did not, and cannot, ever have this, and it's not my fault. It's a work in progress, and I manage my confidence by compartmentalising all the different pains involved I think.
Are any of the posters here fathers talking about estrangement or are we all mothers? Is it something that is more painful for us? Happens more to mothers? I know there are a few mothers talking about their sons, but I wondered about fathers?