Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Estrangers and their 'entitled' expectations

(208 Posts)
Flower21 Mon 12-Aug-24 02:00:28

There is a growing trend for adult children to cut contact with their parents. It seems to be the modern way for the 40 something to deal with conflict with their parents. Do they really believe that they will get away with breaking hearts and ruining lives and then later collect their 'entitlement' in the shape of inheritance? You can't provide childcare for your grandchildren even though you are yourself working full time, no problem, I will cut you out of my life and still expect to inherit and the sooner the better... Any views please regarding being estranged by adult children and therefore cutting them out of our will.

Norah Mon 12-Aug-24 18:00:31

Sara1954

March, I think you’re right, I think we just put up with stuff, looking back at what I meekly put up with makes me quite angry now.

Well done you. Done, no drama.

I'm sorry you are angry now, however having horrid people near could be far worse, in my opinion. Clean breaks are advantageous.

Sara1954 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:03:20

Thank you Smileless, I know your situation from many conversations, I also know you have been a huge support to others.
Every situation is different, you are right, we shouldn’t judge each other.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:03:58

however having horrid people near could be far worse, in my opinion I agree Norah. Despite what we have lost I think having our ES's wife in our lives would have been far worse in the long term.

Sara1954 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:05:33

Norah, you’re right, I’m only angry at myself for being such a doormat!

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:07:36

Let go of the anger Sara and be proud of what you've done. It may have taken a while, but you got there in the end.

Purplepixie Mon 12-Aug-24 18:08:57

I havent seen or spoken to my daughter in nearly 10 years. Thankfully her dad, my daughters ex husband got in touch with my and I have only missed out on 2 years of their childrens lives. My granddaughters. They are teenagers now and text when they want to come and stay. BUT one of them recently asked me outright just what they were going to get when I die. I was shocked, saddened and disappointed. I have not included my daughter in my will but I am leaving something for my grand kids but I do not see a need to tell them in advance. I hope to live until I am 100 and stuff the lot of them.

Purplepixie Mon 12-Aug-24 18:34:22

Whoops sorry, should read. Thankfully my granddaughters dad, my daughters ex husband got in touch with me etc.

Feverjo Mon 12-Aug-24 18:40:39

I don't think it's reasonable to expect inheritance from someone you didn't want in your life.

Likewise, I don't think anyone who would use the threat of losing an inheritance is someone to keep in your life.

If the goal is peace and healing, as estrangement is a last resort to, putting a monetary value on it by way of inheritance just feels so wrong.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:45:48

I hope to live until I am 100 and stuff the lot of them sounds like a plan Purplepixie smile.

I would have thought threatening to take away someone's inheritance if they don't do what you want is a sure fire way of losing the relationship.

Bridie22 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:51:37

Emotional blackmail isn't how I would expect a reconciliation!

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:56:30

No me Bridie or what I expect a healthy relationship to be based on.

Sara1954 Mon 12-Aug-24 18:59:30

My mother has told my husband often that if I don’t go and see her she’ll cut me out of her will, what sort of person would that make me? A greedy, hypocritical person is what, and it infuriates me that she thinks I might be tempted.

tickingbird Mon 12-Aug-24 19:01:45

I agree with the OP that it does appear to be a growing trend, along with labelling people as narcissists at the drop of a hat.
Going no contact seems to be another phrase frequently used, along with flying monkeys etc.

I, personally, don’t have experience of this but I have a good friend who’s a victim of such behaviour. To say she’s been devastated is an understatement. She’s been run ragged by her two AS and really gone out of her way to do everything for them. One weekend couldn’t visit and bang! Finished. No longer required, couldn’t see grandchildren anymore and as if she doesn’t exist. I know this lady very well and she isn’t in the slightest bit pushy or demanding, far from it. 8 years since this happened and she suffers terribly with anxiety brought on by this.

I accept some parents are toxic and AC need to cut contact but I do believe it’s something of a trend and that some selfish AC just don’t want to be bothered with their parents anymore so cook up excuses.

If it happened to me with no good reason I would cut them out of my will, no matter how upsetting.

Feverjo Mon 12-Aug-24 19:02:46

Agreed, Birdie. Not a lot of information in the OP but based on the very limited details it looks like learned behaviour for the family.

Can't babysit--we won't you include you in our lives much.

Don't include me? I'll disinherit you.

Surely there are more healthy ways to resolve family conflict than to emotionally blackmail each other.

Maybe family counselling would be beneficial. It teach tools of effective communication so that messages can get across without the anger and threats.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 19:04:45

Well you've shown her that you're not tempted Sara smile.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 19:15:37

Your poor friend tickingbird, dumped because she couldn't babysit. When I read things like this I can't help but hope that what goes around does come around.

I agree Feverjo there is limited information in the OP so limited in fact that I'm wondering why you've said that it looks like learned behaviour for the family confused.

Babs03 Mon 12-Aug-24 19:21:29

We have been able to heal since becoming estranged from our daughter. When I remember all the abuse to our faces and online, how we had to tread on egg shells around her, and the constant put downs making us feel 2 inches tall, it reminds me why all our lives are more tolerable without her in them, ourselves and our other 3 daughters.
Sadly I also became estranged from my sister who took sides with my daughter and joined in a racist chorus against my husband.
Am still on meds but have come through the breakdown and am looking forward to moving to a new house and starting a new chapter.
We still send money/presents and cards on birthdays and Xmas to our daughter and GCs, but not sure how much longer we should do it, don’t even know if she gives what we buy to the GCs anyway.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 19:30:14

Good news about your move and the new chapter you'll be starting Babs.

It was the best thing we could have done and has really helped us on our healing journey. So much so that after 7.5 years our time here has ended and we are moving again to begin another new chapter.

If and when the time comes to stop sending money, presents and cards for birthdays and Christmas you'll know it's right. It took me by surprise a couple of years ago when we decided to stop sending cards to our GC; we never sent gifts or money.

A bigger surprise was disposing of the memory box a few weeks ago we've had for the GC, and have added too over the years since we were estranged.

Babs03 Mon 12-Aug-24 19:33:41

Smileless2012

Good news about your move and the new chapter you'll be starting Babs.

It was the best thing we could have done and has really helped us on our healing journey. So much so that after 7.5 years our time here has ended and we are moving again to begin another new chapter.

If and when the time comes to stop sending money, presents and cards for birthdays and Christmas you'll know it's right. It took me by surprise a couple of years ago when we decided to stop sending cards to our GC; we never sent gifts or money.

A bigger surprise was disposing of the memory box a few weeks ago we've had for the GC, and have added too over the years since we were estranged.

We started a memory box but I got too upset by it.
Thanks for your kind comments.
x

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 19:39:46

You're welcome Babs. I wish you peace and happiness in your new home x flowers.

Grams2five Mon 12-Aug-24 20:17:50

I will add that I think in large part this is a one sided problem. At least it seems to be from where I stand. I’ve met in life over the years a handful or more of people who , for one reason or the other were estranged from their parents - and with the advent of online forums many online. Not one has ever expected to receive or wanted any sort of inheritance. Nearly all
Had been threatened with losing one when they cut contact - and
On here there’s often posts of estranged parents worrying about how and when “to cut them off”. Most people who estrange seem to not
Care nearly as much about the “inheritance “ as those being estranged seem to think they do

Grams2five Mon 12-Aug-24 20:20:53

Hit post too soon!

So my advice would be to spend the money of yourselves. , live your life to its fullest and leave anything left over to whomever you want.

Feverjo Mon 12-Aug-24 20:23:20

I can attest to this as well, as my husband wouldn't so much as attend an estate meeting much less accept an inheritance.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Aug-24 21:10:00

That's my advice too Grams and for anyone whose been estranged and worries that not leaving their estranger an inheritance is the wrong thing to do, hopefully they'll be reassured by those who have estranged that an inheritance wouldn't be wanted anyway.

Sara1954 Mon 12-Aug-24 22:07:33

I think for most of us who have estranged our parents, we would have liked a different story.
I was always envious of my friends who were close with their families, I would have loved to have been part of an affectionate loving family.
I also had a good relationship with my in-laws, my mother in law could be annoying at times, but she was always kind and generous, and I loved my father in law. We were together from a young age, and they always looked out for me.
So although I don’t consider myself to be without blame, I know I tried my best.
Sometimes people just don’t like each other, and nothing can change that