Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Not fully estranged but gaining depth into what it is

(291 Posts)
Eugenia Wed 07-May-25 23:43:28

I have learned something in these forums by just reading so many of these posts from broken hearted parents, that estrangment can happen to the best of parents if the situation in life opens a door for it. It seems so very easy these days, when life gets difficult or busy, for people to throw away those who care the most, the parents.

I truly wonder if it is because people always want what they don't have (love of others) but not what they do have (love of parents). It's amazing how much work they will put in to get friends, gain popularity and will work like hll to get someone to love them.
Maybe because they feel it's a victory of sorts, an accomplishment, and makes them feel worthy as a person because they made it happen. Parental love isn't something they had to accomplish or work for, that's the difference?

It's a mystery to me why other people mean so much more to them than the people who love them in a way nobody else on earth really can, even if they wanted to. Parent/child bond is something so natural and powerful, that's why I feel no other relationship can really replicate or exceed it. I am quite aware that there exists some colder parents out there, but I am not really referring to those anomalies because they are a minority in the world. Majority of parents love deeply and it's become something disposable for the young, as they go out and strive to prove themselves to others. They never had to prove anything to their parents.

Maybe not having to prove/working for something makes that something seem worthless???? And of course, now society is full of "toxic" parents and grandparents, according to the most popular publications, which lets face it, someone's making money off these trends. I think that may be the core of it all......a gullible, emotionally lost society looks to those so called professionals they feel have all the answers, but what they really have are fat bank accounts off their chosen field of constant critisism and promotion of it's all about me and my victimhood generation.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 16:49:05

BlessedArt

GoPhish

You call your own child a bitch while believing her claim that you're a "bad grandma" holds no water...Interesting.

Your daughter may have issues, but your manic, self-absorbed "parenting" style is the last thing she needs.

I think it’s safe to say we see why the daughter has issues.

Nah, you have no idea what you are actually talking about. I am the one experiencing this betrayal. Nobody gets treated like I have been over what someone else did and comes out with no bitterness, pain, anger and resentment. Normal responses for such treatment. Her issues are her own, caused by other influences, other traumas outside of her immediate family.

But I think the tendency to reject and blame someone, whoever is closest, is pretty common. When that goes to far, you sever relationships and that's what she's done to her own mother. It's a pretty cruel thing to do actually. That's on her.

Luminance Wed 14-May-25 18:19:32

It's never acceptable to use such language to our own family members, it is an insult, insults are designed to wound. It is I am afraid rather a clear sign of emotional immaturity. There are constructive ways to word things that contain a clear and concise reason for frustration or hurt.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 19:23:34

Luminance

It's never acceptable to use such language to our own family members, it is an insult, insults are designed to wound. It is I am afraid rather a clear sign of emotional immaturity. There are constructive ways to word things that contain a clear and concise reason for frustration or hurt.

ONCE Again..I didn't not use this language to my daughter. I used it to describe what she has become since her husband left her, on this forum only. It is actually a mild assessment compared to her cruelty, but I am not sure how to find a stronger word. Please try and keep up.

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 19:33:24

Continue defending the indefensible by focusing on meaningless semantics. We are talking about your mindset, your attitude, your view towards your daughter. So, keep up!

There are mothers who can handle the same frustrations with infinitely more grace, empathy, wisdom, and maturity.

Self-absorbed parenting style isn't actually real. It seems like a facetous joke pointing out that your style of parenting isn't parenting at all.

Luminance Wed 14-May-25 19:35:04

It makes very little difference in my opinion. The word was said and meant.

Smileless2012 Wed 14-May-25 19:35:31

It's very frustrating but often power for the cause here to be responded too about things we haven't actually said Eugenia, and I'm not convinced it's done in innocence but rather to goad a reaction.

Luminance Wed 14-May-25 19:42:39

Smileless2012 Is that what you genuinely believe? Do you think perhaps that is what you perceive instead? The most genuine people will tell you clearly and concisely where they see an issue without insult not malice. Those people are perhaps to be trusted and listened too because it takes true empathy to tell you the truth and they would be trusted to catch you from a fall too when you are able to hear it.

Smileless2012 Wed 14-May-25 19:50:57

Yes, it's what I genuinely believe Luminance because as we can see from this thread alone, there are responses that are indeed insulting and malicious.

I don't believe that they come from people who are to be trusted or should be listened too. As for being told the truth, all any of us can offer are our opinions and the best way to show empathy is to believe what we are told and not to twist or misrepresent what is being said here.

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 19:59:05

You seem absolutely hell-bent on villianizing your daughter. As if you view life so simply that you think it has a clear bad and good guy (and if your daughter is the bad guy in this story, than you are the ...)

You appear to lack the maturity to successfully navigate the complexities of life. Just because she makes mistakes doesn't absolve you of yours.

You still have a lot of growing up to do, but probably don't have enough time to do it.

May you and your daughter find peace, one way or another.

Luminance Wed 14-May-25 20:02:45

Who are you talking about specifically Smileless2012?

Smileless2012 Wed 14-May-25 20:09:04

You can't miss them Luminance unless you want too of course.

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 20:10:00

Smileless2012

Yes, it's what I genuinely believe Luminance because as we can see from this thread alone, there are responses that are indeed insulting and malicious.

I don't believe that they come from people who are to be trusted or should be listened too. As for being told the truth, all any of us can offer are our opinions and the best way to show empathy is to believe what we are told and not to twist or misrepresent what is being said here.

I'm ingenuinely sorry to hear that you have so much trouble trusting your own judgement, that you (almost) solely rely on emotions; whether the message made you feel happy smile or if it made you feel sad sad

Truth is truth no matter how harshly expressed.

Luminance Wed 14-May-25 20:18:41

Smileless2012

You can't miss them Luminance unless you want too of course.

It's troubling when such a comment comes after my own. Perhaps just report anything suspicious and move on with your day in peace.

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 20:20:52

Namaste

Smileless2012 Wed 14-May-25 20:37:04

I have absolutely no trouble trusting my own judgement Stoppableforce, it's sometimes the judgement of others that I struggle with.

I report if I feel it's necessary Luminance.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 20:37:40

Smileless2012

It's very frustrating but often power for the cause here to be responded too about things we haven't actually said Eugenia, and I'm not convinced it's done in innocence but rather to goad a reaction.

You most likely, are right.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 20:42:00

StoppableForce

Continue defending the indefensible by focusing on meaningless semantics. We are talking about your mindset, your attitude, your view towards your daughter. So, keep up!

There are mothers who can handle the same frustrations with infinitely more grace, empathy, wisdom, and maturity.

Self-absorbed parenting style isn't actually real. It seems like a facetous joke pointing out that your style of parenting isn't parenting at all.

You're one of those I see. Well what on earth makes you think I am the only one who views my daughter this way? She has done and said worse to me you can't imagine. People who see it know it. Bugg off now.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 20:58:37

StoppableForce

You seem absolutely hell-bent on villianizing your daughter. As if you view life so simply that you think it has a clear bad and good guy (and if your daughter is the bad guy in this story, than you are the ...)

You appear to lack the maturity to successfully navigate the complexities of life. Just because she makes mistakes doesn't absolve you of yours.

You still have a lot of growing up to do, but probably don't have enough time to do it.

May you and your daughter find peace, one way or another.

May we now? Oh my you really wish that. Yeah sure, excellent try at attempting to make yourself look good after drilling judgements into a total stranger. What a compassionate soul you are hahaha. Phoney people, gotta love em...

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 20:59:46

StoppableForce

Namaste

Oh my god stop. Too funny!!

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 21:00:06

If that is how you genuinely view your situatuon than you must not of had good enough role models in life.

You yourself called your daughter a bitch. Noone is twisting or misrepresnting your words.

You have displayed unmotherly, immature behavior, and unsuprisingly, you lack the maturity to learn and grow from this.

It's actually crazy that you feel entitled to your daughter's children when you call her a bitch (in your head).

Actual lunacy.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 21:07:19

Actually not at all. Children are separate beings from their parents. Anyone who uses children as weapons are abusing both the children and the adult they are already abusung. Entitled? Definately entitled, as are the loving children, to have a relationship if they so choose.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 21:12:30

Do you believe children are owned by their parents, with no right to love who they love, be forced not to have a relationship with anyone other than mom approved? Forced to think like mom believe moms lies and slander?
Sort of fascist isn't it?

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 21:37:02

I repeat.

Actual lunacy.

StoppableForce Wed 14-May-25 21:39:34

Idk how to help you.

Try imagining Mr. Rogers in your position. Do you think he would ever insult his child (let alone use a cuss word), no matter how much they may have slighted him.

Try to be more like Mr. Rogers, he's a perfect role model.

Eugenia Wed 14-May-25 21:51:44

Who asked for your help? Anyone at all here? I must have missed it. Boy what a narcissist! Is that on purpose? Why are you babbling about Mr. Rogers? Ok wait I think I have been had by a troll. Boring.