Gransnet forums

Grandparenting

Should I provide Childcare??

(107 Posts)
LouLou23 Sun 11-Jun-23 05:28:05

Hi there, I am new to the site and encouraged to find some discussion on this subject. I did want to get some specific feedback though on my situation. My daughter recently asked me if I would take care of her baby 3-4 days a week all day, as she has to go back to work after 4 months after the baby is born. My jaw dropped. She is not open to a flexible arrangement (her OCD) so its either Montessori Daycare or me watching my grandchild and her and her husband taking one-two days off from work a week. I would love to help her and be with my new grandchild. I help raised my youngest daughter's son as she was a single Mom. But that was 10 years ago and not only is my energy level much less, but I've developed several conditions that cause chronic pain, one being fibromyalgia. I am fine as I have learned to manage it all and have learned to push through the pain and fatigue. I am honored she would entrust me with her baby and envision being the perfect Grandma and Mom watching the baby and supporting my daughter and son in law! I have a 12 hour a week job now answering the phone at a medical clinic, which is a very easy, low stress job. Watching the baby would be twice as many hours for half the pay. And then there is the endurance and pain level. I usually am in my recliner about 2 or 3pm each day recovering and resting, to manage my pain levels. I am so divided and not thinking clearly. Any input would be appreciated.

rosie1959 Sun 11-Jun-23 06:09:17

With the best will in the world LouLoo23 from how you describe your physical condition it would be far too much for you.
I have looked after my grandaughter from age 6 months for one day a week I am in good health and reasonably fit but it was tiring especially when she was a baby. My daughter has always been happy with this and for the other 4 days she was in full time nursery. I am always about to step in for the odd times and now take and pick her up from school one day a week.
You have had your children and now your life is your own help out by all means but not for extended periods.
You cannot rest in your recliner when you have a baby to look after.
You also have your own job which I presume you enjoy would you have to give thus up?

LouLou23 Sun 11-Jun-23 06:21:45

Hopefully this comes as a reply to Rosie! Thanks for your input. You are so right about the one day a week and then filling in here and there. Even that is a stretch on our energy isn't it? I did something similar with my last grandson. I had to chuckle reading your words, that you can't watch a baby if you are in your recliner! Really, it is you can't sit in your recliner if you are watching a baby, lol. And yes I would have to give up my 12 hour a week job. I feel selfish comparing them, but I would be working for my daughter for twice the hours (about 24) for what I make in my little job for 12 hours, sitting and answering the phone. I do it for extra income and to get out of the house and socialize. I also get free Veterinarian Care for my cats as it is a Vet clinic. I thought I would be happy being able to stop working this job, but now I'm not so sure.

Oopsadaisy1 Sun 11-Jun-23 06:24:51

I think you have answered your own post!

Childcare will be for 4 years, with the best will in the world as you aren’t well at the moment I can’t see you being fit enough to look after a toddler, plus you will miss socialising.

Opt for one day a week and let the parents sort out the rest.

Madgran77 Sun 11-Jun-23 06:35:37

One day a week is a sensible compromise. You daughter and SIL either accept that offer for they dont really ...but why wouldn't they? This one day will enable you to build lovely routines and a relationship with your grandchild without being totally exhausted.

Mizuna Sun 11-Jun-23 06:37:53

It's lovely to be involved with grandchildren isn't it LouLou? But as you know the baby will grow into a boisterous toddler! I looked after my granddaughter from age six months until she was five years old, three days a week, and that was quite enough and I had no health issues. What you are being asked to do sounds very tiring, however enjoyable it would be otherwise. And it does sound as if you would miss your job. All the best in making your mind up!

Visgir1 Sun 11-Jun-23 08:22:05

Me thinks that's a No IMO.. . 4 days you will have the baby more than the parents.
By all means help but from friends experience and including myself 4 days is too much.
You need to maintain your job that's income and self worth. Your illness as well can lead to bad days with a baby there, more stress.

My friend does 3 days and she regrets it. Also it has put her relationship with her daughter on rocky ground, with her daughter wanting things done her way, and the Grandma not complying to these exact rules.

I look after my grandson from 3.30 - 6 pm and 10 - 6pm over 2 days that's enough for me as I also work 2 days a week. Luckily Grandad is around he was a godsend when I got my Hip replacement last year.
You need to have a frank conversation with your daughter, see what you can sort and support.
Good luck

NotSpaghetti Sun 11-Jun-23 08:33:11

A Montessori nursery is a great option.

I would not have the energy to do what your daughter is asking.
If she is on the spectrum and wants absolute continuity the pressure will be immense if you start on this path and then get to the point where you can't continue.

Value your " social" happy vet job (and don't forget the cat cover that comes with it) and say no.

Tell her what you have told us - that you are honored she would entrust you with her baby and can offer her one day (or 2 half days if that works for you) but you don't feel able to do what she is asking.

Thinking of you. flowers

Primrose53 Sun 11-Jun-23 08:43:46

What I don’t understand is why kids even ASK parents who are not in good health to help out. When I went back to work my parents were newly retired. I was going to ask them but I realised one day that they could do what they want, when they wanted and enjoy days out together. They also had a few bob for the first time in their lives as they were both getting state pensions. I decided to pay a childminder instead.

My own nieces asked their Mum to look after their kids while they worked and she had been seriously ill with cancer. My husband was furious as it was too much for her. She did though because she said “she felt sorry for them” but she has passed away now.

Humbertbear Sun 11-Jun-23 09:39:33

We had all of our grandchildren in turn for one day a week before they went to school. One day a week was enough. It is tiring! There is a reason why women in their 60s can’t have babies. We don’t have the same energy. You have to say a polite and gentle no.

Witzend Sun 11-Jun-23 09:54:42

You need to explain, much as you have here, why you’re sorry that it’s just not going to be possible.

I was 67 and in relatively good health when Gdd1 arrived, and did do one day a week (I offered) until Gds arrived only 15 months later. I knew that 2 would be too much - especially if they didn’t have coordinated naps - so after dd’s mat. leave was over, we helped with childcare costs instead.

I/we will still do emergencies/one offs - Gdd1 is 8 now and there’s a Gdd2 of 3 - but I do frankly find it all a lot more tiring now.

I’d just add, when Gds was only 4 months, he was in hospital for a week with severe bronchiolitis. For most of that week (dd being at the hospital) I looked after Gdd1, still then under 2. She was a very easy little girl, but I still found it exhausting. I felt like a wet rag once I eventually got home (60 miles away), promptly succumbed to a stinking cold, followed almost immediately by shingles!

I still put that down to my immune system being badly affected by exhaustion. Awful warning!!!

eazybee Sun 11-Jun-23 10:03:56

The issue that needs to be confronted is your daughter's obsessive compulsive disorder. She is attempting to return to work far too soon, and trying to blackmail you into doing four days a week full time care for her child. You clearly do not want to, and you should not be compelled by guilt into doing it.
The care of the baby is the parents' responsibility and they must sort it out, putting . Again, the mother must confront the OCD issue; the baby's welfare comes first. first
You do one day, she does two and the father one. Covered, and all within the family.

Shelflife Sun 11-Jun-23 10:31:01

I had my GC one day each week, loved it! but any more than that would have been a chore!! You know your limitations so stick to your guns. You have a 12 hour a week job that you enjoy with the added bonus of free veterinary care for your cat - that is a great bonus - don't lose it! IMO 3 to 4 days each week is far too much even if you were in perfect health. You daughter may be paying you for childcare but that makes no difference, she is asking too much of you. I recognize her OCD may complicate the situation but you must follow your feelings and say no to having your life disrupted in this monumental fashion!!! Their child , their responsibility they must sort this out themselves. I read about this so often and recognize some grandparents are happy to devote so much of their lives to their GC and that is fine , but you are not in the best of health so take care of yourself. IMO parents should not expect their own parents to ' bring up their children ' !??? Just to add I love my GC dearly and although they are all in school now I am here for them in an emergency, and they love the odd sleep over at Grandma's!
I most certainly would not have had my GC 3/ 4 days each week , even when git and younger - and my AC earn very little. I have had my children and most certainly did not rely on my lovely Mum for too much. Adult children are just that - ADULTS!!!! They should behave as such.

JenniferEccles Sun 11-Jun-23 10:39:33

Is it an absolute financial necessity for your daughter to return to work when the baby is only four months old?
It’s so soon isn’t it? What about feeding?
If she really doesn’t have to work, couldn’t you gently try to persuade her to defer work and just enjoy her baby?

We don’t necessarily realise it at the time but the early days and weeks with a new baby just pass so quickly. I think it’s so sad that so many mothers miss out on so much by rushing back to work too soon.

Unfortunately of course in some cases the family finances mean that new mothers have to be earning which may be the case here.

Regarding the possibility of you helping with childcare though, is your daughter aware of how your illness affects you?
Fibromyalgia is a nasty illness.

ChickenLicken Sun 11-Jun-23 10:42:12

LouLou23 some great advice & suggestions shared here. From my own experience, I had DGS all day once a week to help out, when he started nursery there was more travelling & school runs - tiring but that was 15 years ago & I coped. I have done a lot of childminding for the DGCs (10/7/5/4/2) but I find their parents’ expectations of me are too much (unnecessary sleepovers for the parents’ social lives; long hours, tricky school runs as distance & parking make it a nightmare). I could go on.
Bottom line is, I want to be a grandmother, not a daycare facility. Family business means I can potentially be flexible but I still have to get work done, meaning later hours etc for me. AC don’t take hints & I was getting increasingly resentful. The only thing that improved matters was a major row between AC which I got dragged into, it allowed me to speak up & now some of the AC are sulky towards me. But I’m fed up of the manipulation & emotional blackmail. There are many other grandparents in the schoolyard who confide similar thoughts, love the DGC, don’t mind helping out, but it is too much/too tiring/taking up time that we should be free to spend as we please.
When raising our brood, I worked nights whilst DH had the kids. I never expected nor got help from others & childcare options were abysmal around here in the 80s.
I hope you find a way forward that is right for you, it’s one thing minding a baby who can be rocked to sleep, completely another when it’s a preschooler with endless energy who needs to be kept safe.

JaneJudge Sun 11-Jun-23 10:56:11

Jennifer Eccles, the poster sounds like she is in the US and women don't have the same maternity protection as what they do in the UK.

I agree that Montessori nursery sounds like a good plan. There should be no expectation that grandparents give up their own job to raise their grandchildren. I realise this is a very Western view but I don;t necessarily think it is wrong

Shelflife Sun 11-Jun-23 11:04:49

LouLou, it looks like you now have your answer, good luck . If you can manage one day a week child care then fine - but do no be afraid to say NO ! Chicken Licken makes a very good point - she wants to be a GM not a child care facility - please think about that. How any parent can even think that their own Mum would be happy to have their child for 4 days each week beggars belief!!!

Charleygirl5 Sun 11-Jun-23 11:22:30

Free vet care to me is a no brainer. How could you be expected to give up your job for half the pay and 3 times the work?

You enjoy your job with the perks attached. I know what I would do. Your daughter will have to look elsewhere.

The odd emergency is fine but not almost the entire week.

Bella23 Sun 11-Jun-23 11:27:35

My answer would be no. The Montessori can give far more than you can with your illness and they are there every day what if you have a bad day and need to rest or a hospital appointment?
I don't think they are really considering your circumstances and are playing with your heartstrings by asking.

Megslotts Sun 11-Jun-23 11:28:25

If they can afford a Montessori nursery let them do that! I have said to my daughter in the past, I love you all very dearly but I can't look after a baby full time. 4 days is full time. I'd do 1 day maybe. And without sounding heartless why have another baby if Mom has decided to go back to work? Maybe they both need part time jobs so that they can juggle their own childcare. I don't agree that it should just be Mom sorting the care out.

vampirequeen Sun 11-Jun-23 11:30:13

Say you won't do it all the time but are willing to help out in emergencies.

You've recognised that you're not as fit as you once were and childcare is exhausting.

Much as you'd like to help, you need to put yourself first.

grandtanteJE65 Sun 11-Jun-23 11:58:08

Dear grandma, no way. Fibromyalgi is as you know chronic, painful and tiring,

And giving up a job to earn less, doing more, isn't on either, is it?

Unfortunately, saying no, may well cause offence to your DD and SIL especially as you looked after your other grandchild ten years ago.

The diplomatic way of saying no, would to my mind, be to hint gently that you are terrified that your chronic ailment might mean you could not look after the baby properly.

Wasn't it Jo in Little Women who was accused of having dropped Amy into the coal scuttle when she was a baby? All right in fiction, but not so good in real life!

Smileless2012 Sun 11-Jun-23 12:07:04

I have nothing really to add to what's already been said LouLou. You shouldn't feel you're being selfish, 4 days a week is a big commitment and it would be harder I think, if you agreed to do this only to find you couldn't manage having given up your job in the process.

One day a week and helping out if the baby is unwell as a nursery wouldn't take the baby if s/he was unwell. That would give your D and SIL peace of mind.

pascal30 Sun 11-Jun-23 12:15:48

Montessori is a lovely atmosphere for a baby.. you obviously wouldn't be able to cope.. one day a week max..

M0nica Sun 11-Jun-23 12:25:37

The key to this is how you tell your daughter, given that you were able to look after your younge daughter's child.

Say that you would love to do for her what you did for her sister BUT, and then explain about your health problems and loss of stamina, let her know that both your children are equally important to you and so are your DGC.

So often when hard decisions like this need to be made, everything hangs on how you deliver the decision rather than the decision itself.