Newdawn
Doodledog..have you ever looked after two small children and a baby. The little boy had been, I think, to a play scheme which would have been with strangers, so unsettling and he wanted his mum.I absolutely don't agree with physical punishment but if a five year old hits you it is,though not desirable, forgiveable if in the moment you tap him on the bum. The op sounds like a loving, caring grandmother.
Yes, I have - several times - but I'm unclear as to why you are asking me about this.
My comments were about the lack of information until near the end of the thread (at which point I said that I would have edited had we not cross-posted), the fact that the OP was very clearly criticising her daughter's parenting choices (eg the plays days) on the Internet, which I found uncomfortable, and that under no circumstances is hitting a child acceptable. I also pointed out that people were jumping to conclusions about the daughter based on the very partial information given by the OP. I never once said that she is not loving or caring to the grandchildren - maybe you haven't bothered to read the thread before jumping on me, or perhaps you are mixing me up with someone else?
Why are people insisting that this was a 'tap'? How would a 'tap' deter a child from doing anything? People change vocabulary and use euphemisms to cover for things that they regret or feel bad about. The OP used the word 'smack' later in the thread, which is still a euphemism, but probably closer to reality than 'tap'. And it's not up to any of us to 'forgive' it (or otherwise).