Gransnet forums

News & politics

Article 50

(860 Posts)
Mair Thu 26-Jan-17 14:36:09

Well its been announced that Jeremy Corbyn is applying a three line whip to his MPs to make them support the triggering of article 50.

I admire Jeremy for this, it's an act of leadership, and it could save Labours bacon in the many Northern Brexit seats that they hold, so in that sense I am not entirely pleased because it will weaken UKIPs chances. It will also weaken Paul Nuttalls chances in Stoke.

What do the Bremain Labour supporters on GN feel about this?

gillybob Thu 02-Feb-17 10:02:44

Of course not Mair much safer for her to be poorly I think!

I reckon she'll be right as rain today though

Jalima Thu 02-Feb-17 10:29:33

My very best wishes to Diane for a speedy recovery.
If only she'd asked I could have gone round with some hot soup, paracetamol and the offer of a lift to the Commons.
Diane - flowers

Anniebach Thu 02-Feb-17 10:31:08

If Diane had voted against he would have to find a new shadow Home Secretary, he hasn't formed a full shadow cabinet yet . Never mind, Thornberry would be happy to be shadow home and foreign secretary , she is at his side like a Siamese twin.

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 10:31:25

ROFL Jalima!

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 10:36:07

Apparently the USA only takes the brightest and the best when looking at someone wanting to get into journalism!

Very sensible.
A points based system is what we need too!
Its bound to miss some well qualified who lack the formal qualifications, like Nigel though, whose experience and personality place him eminently among the 'brightest and best'.

Anniebach Thu 02-Feb-17 10:37:10

So the number of labour MP's who either voted against or didn't vote is seventy . Corbyn will appoint his new front bench next week !

rosesarered Thu 02-Feb-17 10:48:58

There seems to be a lot of changes, all the time, to the shadow cabinet.I used to know almost all the names, now I struggle to name more than three.

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 12:31:01

"to name more than three"

If you can do that and their jobs youre doing impressively Roses! LOL

Anniebach Thu 02-Feb-17 13:04:10

There has been three changes to the Labour shadow cabinet in less than two years .
I am curious as to will be next , so few left who are willing to work with him

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 13:11:14

What I can't understand is why, if we are leaving the EU and do not want free trade or free movement of people, it seems okay to go to the US and try for the same deal with them?

Oh dear me DJ, let me explain. Nobody doesnt want free trade with the EU. The problem is coming from the EUs insistence that they will not agree a free trade deal without free movement.
This is pure spite. They have agreed a free trade deal wth Canada that does not involve free movement. Its possible to do the same with us, but the EU mandarins do not want to.

We already trade with the US
Not on favourable terms.

gillybob Thu 02-Feb-17 13:15:15

The only favourable terms in trading with the US will be favourable terms FOR the US.

Slightly off track here, but can anyone explain to me why we trade our own home grown grain in US dollars? Weetabix are apparently putting their prices up due to the fluctuation in the price of grain (grown in the UK) but priced in dollars. Why are we allowing this to continue?

whitewave Thu 02-Feb-17 13:21:22

It's the world wide currency. Like oil and other commodities

gillybob Thu 02-Feb-17 13:23:10

Thank you WW I get that, but the grain (in particular) is grown here. Do we sell it to ourselves and then buy is back again? I am really confused.

whitewave Thu 02-Feb-17 14:19:13

So there will be a grain market in London (I assume) where everything is bought and sold. So the farmer or the middleman will sell and whoever wants it will buy. They will have a dollar account. Converted to sterling.

Same with loads of stuff.

Stuff is also forward bought on speculation. Which is why fuel suppliers should not immediately put the price up at the same time the market price goes up.

gillybob Thu 02-Feb-17 14:25:02

Thank you for taking the time to explain WW .So basically we sell our own grain at £xxx and buy it back (effectively from ourselves, but there will be someone in the city getting rich off the back of it) in $xxx ? hmm

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 14:27:47

Almost certainly. Grain gets traded on commodities and futures markets

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 14:29:22

It can be sold and resold without even being delivered. All speculation.

Yorkshiregel Thu 02-Feb-17 15:04:16

It isn't just about immigration and free trade, it is also about loss of sovereignty and not being able to make our own laws or decisions without going to the EU for approval. Loss of identity in fact. What they were after and have been from day one was to make European countries, including the UK, one big country called 'Europe'. They also tried and are still trying to form a European army, which I think sounded alarm bells. What is wrong with NATO and the United Nations? It is they that have kept the peace, not this EU Union which has changed so much Mr Heath would not recognize it these days. We were conned then, we were NOT conned a second time.

Now we and Parliament have voted to trigger Article50 can we hope that there will be no more talking this country down making the Markets wobble? Start supporting and taking pride in UK and things will get better, and that has already started to happen. We are still 'in the Market' until Mrs May triggers Article50 but that is going to happen whether people like it or not.

whitewave Thu 02-Feb-17 15:10:52

A50 only indicates an intention, we are still in the EU

Yorkshiregel Thu 02-Feb-17 15:15:03

When we come out of the EU we will be able to control our own borders, deport criminals or terrorists without the squeal of 'I am entitled to a family life', (go back to your country and take your family with you), men will not be able to bring 5 wives to this country because it is illegal (stands to reason that a man takes 5 wives there may be 5 children every year). At the moment our laws forbid this so they have got around that problem by saying that one of these women is his 'official wife' the rest are not but they can still come over.

The EU is in a fit of peak at the moment because they can see their dream of a country called 'Europe' is slipping away. They have brought this upon themselves because they slammed one too many doors in Mr Cameron's face and humiliated him over the re-negotiation.

When we come out as we surely will, we can trade with whomever we wish and EU countries will be included in that if they wish. Germany will still want to sell us their cars for example, France will still want to sell us their wine as will Italy. We can sell our things to those countries as well. If our farmers want casual labour in the summer for the fields what is to stop them advertising in European countries, which is what they do now anyway and that is why so many of them pop up here and then go home in winter. They will still be allowed to do that.

What we have to make sure of though is that when people come here to work they are not exploited by gangs of criminals and that they are paid a fair wage alongside our own people. We have seen wages across the board plummet because of these gangs bringing in cheap labour and paying them below the minimum wage.

MaizieD Thu 02-Feb-17 15:15:39

and not being able to make our own laws or decisions without going to the EU for approval.

Would you be kind enough to give us some examples of this happening?

Yorkshiregel Thu 02-Feb-17 15:18:37

Whitewave I think you will find that once triggered Article50 is irreversible. Final!

Please do not cling on to the thought that there will be a way to wreck Article50 being triggered. Many have tried to throw a spanner in the works and the MPs/Parliament still voted to trigger it.

Mair Thu 02-Feb-17 15:19:18

The EU is in a fit of peak at the moment because they can see their dream of a country called 'Europe' is slipping away. They have brought this upon themselves because they slammed one too many doors in Mr Cameron's face and humiliated him over the re-negotiation

Exactly

Yorkshiregel Thu 02-Feb-17 15:22:17

MaizeD, you as well as I know we cannot make any decisions about anything until we get EU approval. Mrs May could not deport terrorists for example nor could she stop them at the border. We cannot stop Spanish decimating our fish stock with their trawlers. When we come out of the EU we can re-instate our 12 mile limit and our fishing fleets can be built up again. There are so many examples, I am not going to give more, I will leave that up to others to do.

MaizieD Thu 02-Feb-17 15:25:16

When we come out of the EU we will be able to control our own borders, deport criminals or terrorists without the squeal of 'I am entitled to a family life',

I take it you are referring to the European Court of Human Rights here?

The ECHR is nothing to do with the EU. We are not withdrawing from the European Convention on Human Rights

The European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) (formally the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) is an international treaty to protect human rights and fundamental freedoms in Europe. Drafted in 1950 by the then newly formed Council of Europe,[1] the convention entered into force on 3 September 1953. All Council of Europe member states are party to the Convention and new members are expected to ratify the convention at the earliest opportunity.[2]

The Convention established the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR).

tinyurl.com/h9yphvj