Gransnet forums

News & politics

Should I vote Conservative

(1001 Posts)
whitewave Tue 25-Apr-17 13:07:35

Anyone got any information we can put onto this thread please?

Ana Sat 13-May-17 17:32:41

I gave two yesterday. If you didn't read them, hard luck.

durhamjen Sat 13-May-17 17:38:19

Being pleasant and helpful again, Ana.

Ana Sat 13-May-17 17:38:19

Sorry to be rude, but this thread (and the Labour one) just consists of point-scoring, nit-picking, name-calling posts by extremely partison posters.

God knows what the post-mortem will be like on June 9th...

Ana Sat 13-May-17 17:38:56

'partisan'

MaizieD Sat 13-May-17 17:41:15

On this thread, Ana? I can't find them...

Ana Sat 13-May-17 17:43:48

It must have been on another thread then. Yes, durhamjen, ever-pleasant and helpful, just like you! smile

rosesarered Sat 13-May-17 19:55:59

I have to agree Ana and full of links and reasons why Corbyn is doing so well,attracting crowds of thousands etc when it is practically certain that Labour will lose the GE.Wishful thinking I guess.
All some people can hope is that with a new Leader they may possibly win the next GE in five years time.Listening to a woman on local radio today that almost had Jezza moving in to number ten, you realise that there is a lot of 'in denial' going on.

GracesGranMK2 Sat 13-May-17 19:58:46

I want a strong say in Brexit and what it will mean.

I agree James. Why do we need to take the final decision away from the people and Parliament - are we children that we can't make it ourselves. May wants complete power to do what? We really know little about what the Conservatives intend to do when they get this landslide majority.

varian Sat 13-May-17 20:06:19

The only means we have to try to get a say in the final deal is to vote for the Liberal Democrats and hope enough are elected to put pressure on the government when the deal is known to put a meaningful choice to the people, the majority of whom may prefer to remain in the EU rather than irrevocably damage the future of our country.

GracesGranMK2 Sat 13-May-17 20:16:36

You are not wrong varian but in my constituency you may not be right, sadly. I will do my best to keep the Tory landslide to the lowest possible numbers.

whitewave Sat 13-May-17 20:35:40

I wouldn't feel quite so bad if I thought that whilst I don't agree with Tory policies (whatever they are as none of us have a clue at the moment) I thought that those in power were half competent but not a single one have come up to scratch to date.

And it's no good anyone saying that Labour would be worse - I actually doubt it very much - the fact is at the moment it looks as if the Tory millstone will be around our necks for the next 5 years, and the further damage they will cause to my beloved country is beyond bearing.

nigglynellie Sat 13-May-17 22:04:47

I shall do my very best to add to the Tory landslide as will all my family. grin

Eloethan Sat 13-May-17 22:10:21

Yes, there are partisan posters on here. There are people who quite open about being on the left of the political spectrum and broadly supportive of Labour policies and there are people who have identified themselves as Conservative supporters. They tend not to consider themselves to be "far right" in the same way that those on the left tend not to consider themselves to be "far left".

If disagreeing with something and giving reasons why you disagree is "nit picking" and "point scoring" then so be it. But it happens on all sides of the debate and is not exclusive to one group of people. As for "name calling", there is some of that but, again, it is not exclusive to one group of people.

Anniebach Sat 13-May-17 22:12:25

Whitewave, would labour be able to form a government now ? most of the shadow cabinet have only been MP's since the last election and very few are put forward for interviews, would Abbott really make a good Home Secretary ? This is not an attack on Corbyn or labour , I do doubt their ability and am concerned there is so little experience, not one has served in government

durhamjen Sun 14-May-17 00:26:35

Having served in a government is not a prerequisite for becoming a member of the government frontbench. However, I am sure none of the rebels would give up a chance to be in Corbyn's cabinet if asked.
There must be at least ten MPs who have been in government.
Nick Brown has, and Chris Leslie. Ann Clwyd, too, and Rosie Winterton, among others.

Anniebach Sun 14-May-17 08:16:45

Chris Leslie is on his hit list and be sacked Rosie Winterton

GracesGranMK2 Sun 14-May-17 09:08:25

I don't think lazy journalists help anyone with the idea that the LP could not form a government and be successful. I wonder where you have read that "LP's costings are not good - in fact way off", Ana. It is interesting that you have as we haven't had them all yet.

I was just watching a pro-tory journalist doing the paper review on Sky who thinks she knows it all too. She was talking about dividing up sausages. Not only that but her answer to people not have the problem with odd sausages was to go out an earn enough to buy more sausages! Now where have we heard that before - Oh yes Ma Thatcher's trickle-down. And could they make that happen. NO THE CONSERVATIVE GOVERNMENTS COULDN'T and there is no more reason to think it would be fairer under a May government that doesn't know ANYTHING about peoples lives outside the leafy avenues.

GracesGranMK2 Sun 14-May-17 09:11:45

More lazy comment Ana. Why is the government in the Cons hands "Safer than it would be in Jezza and McDonnells' hands, that's for sure!" How can you turn your prejudice for the Cons into real fact. Otherwise it is just hot air on your part.

GracesGranMK2 Sun 14-May-17 09:31:19

Here we go again with the 'extreme right wing' rubbish.
Ana here is a simple explaination of right wing politics. Do you really believe that the Conservatives are not right wing and that there are not a proportion of them who are extremely in favour of the description below?

People who are right wing are in favour of ‘free market economics’. This is where private companies are unregulated so they are free to go about their business without any interference from the government, which is sometimes referred to as ‘the state’.

Right wing societies are based on a ‘survival of the fittest’ model where it is believed that the most talented and hard-working individuals will eventually become successful.

Right wing people believe that those who have earned lots of money should not be taxed disproportionately and deserve to enjoy the benefits that their wealth can bring such as being able to pay for a higher quality of education or healthcare.

durhamjen Sun 14-May-17 09:37:26

Not only that, but they are desperate for votes and funds.

skwawkbox.org/2017/05/14/may-sends-letter-begging-for-support-to-welsh-labour-leader-ge17/

Letter sent to Carwyn Jones!

Anniebach Sun 14-May-17 09:46:36

Welsh Labour Leader? But you said Welsh Labour doesn't exist dj

GracesGranMK2 Sun 14-May-17 09:51:50

Ana, I think I was a little harsh about the 'hot air'. Could you just explain what the Conservative government has done that is no other government could do that is a good thing and also why they have done so many bad things such as trying to heal the issues of an international banking crisis on the backs of the poor and less able while cutting taxes that the rich benefit from but is still lauded by the right-wing press?

Otherwise, really any government would be better than the one we have it is just the right wing press who keep telling us they are wonderful and no one else has any ability at all.

durhamjen Sun 14-May-17 10:01:34

No I didn't, Annie. You are being really ridiculous now, as ridiculous as May sending a letter to Carwyn Jones.

Why, in your determination to attack everything I write, have you managed to not notice that?

I have said that this general election is not about Welsh Labour.
Carwyn Jones is the leader of the Welsh Assembly, nothing to do with Westminster. THAT IS WHAT I HAVE SAID.
You insist you are supporting Welsh Labour and Carwyn Jones in this election. If that is the case, you are doing nothing for the Labour Party, however much you profess to be a member of the Labour Party.

You will not find Welsh Labour on the voting papers.
Which constituency is Carwyn Jones standing for on June 8th?

durhamjen Sun 14-May-17 10:05:01

Carwyn Jones saw the funny side of it.

"Not sure the Tories' voter ID is that efficient!"

A shame in your zeal to attack me you appear to have lost your sense of humour, Annie.

durhamjen Sun 14-May-17 10:14:25

Another reason not to vote Tory.

"The SKWAWKBOX has learned that Calderstones – the second-biggest school in Liverpool – is facing cuts of such scale that it told its maths department on Friday that it will be facing cuts to its budget of twenty percent for the 2017/18 school year.

In maths.

One of the most core of core subjects.

Theresa May told her small audience last week that education is not just about funding, it’s about results. Well, imagine the results to your child’s education and life prospects of a 20% cut to his/her school’s maths budget.

Then think: if maths is that badly affected, at least the same is happening in English, science, computing and other vital subjects – and far more in supposedly ‘non-core’ areas. Going to university under this government, unless you’re rich, is to burden yourself with huge debts – but even that might become an impossible dream for children learning in a school with such huge cuts to core-subject budgets.

If you care about the education and life chances of your children, grandchildren, nieces or nephews you simply cannot afford to even think for a second of voting Tory."

Tories are not concerned about education for the many, if there are schools which are having to cut their maths budget by 20%

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion