Gransnet forums

News & politics

Aimed at the Wrong People?

(365 Posts)
Jalima1108 Mon 26-Jun-17 16:27:31

Was Jeremy Corbyn's speech at Glastonbury aimed at the wrong people?

The well-heeled and privileged people who paid £238 each for their tickets, teepees or glamping extra, running into the thousands of £, cheering him on and lauding him are not the disaffected living in poverty whom he champions. Do they not see the irony in this as they go back to their middle-class comfortable lives, recycling their rubbish and urging us to 'look after the planet'.

This is from last year but I am sure it is just the same this year. Brand-new tents left behind, mounds of rubbish to be cleared up by others - who cares who clears it as long as they don't have to soil their own hands. Someone will do it - probably on a wage less than a quarter of what most of them will earn.

'Takers of the system' as the commentary says:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=y70LCoK-XMA

And the fence - the fence!! Perhaps Donald Trump could take a lesson on how to build a huge fence to keep out the hoi-polloi, the less than desirable who cannot afford a ticket.

Who said that Glastonbury is 'The Most Bourgeois Festival on the Planet'? Was it someone from Iron Maiden? Can't remember now but I do remember someone mentioning it.

Oh, the irony.
Obviously Jeremy Corbyn didn't understand that, nor did the crowds he was addressing.

suzied Thu 29-Jun-17 18:13:07

Seems like this has declined into a slanging match- May did/ didn't do X / Corbyn did / didn't do Y. We don't really know what people do/ don't do when not reported unless we were there so don't pretend to.

Iam64 Thu 29-Jun-17 19:00:13

This is another very unpleasant thread now.
I have a faith, it's not something I talk about much. I find so many people feel they have the right to dismiss anyone with faith as daft, or prepared to believe in magic. I wouldn't dream f being so offensive to those with no, or different faiths.
Praying for the dead isn't about 'phopbf they 'get a better seat in heaven'. Dismissive, is unnecessary and negative,
What about a more gentle style of posting, to go along with the more gentle style of politics many of us would like to see.
What kind of example do our generation want to set for the younger people? I live in a town where we have a large Muslim population. We are an umbrella town for asylum seekers, as are many other former mill towns in the north west. We have a growing pipulation of African Muslims who I hope will find common ground with their Pakistan Muslim neighbours,
The evangelical Church is full to bursting. The congregation includes White a British and many fairly newly arrived Africans. Are they to be dismissed by posters here, with The ease found possible for Theresa May's faith
.

Ana Thu 29-Jun-17 19:07:01

Hear, hear Iam64. People who believe pray for the souls of the dead. Let's give reigion a break on here, please.

durhamjen Thu 29-Jun-17 19:08:49

It started as being very unpleasant, though, Iam.

whitewave Thu 29-Jun-17 19:09:54

I am an atheist and a lapsed confirmed Christian, with a strong Christian upbringing.

What I find so very difficult to come to terms with, and why I can no longer believe in a higher being, is the extraordinary hypocracy I see emanating from all religions.

Wars are carried out in religious faiths, people are slaughtered in religious faith, people are left to starve when a professed religious vastly wealthy country does absolutely nothing to save those dear children. People are drowning as I write this who are surrounded by countries of faith.

Excuse my cynicism, but that is why I agreed with nanny

GracesGranMK2 Thu 29-Jun-17 19:15:38

Iam, I'm afraid it is not only those who do not believe who could be seen as making remarks others may not like. We also had good Christians telling us that someone is better because they prayed with the Archbishop of Canterbury.

Jen is right; this started out as an unpleasant thread, designed to cause trouble rather than clarity - sadly it appears to be succeeding.

Iam64 Thu 29-Jun-17 19:18:08

I do t dispute any of that ww.
Which organisations were at he front of offering practical and emotional support at Grenfell, the Churches,
My charity of choice when recycling clothes and household items, is the Salvation Army. They work with people on the very edges of our society,
No one could claim religion hasn't been involved in wars or terrorism. That isn't a reason to dismiss any faith as nonsense.
I'm watching Broken, written by the wonderful Jimmy McGovern. It portrays the Catholic Church in all its complexity. I feel our society will lose a lit if we simply dismiss all faiths and believers as hypocritical losers .

whitewave Thu 29-Jun-17 19:21:08

Of course they were iam !!! They would be utterly immaterial if they didn't. But I stick by my point. I will not continue with this conversation as it may upset too many people and I don't want to question their beliefs. Windows and souls etc.

NannyMcPhU Thu 29-Jun-17 19:28:18

I know some of you will not understand my point of view but I genuinely cannot understand the concept of praying for the dead. I did ask someone to explain, and I apologise if my second post offended. I was probably trying to elicit a response to my first question.

But I'm still in the dark.

And yes, people are entitled to their faith or to their atheism.

Eloethan Thu 29-Jun-17 19:35:58

I'm afraid I have little time for any organised religions and ostentatious displays of piety.

I very much respect people of faith who accept that others have different beliefs from their own, and who put their faith to good use by helping others, especially when it is inconvenient or unpopular to do so.

NannyMcPhU Thu 29-Jun-17 19:39:10

I'll go along with that too Eloethan

Ana Thu 29-Jun-17 19:41:56

What do you mean by them being 'utterly immaterial' whitewave?

whitewave Thu 29-Jun-17 19:44:32

ana if you had read the whole of my post you would realise that as far as I am concerned for the reason I have given have closed the subject.

rosesarered Thu 29-Jun-17 22:06:59

Good posts Iam64 ....it is the height of crassness to talk about religion in that way.

rosesarered Thu 29-Jun-17 22:08:52

....and the Salvation Army is wonderful.

durhamjen Thu 29-Jun-17 22:09:28

We can talk about religion any way we want, same as any other subject.

rosesarered Thu 29-Jun-17 22:14:31

Yes, you can, if you wish to upset or offend durham but few posters really want that.

GracesGranMK2 Thu 29-Jun-17 22:40:05

I am upset and offended by the position some on here are trying to give their religion. Apparently if they mention their belief free speech has to stop! If you are going to be offended don't bring the subject up. Keep it in your head - along with the opinions you don't like being challenged either.

durhamjen Thu 29-Jun-17 22:45:02

So you are allowed to say the Salvation Army is wonderful?

My religion is veganism, and I think that's wonderful, as well as CND.

whitewave Fri 30-Jun-17 06:52:38

My religion is humanism, but they are often far from wonderfulsadangryblushconfusedgrinshocksmile

That is some of the reasons i find humanism so fascinating

sunseeker Fri 30-Jun-17 09:49:58

I am a believer and yes I do pray for the dead because I believe we all have a soul and I pray that their souls can rest in peace.

There are those of a different faith or no faith at all and, of course, I accept and respect that.

I remember a priest once said to me that any religion which cannot take criticism or even ridicule will not last long - and Christianity as been around for 2,000 years!

rosesarered Fri 30-Jun-17 09:55:15

Veganism is not a religion durham ( though I realise that to some people it almost is)
The Salvation Army does wonderful work....where there is a human need, they are there!

varian Fri 30-Jun-17 09:59:04

Judging by the blind faith of the angry brexiters, brexit seems to be a new religion, and no you must not criticise it as they find it offensive and get even angrier

Anniebach Fri 30-Jun-17 10:05:27

Those who show the most ostentatious display of piety have always been atheists

rosesarered Fri 30-Jun-17 10:11:09

varian ..... who on here is talking about Brexit ( except you) must it be brought into every topic?