Gransnet forums

News & politics

Why are we leaving?

(390 Posts)
yggdrasil Thu 05-Oct-17 08:49:38

This vid says a lot. Especially why the EU finds our government's attitude so incomprehensible

www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgu6pFz5oxA

(it is about 8 mins long)

GracesGranMK2 Sun 08-Oct-17 12:34:04

In this government Jen?

durhamjen Sun 08-Oct-17 12:38:01

Yes, because it gave her the position she had.
She was also chosen by Cameron because they needed an expendable woman.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/oct/07/outrageous-good-fortune-smiles-once-again-on-theresa-may

Ilovecheese Sun 08-Oct-17 13:39:52

I bet he regrets a lot of things now.

GracesGranMK2 Sun 08-Oct-17 13:54:14

I must admit that I agree about her 'luck' with the cough, etc. If these things had not happened we would have had all the pundits reporting on the thinness of ideas in the speech and the fact they seemed to be offering Labour light.

durhamjen Sun 08-Oct-17 14:26:29

I wonder how many other MPs have gone straight from backbencher to Home Secretary?

JessM Sun 08-Oct-17 17:18:02

My late mother observed that when a female politician was having a rocky patch the knives would be drawn far faster than if the politician was a male. She was right about Edwina Curry and Thatcher. All Curry did was tell the truth. Imagine that! I think the only things delaying those Tory knives now are 1/ she could take the blame for the brexit disaster 2/ there are no strong candidates for a replacement 3/ they are terrified of an election. Not inconsiderable, so she might hang on in there despite the awful election and her weak and wobbly leadership.

durhamjen Sun 08-Oct-17 20:57:51

Curry didn't tell the whole truth, though, did she?
If she had, John Major would have been knifed as well.

lemongrove Sun 08-Oct-17 21:23:03

How many MP’s have gone straight from backbencher to Leader Of The Opposition, come to that.

lemongrove Sun 08-Oct-17 21:24:51

I think that your Mother was right about that JessM and further to that applies to any position in life, as well as politics.

paddyann Sun 08-Oct-17 22:46:36

DJ ENGLAND doesn't NEED its own parliament.Westminster is more than 80% English Mp's ,it makes it almost impossible for the other nations to get anything THEY want through parliament....and thats how WM likes it.Just watch them try to claw back the powers already devolved once Brexit happens.They dont like anyone having a say but them .62% of the Scottish vote was REMAIN yet we cant even have a voice in the discussions....thats Westminster saying we're second class citizens with no voice and it makes my and millions of others blood boil !

durhamjen Sun 08-Oct-17 22:52:56

Yes, paddyann, but if England had a separate parliament where only English things were discussed, and Westminster could only discuss things that related to all four countries, wouldn't it make things more even and get rid of some of the anomalies and animosity?
We would then HAVE to separate out those things that were parochial from those that were truly uniting us.

durhamjen Sun 08-Oct-17 22:55:28

Oh, and there should be proper devolution of powers. We would have to decide about transport, roads, education, the health and care service, etc., in all four separate countries, or decide that they should be truly federal.

GrandmaMoira Mon 09-Oct-17 10:17:09

When talking about devolution and the separate countries, as someone living in London, which is a global city, with a much larger population than Scotland, Wales or N Ireland, I feel London should have a lot more independence.
London also voted strongly Remain.

durhamjen Mon 09-Oct-17 10:29:42

I think there is a forum asking for devolution for London.
There might even be a petition.

If London had devolution, that might be a good idea, because the rest of us could have our money back and not support the south so much.

durhamjen Mon 09-Oct-17 10:32:17

www.change.org/p/sadiq-khan-declare-london-independent-from-the-uk-and-apply-to-join-the-eu

grannygranby Mon 09-Oct-17 11:40:17

facts o people. England makes up 85% of UK and already has the lions share of everything. London dominates England - even the UK. It is also the richest because all the money is there. Of course you shouldn't let it be independent, it has responsibilities along with all its rights. It's just a waste of space and energy to get involved with such silliness. EXIT BREXIT is not at all silly and it is worth the fight in buckets.

varian Mon 09-Oct-17 12:22:00

So many people all over the world agree with you, grannygranby. Here's just one:-

www.huffingtonpost.com/norman-macafee/exit-brexit-fixit-how-did_b_11993154.html

whitewave Mon 09-Oct-17 12:33:05

That was a good article dj

What I find really bizarre is that so much is being published about the argument for reasons for staying in EU, with very, very little being published about the reasons for withdrawing. None of it makes sense and leaves me utterly bewildered as to the mindset of Brexiters.

I can’t believe that they are all being fooled by the lies, that they are willing to believe all the propaganda given out by the wealthy hedge fund managers and tax avoiders -for they are the only ones who stand to benefit.

whitewave Mon 09-Oct-17 12:50:16

Apparently the Treasury have found billions to be used in case of a bad Brexit - blimey and they were worried about what is paid to the EU.

gillybob Mon 09-Oct-17 13:03:19

London is not England though grannygranby . Yes I agree all of the money is there, but what about the rest of us?
Those of us who don't benefit from the wealth of London or the free prescriptions, tuition fees etc. enjoyed by Scotland etc.

It seems we are completely forgotten.

whitewave Mon 09-Oct-17 14:28:24

The most important talks ever, -talks that are stalling and Davis can’t be bothered to turn up. What are we paying him for?

paddyann Mon 09-Oct-17 14:34:24

gillybob haven't you yourselves to blame for the situation re tuition fees etc ? You voted for a government that opposes these things..we in Scotland voted for a government thats left of centre ..thats interested in the people who put them in power.They work FOR us not against us as the tories are doing .This is SUPPOSED to be a union ...although it wasn't ever what the people of Scotland wanted we were signed up to a UNION ...equal apparently ...though thats not what it turned out to be .Please fight for ENGLISH independence and let us get n with running our country OUR way...which has never been the tory way

durhamjen Mon 09-Oct-17 15:00:55

Paddyann, I was reading today that tuition fees cost the government more now that they have increased them to £9000 than they did when they were just £3000 a year.
IFS research says that the system is "more expensive to the taxpayer than it would have been if there had been no changes in 2011".
They can't blame Labour for that.

durhamjen Mon 09-Oct-17 15:49:05

www.theneweuropean.co.uk/top-stories/i-accuse-ac-grayling-s-denunciation-of-britain-s-craven-politicians-1-5218037

I don't normally agree with Grayling, but I do here.

durhamjen Mon 09-Oct-17 15:58:47

"The government claimed last week to have made one of the first big breakthroughs in Brexit-related talks, in the form of a preliminary agreement between the UK and EU on World Trade Organisation quotas. However, this was quickly undermined when the Trump administration joined a group of countries objecting to the deal as far as it related to agricultural quotas. This Financial Times article suggests that this is a sign of how the US and others plan to use Brexit to force the UK to open up access to its markets to agricultural goods from third countries far more than it wants - even before it agrees any new trade deals with such countries."
Can't link to the FT article, but this looks very worrying.