Gransnet forums

News & politics

I do wonder- is this what the Brexiters wanted?

(571 Posts)
Kali2 Tue 11-May-21 13:24:02

Free Movement of people agreed with India in exchange for Deal?

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 12:39:10

Kali2 et al - I thought you would have known that faux outrage is the worst crime anyone on GN could be accused of.

Concern for other people? Pah! And we're the ones who are accused of saying "I'm alright Jack"

You couldn't make it up.

Urmstongran Tue 18-May-21 12:50:30

Concern for others is an admirable trait.
Using it just as a wind up merchant ... not so much.

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 12:52:45

Peasblossom I do appreciate you taking the time to post at 11:46, really. But I remain unconvinced. The local farming conglomerates are changing their business models because their former workforces are no longer available to them, understood.

But the whole section about people accepting lower wages and preventing "locals" from getting a fair wage do not convince. That's what they used to say about working women; all those men with families to support. Remember?

And even if all you say was true; is it worth throwing the entire country into economic and societal disarray? If the Government had made it impossible for the conglomerates to exploit the workers in agriculture then the EU wouldn't have come into it.

BTW, where I live strawberries are rotting where they grow because there is no-one to pick them. Farmers facing financial ruin. But maybe that's just a first world problem. Let them eat apples. (Oh wait - who will pick them.....?)

Welshwife Tue 18-May-21 12:57:52

It is not just the Hall Marks no longer being recognised I read an article last week that many U.K. qualifications are no longer being recognised in the EU - this presumably will put U.K. qualified engineers etc at a disadvantage obtaining jobs in EU companies. I have no idea how that might affect people already working in the EU.
It is having an impact on young British people who have lived in and been educated in the EU now requiring permits to continue their lives - some finding themselves in a Catch 22 situation with needing residency rights to work and needing a job to obtain residency rights. There are also various problems with youngsters going to University and fees to be paid etc. This appears to be problematic for some - which fees are applicable and grants/loans available.

Interesting what Peasblossom has been saying about the agricultural workers. Did they stop giving agricultural workers tied cottages etc for their families? In the 60s I had relatives who lived in a tied cottage in Lancashire on a mixed farm. Farming methods have changed so much over the last half century I wonder how much it would still have altered for these workers even without going into the EU.

growstuff Tue 18-May-21 12:59:49

Alegrias1

Kali2 et al - I thought you would have known that faux outrage is the worst crime anyone on GN could be accused of.

Concern for other people? Pah! And we're the ones who are accused of saying "I'm alright Jack"

You couldn't make it up.

Nah! It's the Union Jacks who think they're alright and have stuck two fingers up at those posh southerners.

MayBee70 Tue 18-May-21 13:02:11

Peasblossom

It’ll be a bit difficult to tell for a few years won’t it, whether people in these regions feel their lives have improved.

And untangling from the effects of Covid isn’t easy but in the immediate term.

The unavailability of cheap itinerant work gangs means that farmers (especially conglomerates for whom shareholder profit is the driving force) are moving from one of crops to all year round farming, meaning that more permanent agricultural jobs are beginning to become available.

Pressure on housing, medical services and social services has eased somewhat as families have moved back into Europe. There was a disproportionate influx that Councils found difficult because the East has always been a low income/high unemployment area with lower central support.

More holiday trade jobs are available to local people, which traditionally removed people from unemployment temporarily. As in agricultural work, cheap intinerant kabour was employed in these as they would accept low wages with board and lodging as a component. They were employed in preference to local Labour that needed a wage that would enable them to pay rent and feed a family.

I don’t know how to explain this to make you understand how desperate and despairing many, many people had become.

The taunt of ‘are they queuing up for the agricultural jobs” shows a lack of understanding of how the system worked. A job for ten or twelve weeks, that includes a bunk in a caravan and food is no good to someone who pays rent on a house throughout the year and needs to feed children as well as themselves.

But surely seasonal crops are just that. Seasonal. Hasn’t it always been the same. A local veggie shop to us always sold Spalding produce and it was seasonal. That’s the nature of farming isn’t it? And I can’t see people going to Spalding for a holiday. And that’s seasonal too. I do agree that the rural poor have always been ignored and emphasis is always in the urban poor but that’s the responsibility of the government. And from what I’ve seen of poorer areas, both rural and urban, most initiatives to improve the lot of the people there seem to have had EU funding.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 18-May-21 13:20:44

Well sorry to point out the obvious but there is an abundance of U.K. fruit and vegetables on the shelves so someone/something is picking and packing them.

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 13:24:25

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/supermarkets-face-post-brexit-fruit-24118354

The obvious.

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 13:28:16

Here's some more:

www.fruitnet.com/fpj/article/185221/scottish-berry-growers-fear-picker-shortage

www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/business/farming/farming-news/2224051/mps-say-british-producers-at-bottom-of-governments-priorities-list-as-fruit-farms-warn-crops-could-be-left-unpicked/

Peasblossom Tue 18-May-21 13:28:19

I feel like I’m giving an agricultural lecture ? but it is interesting how much understanding I take for understood.

Of course crops are seasonal and specific to our climate unless you provide artificial means. But a variety of crops would be grown that provided a job year round. But that meant paying a wage year round. It’s much more profitable to grow one or two specialised crops that only require labour for a few weeks and some that you can hire a machine for for a few days. No employment obligations either.

This method of farming became widely possible with the availability of itinerant workers. If they’re not available the farming method will have to change to be economically viable.

I could develop on here about the alternatives but I’m sure I’m drifting towards my thread about being boring?

Rented farm cottages have been sold off, mostly to weekenders, as they were no longer needed for a permanent workforce. I guess there’ll be a raft of planning applications on farms now. You need your stockman on site!

Peasblossom Tue 18-May-21 13:28:47

drivel not develop. ?

GrannyGravy13 Tue 18-May-21 13:32:13

Alegrias1

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/supermarkets-face-post-brexit-fruit-24118354

The obvious.

If I wasn’t on Granny duty I would pop out and photograph one of our many farm shops or supermarkets, no empty shelves, could be a region problem?

Have just had a quick browse in my fridge, Asparagus, potatoes, cauliflower, cabbages, brussel sprouts, strawberries, raspberries, tomatoes, onions, just a few U.K. grown products.

There is a Scottish Fish site saying that they have exported my salmon in the last three months than a long time.

One minute the media is accused of being sensationalist, next totally believable?

GrannyGravy13 Tue 18-May-21 13:32:50

*my - *more

Callistemon Tue 18-May-21 13:33:52

I feel like I’m giving an agricultural lecture

You can say whatever you like Peasblossom but others will always know far more than you about it even if never having owned or worked on a farm.

Urmstongran Tue 18-May-21 13:34:01

Ah the poor EU really isn’t having a good decade and we’re not even 18 months in.

At least they didn’t lose their second biggest economy or anything.

Callistemon Tue 18-May-21 13:35:24

I can recommend the Herefordshire asparagus!

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 13:36:56

GrannyGravy13

Alegrias1

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/supermarkets-face-post-brexit-fruit-24118354

The obvious.

If I wasn’t on Granny duty I would pop out and photograph one of our many farm shops or supermarkets, no empty shelves, could be a region problem?

Have just had a quick browse in my fridge, Asparagus, potatoes, cauliflower, cabbages, brussel sprouts, strawberries, raspberries, tomatoes, onions, just a few U.K. grown products.

There is a Scottish Fish site saying that they have exported my salmon in the last three months than a long time.

One minute the media is accused of being sensationalist, next totally believable?

I'm alright Jack.

Is it this one?

thefishsite.com/articles/scots-salmon-producers-report-record-exports-to-europe-despite-brexit

The one that says volumes are u but value is down?

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 13:37:54

up, not u

This isn't the Pursuit of Love thread smile

Peasblossom Tue 18-May-21 13:42:52

Alegrias I don’t think it’s really the same thing as the women’s wages argument. It’s not that itinerants took locals jobs at lower wages. They wouldn’t have wanted them anyway. The whole essence is that you work away and return home.

It was the availability of cheap itinerant workers and its economic benefit to shareholders that caused the face of farming to change and the work not to be viable as a means of permanent employment.

No I didn’t think it was worth throwing the whole country into disarray. I voted remain. But then I wasn’t unemployed and homeless. I was doing ok with the status quo. I wanted support for those who were having to deal with massive life changes. But it wasn’t forthcoming -from anywhere..

Was it worth making people unemployed and homeless so that other people could have easy access to holiday homes and visiting relatives abroad? Honestly that’s pretty much what the moans and cries of anger sounded like on here.

Two nations? Or maybe a continent divided

Ellianne Tue 18-May-21 13:44:47

Callistemon

I can recommend the Herefordshire asparagus!

I'm good for tonight with Cornish thanks.

Ellianne Tue 18-May-21 13:46:10

But I can't do without my French wine for lunch!

Kamiso Tue 18-May-21 13:47:34

Callistemon

I can recommend the Herefordshire asparagus!

We’ve driven there quite often. Delicious (OH not keen so all the more for me!)

Urmstongran Tue 18-May-21 13:47:51

Northern Ireland Protocol 'dead in the water', senior ally of Boris Johnson says.

Lord Frost, the Prime Minister’s Brexit negotiator, has privately set a July 12 target date to end the chaos of cross-border checks.
?

Go ‘Frostie’!

Kali2 Tue 18-May-21 13:49:31

Urmstongran

Oh Kali2 change the record please. You’ve been tub thumping for years! Usually on behalf of others just ‘showing empathy’. Hmm. Stirring things up more like that don’t even affect you!

What are you on about. Feeling unwell?

As for avoiding France due to new regs, to go to Spain, well not sure.

????? ?? ????????Ó? – ????? ??? ?? ?????????
Confirmed by the ??????? ?? ?????????í? ? ????????? in Granada this morning, and by Antequera National Police as well, with thanks to the helpful lady there.
Like for all other nonEU nationals wishing to visit Spain and NOT lodging in paid holiday accommodation, but with friends or family instead, the host in Spain must apply for a ????? ?? ????????ó? for each person involved. ???: ???? ????? ????????? in Spain can apply for this Carta for the family or friends they wish to receive in their own (or rented) home or a second home they own here, ???-???????? ???? ?????? ??? ???. The latter can only receive nonEU guests in their holiday home if the property is listed as a holiday rental with the Registro de Turismo and they charge for their stay and provide the guests with a tourist rental contract and confirmation of booking. For those who rent their home, please check that the rental contract doesn’t contain a clause that prohibits guests from lodging with you, or only allows so for very limited time in case they intend to stay for several weeks e.g.
The procedure is a ???-???? one. You need to apply for the Carta de Invitación with the National Police in your area, with a cita previa sede.administracionespublicas.gob.es/icpco/index
fill out this form for each guest www.interior.gob.es/.../Solicitud+de+Carta.../
And Modelo 790-12 to pay the administrative fee. Tick ‘solicitud carta de invitación’. The amount of 74,31 euros will appear. sede.policia.gob.es/Tasa790_012/ImpresoRellenar
?????????? ????????? ?? ?????:
✼ Title deeds or rental contract for the property where the guests will be lodging
✻ Padrón certificate not older than 3 months
✼ TIE or green EU residency certificate and passport plus copies
✼ Copies of the passports of the guests that will travel from the UK to Spain to stay with you
There is no fixed window to process your application, it depends on how busy they are, but generally no more than 20 days. Once you have been notified that your application has been resolved favourably, you can pick up the the Carta(s) de Invitación. You’ll need a ?????? ???? ???-??, tick ‘Expedición de Carta de Invitación’. No amount will appear, you need to print the form and put in the amount of 6,43 euros times number of guests. So for a family of five, 5 x 6,43 = 32,15. Note that these amounts vary each time the State General Budget for the following year is approved and published.
Once you have the Carta(s), you need to send them to the UK so that the guest can bring the originals with them when they travel to Spain.
It will no doubt take a bit of getting used to, but this has been in place for all nonEU nationals for many years. Although the GOV UK website doesn’t mention anything in their ‘travel to Spain’ section, the Carta de Invitación is in fact in place for UK Nationals when travelling to the EU for tourist purposes, when not staying in paid holiday accommodation. As said at the beginning of this article, confirmed by official sources.

Kali2 Tue 18-May-21 13:51:32

Urmstongran

Northern Ireland Protocol 'dead in the water', senior ally of Boris Johnson says.

Lord Frost, the Prime Minister’s Brexit negotiator, has privately set a July 12 target date to end the chaos of cross-border checks.
?

Go ‘Frostie’!

You are aware that it was Johnson and Frost that negotiated the Deal and agreed to the conditions required by the NI protocol.

So they were either totally unprepared and didn't understand the implications- or totally dishonest and plain liars. Which is it?