Gransnet forums

News & politics

So many dreams for our youngsters dashed.

(407 Posts)
Kali2 Thu 05-Aug-21 08:45:49

Already a huge problem for all those wanting to work in European resorts, be it in the leisure, sport or tourism of any form - and ski/snowboard instructors, sailing, surfing, etc. as 'equivalence' only applies to EU and Switzerland. Now those who aspire to be pilots, face the same problem as post-Brexit exclusion frustrates UK pilots as carriers seek EASA-licensed crews.

The Ski Operators are now advertising for staff in all their resorts, requiring an EU passport for all staff, from cleaners, to reps and instructors.

How sad that opportunities for our grand-children are being dashed like this - at the time where they lives are being so restricted in other ways due to Covid, and they also face the worries of climate change.

Katie59 Sun 08-Aug-21 10:58:49

Alegrias1

^People don't have to go abroad to find work.^

They do though.

^There are more things in heaven and earth, than are dreamt of in your philosophy, Theoddbiord^

Indeed they do, now it’s the country they are travelling to that decides if they are wanted, some are very difficult, some less so. You certainly need a skill, building trades, motor technician, hairdresser, nurse, but you need a recognized qualification.
Getting a working visa has never been harder.

KateF Sun 08-Aug-21 11:01:56

Kali2

Already a huge problem for all those wanting to work in European resorts, be it in the leisure, sport or tourism of any form - and ski/snowboard instructors, sailing, surfing, etc. as 'equivalence' only applies to EU and Switzerland. Now those who aspire to be pilots, face the same problem as post-Brexit exclusion frustrates UK pilots as carriers seek EASA-licensed crews.

The Ski Operators are now advertising for staff in all their resorts, requiring an EU passport for all staff, from cleaners, to reps and instructors.

How sad that opportunities for our grand-children are being dashed like this - at the time where they lives are being so restricted in other ways due to Covid, and they also face the worries of climate change.

When I did my stints at Ski resorts and Campsites, we all were required to have visas, no different to today on a Brit Passport, they are also required to have a Covid Vaccination certificate.

Who has led Europe in Covid Vaccinations, Ummmmm Ummmmm of course the UK, silly me I forgot!!.

sylla12 Sun 08-Aug-21 11:09:26

Brexit is a monumental shame ! and to think it came about based on lies ! I makes me so sad and angry !

Katie59 Sun 08-Aug-21 11:11:49

coastalgran

It is not just young people suffering from the fall out of leaving the EU. Farmers can't get EU seasonal staff because of Covid restrictions and other red tape, our youngsters don't want to pick fruit, veg or harvest grain. Hospitality is another area suffering in Europe being in that industry is not seen as a lesser profession whereas here young people only see working in a bar or hotel as a stop gap or holiday job while a student. So maybe it all needs a rethink by our young people.

Vegetable and fruit crops are being left unpicked because workers cannot be found, replaced by imported produce. Chefs in particular are very short and restaurants are reducing menus so that less skills are needed, we stayed in a hotel recently and it was chips with everything - nobody to prepare potatoes.

JaneJudge Sun 08-Aug-21 11:12:58

It sounds like young people are being blamed for the decisions made by others

M0nica Sun 08-Aug-21 11:19:05

One of the main aims of Brexit was to reduce the number of migrant workers and to reduce the flow of manufacturing outside the UK to lower labour cost countries, thereby keeping more jobs at home.

Was it, that really is news to me. If true it shows just how poor the understanding of how the economy works was in the Brexit community.

Lesson 1: If we do not have enough workers in this country to meet our requirements, it drives the price of labour up. Lorry drivers at the moment can currently almost dictate their wages. Employers are hiking their pay rates up, offering bonuses when they join a company and so on, employers then have to recoup their extra costs by passing them on to the consumer in higher prices, which contributes to inflation. The alternative is we let migrant workers in to fill all these vacant posts, costs of employment stay roughly where they are and transport costs do not contribute to inflation.

Lesson 2: Nothing can stop us buying goods from abroad if they are cheaper than those manufactured at home, whether we are in Europe or not. Do you really believe that the home consumer will buy expensive UK manufactured baby wipes, when they can buy Indian manufactured ones for less than half the price, for example?

Remember the 'Ever Given'? The huge container ship that got stuck across the Suez Canal and cause such disruption to freight traffic. She docked in Felixstowe this week. On her were 18,000 containers and every single one was filled with goods made in China. Not one single container had anything in it that was made in the EU. if it becomes difficult to import something from the EU, we will not make it in the UK, we will import from elsewhere, probably China.

However, nearly half our exports go to the EU. Brexit will only make exporting more difficult for things we do still make in the UK.

Alegrias1 Sun 08-Aug-21 11:22:13

Who has led Europe in Covid Vaccinations, Ummmmm Ummmmm of course the UK, silly me I forgot!!.

Who has the biggest share of their country fully vaccinated? Malta, Belgium, Spain, Portugal, Denmark. Triumphalism isn't nice, especially when its misplaced.

GoldenAge Sun 08-Aug-21 11:24:26

I'm with Kali2 all the way - the issue is not about language, but about learning about different cultures and that's what young people who choose to go abroad for temporary work or travelling gain - knowledge of other ways of living, and the very important lesson that what they've been brought up with is the only/right way of being. To bring in the argument that English is spoken around the world is a red herring, and serves to confuse the issue. Brexit has not made everything OK, and will not - it's completely ruined our fishing industry and heaven knows how the poor people of Northern Ireland feel - still feeling very, very frustrated by the complete impingements to our lives by Brexit and I do despair of the view that we, on this little island, with so much xenophobia are providing the right future for our younger generation - we're not - in a previous existence as an academic I sent around 60 third year undergraduate students abroad each year to work in different situations as part of their degree programme and I can say I have the evidence that every one of them, around 800 in total came back with different and better perspectives on life.

Camellia20 Sun 08-Aug-21 11:28:39

Young people coming into the workforce now did not get to vote. I am with you Kali and sylla. I know several young people who are in the science and research communities - all concerned about funding and opportunities. Another young man I know built up his own high tech electronics business employing 12 people. He is now looking for premises in an EU country. Nothing whatsoever to do with COVID. The reality of Brexit is here now.

sundowngirl Sun 08-Aug-21 11:29:39

I worked in France,Germany and Switzerland in the late 60s before we even joined the EU or the common market as it was then, without a problem. If our youngsters want to work abroad they will, I wouldn’t call it that their dreams are being dashed!

Notright Sun 08-Aug-21 11:32:45

While it's disappointing for the youngsters, Life is tough and they're having their first experience before they've even done anything. The want it right now is in the past, we 're all going to have to fight hard to get where we want. It's a whole new world and they must not give up at the first fence. I wish all the youngsters good luck, persevere and it can still happen. ~Don't put all the plans in one basket.

Sheilasue Sun 08-Aug-21 11:37:07

I have always said right from the beginning when they started to talk about leaving the EU makes me sad for our young ones I only have one grandchild a grandaughter and would have loved to see her travel and perhaps get work. But it’s not to be .?

Alegrias1 Sun 08-Aug-21 11:38:29

All these comments along the lines of "I did it in the Sixties, I don't see the problem...."

Of course its still possible to go and work in the EU, if you really want to do it. But when I did it, in the nineties, I hopped on a cross channel ferry, drove to my destination, started work on the Monday. No Visa, no immigration requirements, just moving house. It was easy. It was becoming normal, it was like moving from one UK town to another. But all those benefits are gone now, to satisfy a set of people who think we'll be better off as a tiny island in the Atlantic, going it alone, because it was fine when they were young. What could possibly go wrong?

maddyone Sun 08-Aug-21 11:47:43

Alegrias1

^Who has led Europe in Covid Vaccinations, Ummmmm Ummmmm of course the UK, silly me I forgot!!.^

Who has the biggest share of their country fully vaccinated? Malta, Belgium, Spain, Portugal, Denmark. Triumphalism isn't nice, especially when its misplaced.

Slightly off topic, but since we had a head start on the vaccination programme, I’m wondering why were now falling behind. One reason could be that we have far more people to vaccinate than places such as Malta, which has a tiny population. Another reason could be the amount of vaccine hesitancy in this country. There seems to be rather a lot of it, but I’ve no idea just how much.

GolferGrandma Sun 08-Aug-21 11:53:02

Not a reference to the original post, however I understood English is the language used in any air related services, air traffic control, etc. so all pilots would need to understand and speak it.

NotSpaghetti Sun 08-Aug-21 11:57:55

Alegrias1

^Who has led Europe in Covid Vaccinations, Ummmmm Ummmmm of course the UK, silly me I forgot!!.^

Who has the biggest share of their country fully vaccinated? Malta, Belgium, Spain, Portugal, Denmark. Triumphalism isn't nice, especially when its misplaced.

I was just trying to remember where I'd seen this.
Thank you!

janipans Sun 08-Aug-21 12:18:36

I'm confused - We have left the "European Union" but we haven't left the continent of Europe, so the need for European qualifications mentioned in a previous post should still be ok, shouldn't it?

Razzy Sun 08-Aug-21 12:22:06

I haven’t read all the replies but there’s a lot more to all this if you give the whole view. Due to far less EU staff coming to work in UK, wages in UK are rising and there are lots of jobs in hospitality/ tourism in UK. The West Country for example has seen a massive influx of tourists this summer. For pilots, it is a political issue yes. The UK CAA stated that UK based airlines could employ crew with EASA licences. The reverse is not true. However, that is to protect the UK pilots as most have UK EASA licences which need converting to UK CAA. 2 years post-Brexit that can change and the UK can say all UK based airlines must employ UK qualified crew. Airlines like Ryanair use all sorts of unsavoury practices with employing pilots. The UK CAA now has the opportunity to stamp some of this out, as other countries have. Pilots will need to have right to work in UK also. For decades pilots have transferred to other jurisdictions licences, whether working for Cathay in Hong Kong, China Airlines or Swiss.
BALPA is campaigning for an even playing field for transferring licences. Those who hold UK issued EASA licences can no longer get a valid EU issued EASA licence, even if they have 10,000 hours of airline flying. The only reason to stop it is politics, not safety.

Newatthis Sun 08-Aug-21 12:33:47

There is a huge problem in the UK with many companies in the leisure industry not being able to find staff because young people from the EU can no longer work in the UK. However, I cannot help thinking that it hasn't stopped teenagers from other non EU countries (e.g. USA) coming to work in the UK in the past so I think there is always a way. I have a friend who lives in France and her son went there post Brexit and is now working in France.

growstuff Sun 08-Aug-21 12:36:51

sundowngirl

I worked in France,Germany and Switzerland in the late 60s before we even joined the EU or the common market as it was then, without a problem. If our youngsters want to work abroad they will, I wouldn’t call it that their dreams are being dashed!

I worked in the EU in the early 1970s and I still remember all the paperwork involved. Why make something more difficult for no gain?

Yammy Sun 08-Aug-21 12:42:02

JaneJudge

My kids don't think they are entitled hmm what a really nasty thing to post.

One of my sons took two languages at school and did exchange trips, I don't think it would be as useful as a year abroad with Erasmus , though obviously not all youngsters go to university anyway.

Do you mean Erasmus the theologian or Erasmus the very cunning and canny South African Rugby coach? The outcome would be very different depending on which.

growstuff Sun 08-Aug-21 12:42:14

maddyone

Alegrias1

Who has led Europe in Covid Vaccinations, Ummmmm Ummmmm of course the UK, silly me I forgot!!.

Who has the biggest share of their country fully vaccinated? Malta, Belgium, Spain, Portugal, Denmark. Triumphalism isn't nice, especially when its misplaced.

Slightly off topic, but since we had a head start on the vaccination programme, I’m wondering why were now falling behind. One reason could be that we have far more people to vaccinate than places such as Malta, which has a tiny population. Another reason could be the amount of vaccine hesitancy in this country. There seems to be rather a lot of it, but I’ve no idea just how much.

Another reason could be that the UK didn't initially order enough of the vaccines needed. There are (admittedly anecdotal) stories of younger people finding it difficult to book vaccinations in some parts of the country.

growstuff Sun 08-Aug-21 12:43:04

Yammy

JaneJudge

My kids don't think they are entitled hmm what a really nasty thing to post.

One of my sons took two languages at school and did exchange trips, I don't think it would be as useful as a year abroad with Erasmus , though obviously not all youngsters go to university anyway.

Do you mean Erasmus the theologian or Erasmus the very cunning and canny South African Rugby coach? The outcome would be very different depending on which.

Is that supposed to be a joke?

Lucca Sun 08-Aug-21 12:45:25

Theoddbird

There are opportunities in the UK. People don't have to go abroad to find work. Keep our talent in our own country I say...

Oh dear. So is everyone to just stay in their own country ? Or is it just Brits ?
Depressing.

GillT57 Sun 08-Aug-21 12:50:53

One of the main aims of Brexit was to reduce the number of migrant workers and to reduce the flow of manufacturing outside the UK to lower labour cost countries, thereby keeping more jobs at home Was it really? I have read this thread from start to finish, and applaud those of you who keep on trying to get the message across, but wilfully or otherwise, there are too many who just don't/won't understand, too many people saying that young people should just get on with it/take a job in a hotel in Blackpool and count themselves lucky/it was possible 45 years ago/why don't they pick fruit? etc., etc., At the risk of a sharp retort from predictable parties, can I just point out that no young adult entering the job market at present voted for Brexit.