Gransnet forums

News & politics

Buckingham Palace Aide resigns

(1001 Posts)
Parsley3 Wed 30-Nov-22 14:12:28

BBC News - Buckingham Palace aide resigns over remarks to black charity boss
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-63810468

Well at least the Palace took this incident seriously and didn't fob off Ms Fulani's complaint.

growstuff Thu 01-Dec-22 19:01:28

Urmstongran

^If one of my neighbours started going on about my grandson's ethnic origins, rather than chatting about how the old man up the street is doing, the pot hole in the road or the noise from the pub, I would think they were cracked^

I get that, totally GagaJo and yet I think the setting here adds substance because this lady wanted to stand out and be noticed and different because she was wearing an outfit that reflected her ethnicity. It wasn’t as though she was in jeans and tee-shirt or a dress from FatFace. She was promoting herself in a completely unusual attire. Good for her, no problem with that at all but don’t be surprised lady if your unusual attire, not something seen on the High Street, arouses curiosity.

She can’t have it both ways. Lady Hussey was insensitive by persisting but she probably wanted to get to the bottom of the origins of the costume. Tactless, sure. Racist? No way.

How do you know what she wanted? Fact - you don't!

eazybee Thu 01-Dec-22 19:03:14

I have answered my own question.
To sum up: it's not illegal to record a call or even collect data. It is illegal, however, to publicise or share such data with third parties without consent.

GagaJo Thu 01-Dec-22 19:03:53

One would think, Urm, that they would be very well versed in what is and isn't acceptable to discuss. There must be a list of do not discuss topics.

Nice, easy openers. Uncontroversial. No one for example, would go up to a gender neutral (to introduce yet another GN hot topic) and say, 'So what gender are you?'.

A 5 year old might. But not a very experienced, well trained individual.

Lucca Thu 01-Dec-22 19:12:32

MerylStreep

growstuff

Anniebach

Megan Markle also said they were married 3 days before their
wedding

What the hell does that have to do with this?

Meghan Merkel tells porkies.

Let’s not drag out all those Meghan tell lies comments we’ve heard so many times. Irrelevant

Lucca Thu 01-Dec-22 19:13:25

eazybee

I have answered my own question.
To sum up: it's not illegal to record a call or even collect data. It is illegal, however, to publicise or share such data with third parties without consent.

Do we know the wire wearing for fact ?

Urmstongran Thu 01-Dec-22 19:13:56

Ah well, we agree to disagree on this GagaJo. No matter.
Probably as well she’s stepped down though (or been pushed to). At 83y she was tactless. My 90y old stepfather says “that coloured chap down the road”. Not “the guy with the red car at 28”. He actually thinks ‘coloured’ is a polite term. It was in the day because other less nice words were used in the 60’s. . We gently try to remind him it’s not PC now .. to no avail.

vegansrock Thu 01-Dec-22 19:15:57

If Hussey wanted to get to know about the origins of the costume she could have asked about it surely?

Urmstongran Thu 01-Dec-22 19:20:02

A lady at my book club is in her mid 70’s. She used to be a Head Teacher. Or Headmistress as it was back in the day. During the course of discussion about topics around race (the book) she said that children were termed ‘half-caste’ and back then it was a perfectly accepted term around the meeting table amongst staff. Now of course it’s ‘mixed-race’ that’s the acceptable term (unless it’s changed again?) and we do have to moderate speech to keep up. What was allowed amongst professionals is no longer the case. The wheel turns and the language with it. I just think some old people don’t keep up.

welbeck Thu 01-Dec-22 19:24:04

it's not
completely unusual attire, not seen on the high street;
it is quite unremarkable in hackney, where Ngozi said sistah space was based.

Urmstongran Thu 01-Dec-22 19:29:14

Well every day is a school day on GN thank you welbeck.
I’ve never seen similar round our way.

DaisyAnne Thu 01-Dec-22 19:29:18

volver

^She seemed to be deliberately forcing Lady Susan to ask further questions ^

Here's another shark!!

How do you become so arrogant that you believe everyone with a different opinion to yours, about something none of us attended, nor do we actually know about other than the biased opinions offered on the internet and on front pages, is wrong while you are right?

Oreo Thu 01-Dec-22 19:29:39

Lotsa things are unremarkable in Hackney.

Oreo Thu 01-Dec-22 19:30:55

DaisyAnne

volver

She seemed to be deliberately forcing Lady Susan to ask further questions

Here's another shark!!

How do you become so arrogant that you believe everyone with a different opinion to yours, about something none of us attended, nor do we actually know about other than the biased opinions offered on the internet and on front pages, is wrong while you are right?

A very good question😄

welbeck Thu 01-Dec-22 19:31:48

that term was never acceptable to dual heritage people or to people of colour generally.
and those so called professionals would have found that out in the 1960s if they had bothered to ask the people whom they were denigrating by describing them as items from a foundry.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Dec-22 19:35:20

I lived in Hackney for 7 years my next door was Hackney Town Hall, I went to Primary School there, passed my 11+ started my senior education at the Grammar School, have school friends that still live there.

Urmstongran Thu 01-Dec-22 19:37:53

Is “dual heritage people” now the new term for “mixed race”.
If it is, I haven’t kept up either.

This ex Head was in meetings with other professionals from across the education system. She told me that’s just how it was then. Nobody challenged it during discussions.

Language evolves to match sensibilities I suppose.

growstuff Thu 01-Dec-22 19:41:03

twitter.com/HertsSid/status/1597950668731731969

Iam64 Thu 01-Dec-22 19:42:40

Language does evolve. I was corrected 12 years ago after describing a 13 year old as mixed race. I was told to use dual heritage. I did though her heritage was more mixed than dual - white c=British/Irish/Scottish/North African/Indian and more.

Language matters. No One would use cretin or lunatic these days though these terms were used in our lifetime.

volver Thu 01-Dec-22 19:42:59

DaisyAnne

volver

She seemed to be deliberately forcing Lady Susan to ask further questions

Here's another shark!!

How do you become so arrogant that you believe everyone with a different opinion to yours, about something none of us attended, nor do we actually know about other than the biased opinions offered on the internet and on front pages, is wrong while you are right?

Why do you think that everything I post is telling someone else they are wrong and I'm right?

I may be the only one who sees the absurdity in claiming that Fulani was "forcing" Hussey to do anything. Doubt that I am though.

growstuff Thu 01-Dec-22 19:43:11

vegansrock

If Hussey wanted to get to know about the origins of the costume she could have asked about it surely?

Possibly Primark.

It's a pinafore dress with animal print - nothing like any traditional African dress.

growstuff Thu 01-Dec-22 19:44:17

volver

DaisyAnne

volver

She seemed to be deliberately forcing Lady Susan to ask further questions

Here's another shark!!

How do you become so arrogant that you believe everyone with a different opinion to yours, about something none of us attended, nor do we actually know about other than the biased opinions offered on the internet and on front pages, is wrong while you are right?

Why do you think that everything I post is telling someone else they are wrong and I'm right?

I may be the only one who sees the absurdity in claiming that Fulani was "forcing" Hussey to do anything. Doubt that I am though.

No, you're not the only one.

It's really quite concerning that people don't even recognise casual racism in themselves (but I'm not surprised).

volver Thu 01-Dec-22 19:46:18

Possibly Primark.

🤣

Now that's good.

Urmstongran Thu 01-Dec-22 19:46:27

Did you see similar ethnic clothes on your High Street GG13?

NanKate Thu 01-Dec-22 19:50:02

I was told off by my boss once in the cafe of the adult education centre I was working at, for offering a student ‘black or white coffee’ instead of with out without milk. Totally barmy in my opinion.

I had many students over the years of a variety of colours and nationalities, I never had any problem with them or them with me.

welbeck Thu 01-Dec-22 19:50:12

i'm not sure on mixed race as a term. think it's ok.
i cannot imagine ever having to use such a term; why, in what context would anyone need to ?
but it's clear when terms are offensive.
i don't think changes are so much about language and sensibilities, but more to do with power.
people will no longer tolerate being insulted.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion