Gransnet forums

News & politics

How can Sunak stop "illegal" entry for asylum seekers if there is no "legal" way.

(69 Posts)
DaisyAnne Tue 13-Dec-22 13:47:27

Lots of noise from Sunak.

"Illegal immigration" is neither a legal term nor an accepted definition except within the Conservative and other far-right parties. It is second on the Conservative voters' list so it's second on Sunak's list - whether he believes in what he says or not.

So, no way, as far as I am aware, to legally apply for UK asylum outside the UK. Therefore, people have to come to the UK to make their application.

Now Sunak is saying they will send asylum seekers to countries which have more applicants to process than we do. Seeing how well this government can negotiate with other countries, I don't hold out any real hope that these countries will agree.

The only possible way to fairly consider claims is for the government to realise that maladministration - in all areas not just refugees - is their biggest problem. But of course, administrators low and high, are just there to be bullied by the Conservative MPs.

Yet again, we get a lot of rhetoric (remember Rwanda?) with not a hope in hell of it improving things for us as the host country or the people concerned.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 14-Dec-22 07:36:03

And they have successfully diverted attention away from the official government report about how much the Tories have trashed the NHS.

The migrant issue has been so good for the Tories. It keeps the sheep nicely in line.

nanna8 Wed 14-Dec-22 07:38:19

Used to be gypsies, there’s always someone. I guess the Russians will be next.

Oreo Wed 14-Dec-22 07:42:48

Lazy thinking of you Petera
Albania is very much in the news and Albanians make up 30% of people arriving here in small boats.Germany has already closed the loophole by saying that Albania is a safe country, which it is, and denying asylum to anyone from there.
Am all for genuine asylum seekers from war torn or otherwise terrible situations being given a sympathetic hearing but the thousands of economic migrants are putting a strain on the system.
The only thing I agree with the OP on is wondering if this government can handle things since they’ve made a pigs ear of so much else.

Oreo Wed 14-Dec-22 07:44:48

nanna8

Used to be gypsies, there’s always someone. I guess the Russians will be next.

What the hell?!
So you think the Russians are good guys? One good thing we have done lately in Britain is to stand strongly by Ukraine.
Get a grip.

Petera Wed 14-Dec-22 07:51:26

Oreo

nanna8

Used to be gypsies, there’s always someone. I guess the Russians will be next.

What the hell?!
So you think the Russians are good guys? One good thing we have done lately in Britain is to stand strongly by Ukraine.
Get a grip.

Lazy thinking of you Oreo

Russia is a country currently involved in war of its government's making. Russian citizens are being conscripted to fight in this war often against their will. For many Russians, Russia is not a safe country.
Get a grip.

growstuff Wed 14-Dec-22 08:02:56

biglouis

*Why is it acceptable for billions of money earned through taxpayers of this country to be spent on migrants who arrive having contributed nothing. Housed in hotels, 3 meals day which they complain about, free to roam around the towns and cities that they’re deposited in, nobody asked for them to be there. Meanwhile, the taxpayers are working supporting this*

Agree 100%. We need a harsh system like that of Australia whereby anyone who arrived via an illegal route will never be allowed to settle here. These people should stay in their own country to work or fight for better conditions.

But it's not illegal to cross the Channel by boat, nor is it illegal to apply for asylum.

Oreo Wed 14-Dec-22 08:07:09

My grip is just fine thanks.
For many Russians Putin is like a god they love him to bits.
Sure, some citizens are starting to doubt the war not that it will do them any good.That’s only because the war isn’t going all that well for Russia.If it was then they would love Putin even more.
Look what the soldiers including conscripts have done in Ukraine, torturing killing and raping and looting.They didn’t need to do that to men women and children in towns and villages, they wanted to do it.

Forsythia Wed 14-Dec-22 09:26:00

growstuff

By the way Forsythia you're not unusual in being a taxpayer. Every single person in the UK who buys anything or uses any service is a taxpayer.

I’m not unusual no. But like so many others I question how my hard earned money is spent. If you agree with it then that is your prerogative. I disagree with it and resent it. That money could be better spent on British people who are struggling.

Meanwhile, Ashford Hospital in Kent has been told to clear its A&E department to admit those whose boat has sunk in the channel overnight. Shame for the poor Kent residents who rely on this hospital to have their needs pushed to one side. Or perhaps you think that is acceptable? Ambulance crews have been diverted to the coast to attend to the migrants who made the journey. Don’t call an ambulance in Ashford this morning then. Your needs are not priority.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 14-Dec-22 09:31:57

Much more of your hard earned money has gone into lining the pockets of the corrupt Tories, buying them yachts and property than has gone to helping those seeking refuge from war, torture and starvation.

growstuff Wed 14-Dec-22 09:37:08

Forsythia

growstuff

By the way Forsythia you're not unusual in being a taxpayer. Every single person in the UK who buys anything or uses any service is a taxpayer.

I’m not unusual no. But like so many others I question how my hard earned money is spent. If you agree with it then that is your prerogative. I disagree with it and resent it. That money could be better spent on British people who are struggling.

Meanwhile, Ashford Hospital in Kent has been told to clear its A&E department to admit those whose boat has sunk in the channel overnight. Shame for the poor Kent residents who rely on this hospital to have their needs pushed to one side. Or perhaps you think that is acceptable? Ambulance crews have been diverted to the coast to attend to the migrants who made the journey. Don’t call an ambulance in Ashford this morning then. Your needs are not priority.

I didn't write anywhere whether I agree or disagree. You seem to be an angry person, if you have to make things up about people.

growstuff Wed 14-Dec-22 09:38:46

Whitewavemark2

Much more of your hard earned money has gone into lining the pockets of the corrupt Tories, buying them yachts and property than has gone to helping those seeking refuge from war, torture and starvation.

I wonder if the LadyM is available to ferry a few refugees! It would certainly be more comfortable and safer than a dinghy. hmm

Whitewavemark2 Wed 14-Dec-22 10:08:59

Nah - they are the little people - not worth consideration.

DaisyAnne Wed 14-Dec-22 10:51:28

You have a very illogical view of the challenges we face Forsythia and of other people's views.

You appear (and do correct me if I am wrong) to the believe the government have not gone far enough but are going in the right direction to solve what you see as the issue.

You seem to lay all the problems on to your chosen group, so called illegal migrants (although there is not such thing).

You also seem to think that if other posters do not want the unfounded ideas you hold then they do not want to solve the problem.

Don't you think it worth finding out a few more of the facts and the reality of the issue before attacking other posters. Attacking the politics of a party is one thing but why the personal attacks? I do wonder where you are getting your information from.

Wheniwasyourage Wed 14-Dec-22 13:41:47

Oreo

Lazy thinking of you Petera
Albania is very much in the news and Albanians make up 30% of people arriving here in small boats.Germany has already closed the loophole by saying that Albania is a safe country, which it is, and denying asylum to anyone from there.
Am all for genuine asylum seekers from war torn or otherwise terrible situations being given a sympathetic hearing but the thousands of economic migrants are putting a strain on the system.
The only thing I agree with the OP on is wondering if this government can handle things since they’ve made a pigs ear of so much else.

If it was possible to process asylum claims in Albania, Oreo, they wouldn't feel the need to come here in small boats, would they? And the traffickers would have fewer customers. Just part of the pig's ear, about which I agree with you!

Forsythia Wed 14-Dec-22 14:25:27

DaisyAnne

You have a very illogical view of the challenges we face Forsythia and of other people's views.

You appear (and do correct me if I am wrong) to the believe the government have not gone far enough but are going in the right direction to solve what you see as the issue.

You seem to lay all the problems on to your chosen group, so called illegal migrants (although there is not such thing).

You also seem to think that if other posters do not want the unfounded ideas you hold then they do not want to solve the problem.

Don't you think it worth finding out a few more of the facts and the reality of the issue before attacking other posters. Attacking the politics of a party is one thing but why the personal attacks? I do wonder where you are getting your information from.

Lovely of you to be so concerned about me DaisyAnne. I don’t believe I’ve attacked any poster who disagrees with my views but do show me an example, if you can. What I will do is retaliate if a poster attacks me in person, as you did yesterday. I think that’s only fair, don’t you?

My information as you call it is on all TV channels and newspapers and I do tend to believe them rather than the views of Gransnet members who are sympathetic towards all migrants, genuine or otherwise. Of course, migration is a huge growth sector and many people have jobs supporting migrants whether it be social workers, legal aid lawyers, refugee charities, hotel owners in rundown areas, all of which may well influence views because without those migrants the gravy train would stop. They’d lose their jobs, the hotels would lose their clients, the lawyers would have to find other avenues of revenue, the charities might cease to operate and no longer receive funding.

All facts that may be worth consideration. But I guess I’m wrong about that too.

Grateful for your concern though. Rest assured I live a full happy and productive life.

MaizieD Wed 14-Dec-22 14:41:33

Grateful for your concern though. Rest assured I live a full happy and productive life.

And have some unpleasant opinions about 'gravy trains'.

MerylStreep Wed 14-Dec-22 15:05:28

nanna8
In Albania there’s a prime time tv show ridiculing gypsies. It’s very popular. BTW, read up on the Russian invasion of a sovereign country: Ukraine.

DaisyAnne Wed 14-Dec-22 16:15:47

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.